Is "The tragedy of Hamlet is the tragedy of irresolution and inaction" a fair assessment of Hamlet?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I would argue that Hamlet is actually resolute in his inaction. As soon as Hamlet decides to believe the Ghost's claims that Claudius murdered him (King Hamlet), Hamlet is bent on revenge for his father's death. He wants to find the perfect opportunity to murder Claudius and doesn't rush to action; instead, he carefully crafts his plans.

Hamlet takes action when he decides to stage the play within the play. He carefully crafts the plot so that he can analyze Claudius's reaction and finalize his plans in dealing with him. When Claudius reacts just as Hamlet expects and with a seemingly guilty conscience, Hamlet again chooses not to kill him when he finds Claudius praying. According to his beliefs, killing a man in the midst of prayer sends him directly to Heaven, and he certainly doesn't want to reward Claudius in the afterlife for his crimes against Hamlet's father (his own brother). Hamlet's choice to wait here shows his resolute will to properly avenge his father's death.

Hamlet also takes action by creating a fake persona of madness to throw everyone off track. He plays with words, toys with Ophelia's emotions, and even engages in a passionate argument with his mother that leaves everyone questioning his mental stability. In great part, these displays seem to be a calculated effort on Hamlet's part to create the space he needs to further his plans for Claudius without coming under too much suspicion.

In act 5, scene 2, Hamlet discovers a sinister plot against his own life:

My sea-gown scarfed about me, in the dark
Groped I to find out them, had my desire,
Fingered their packet, and in fine withdrew
To mine own room again, making so bold
(My fears forgetting manners) to unseal
Their grand commission, where I found, Horatio
O royal knavery!—an exact command,
Larded with many several sorts of reasons
Importing Denmark’s health, and England’s too,
With—ho!—such bugs and goblins in my life
That, on the supervise (no leisure bated,
No, not to stay the grinding of the ax)
My head should be struck off. (5.2.14–26)

Hamlet's reaction here isn't inaction; instead, he quickly puts a new plan into motion. He switches this letter with a new one that he composes instructing the king of England to kill Rosencrantz and Guildenstern (the bearers of the letter, spies working with Polonius and Claudius against Hamlet) instead.

Although Hamlet delays his plans to kill Claudius, that in itself isn't a tragedy. In fact, his desire to ensure his plan is successful shows resolute strength as he sets small pieces of his plan in motion over several acts.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In all fairness, I believe Hamlet was being cautious in his judgment of whether or not his Uncle Claudius killed his father or not. It is wise to not make assumptions, especially in a case such as this. To accuse someone of murder is quite serious. It should not be done so lightly.

While some critics may argue that Hamlet was inactive, I would say he was making sure his questions were answered with sufficient eveidence. That is why he reenacted his father's murderous scene. He was searching for signs of guilt from his Uncle Cladius.

Tragically, during his effecient search for evidence of his father's murderer, Hamlet's Uncle Claudius becomes aware that Hamlet suspects him as the murderer. By this point, Claudius is making plans to have Hamlet killed as well.

If there is a weakness or tragic flaw in Hamlet's character, it would be that he wanted to be certain his father's murderer. I believe this is a a good quality that cost Hamlet his life.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Shakespeare expressed Hamlet's problem best in Macbeth:

Words to the heat of deeds too cold breath gives.

While Hamlet can be blamed for his inability to dedicate himself fully to the task that has been given to him by the Ghost of his father, Hamlet's real problem is that he thinks too much. He is so given over to thought that and planning things this way and that and deciding and then second guessing himself, that he just can't get himself to finally act until he absolutely has to.

It's been said that many procrastinators are simply perfections who can't start until they get it all worked out in their minds first. That's Hamlet.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial