Analysis

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on August 20, 2020, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 1080

As a historian, Macdonald is concerned throughout H Is for Hawk with the intersections of natural and social histories in the English landscape. “Wildness,” Macdonald argues, does not exist in a vacuum but is in part a product of human ideas and human interaction with the land. She frequently meditates upon the ways in which England’s landscape has been historically employed to promote myths of national “blood-belonging” and to maintain class distinctions. Falconry, she suggests, plays a role in these social and political projects, and she often thinks about her own place in its history. Today, falconers like Macdonald can disrupt some of these damaging narratives, paving the way for a more informed and inclusive approach to interacting with the natural world that doesn’t overlook the complex histories of England’s landscapes.

Illustration of PDF document

Download H Is for Hawk Study Guide

Subscribe Now

For centuries, falconry remained an exclusive pursuit of the English landed classes; its practice communicated ideas about the superiority of the aristocracy as well as of England and Englishness. These cultural ideas reinforced the nationalist and colonialist sensibilities of the British Empire, and during World War II, falconry featured in propaganda that drew on the imagery of a romanticized medieval period in order to promote the idea of an innate and essentially English sense of chivalry and honor. Macdonald also notes with horror that the Nazis employed hawks and falcons—associated with inherent power and strength—to symbolize Aryan dominance, and naturalize the violence of invasion and conquest, in the propaganda of the Third Reich. Thus the history of falconry and the relationship of birds of prey to their habitats is both a natural and a manmade history. The book suggests that to understand one, we must understand the other, acknowledging the ways in which these histories are inseparable.

Describing the way she learned about English falconry as a child, Macdonald writes:

What I was doing wasn’t just educating myself in the nuts and bolts of hawk-training: I was unconsciously soaking up the assumptions of an imperial elite. I lived in a world where English peregrines always outflew foreign hawks, whose landscapes were grouse moors and manor houses, where women didn’t exist. These men were kindred spirits. I felt I was one of them, one of the elect.

Macdonald is a woman from a working-class background, but the falconry books she read in childhood taught her the ideals of a male ruling class, imparting a sense of English nationalism that privileged the white, landed aristocracy. As a historian, Macdonald now recognizes the way the political conditions of the past influenced the development of falconry, and she hopes to divorce herself from them. Hawks and falcons are beautiful and valuable precisely because, in reality, they have nothing to do with our human ideas of power and violence.

This idea is complicated, however, because much of what naturalists understand about the wild is in some way “manmade”; it is almost impossible not to see human activity as part of the landscape. Macdonald describes deforestation through agriculture, the introduction of new animal species with colonization and trade, and the impact of hunting on various habitats over time. The wild as we understand it, she says, does not exist separately from us. Humans project their own ideas and desires onto the landscapes they see, and they also impact them physically. The landscape as humans interact with it is not a neutral space but one bound to human history, human events. By buying Mabel from a breeder, training her, and eventually letting her fly free and hunt, Macdonald illustrates this idea in action. Even though Mabel is well-trained and bonded to Macdonald, she is still a wild creature, who hunts and kills with acute skill. Her survival,...

(The entire section contains 1080 words.)

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this H Is for Hawk study guide. You'll get access to all of the H Is for Hawk content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

  • Summary
  • Chapter Summaries
  • Themes
  • Characters
  • Analysis
  • Quotes
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial
Previous

Characters

Next

Quotes

Explore Study Guides