Discussion Topic
Point of view and theme in "A Coward" by Guy de Maupassant
Summary:
"A Coward" by Guy de Maupassant is narrated from a third-person limited point of view, focused on the protagonist, Viscount Gontran-Joseph de Signoles. The main theme is the conflict between societal expectations of bravery and personal fear, illustrating how societal pressure can lead to tragic consequences.
What is the theme of "A Coward" by Guy de Maupassant?
Maupassant's "A Coward" tells the story of a man (Viscount Gontran-Joseph de Signoles) who challenges another (Georges Lamil) to a duel, becomes anxious and afraid in the days leading up to the duel, and finally kills himself with his gun rather than face the ignominy of possibly fainting at the duel.
The main theme of the story is the theme of social expectations, and specifically the expectations that society (in this case a nineteenth-century society) has of men. In the story the Viscount is acutely aware that, as a man, he is expected to be chivalrous, honorable, and brave. Accordingly, when he sees that one of the ladies he has invited out for ices is becoming upset because another man is staring at her, he promptly does what he thinks he is supposed to do, and, in the name of chivalry, challenges the man to a duel. Having done this, he reflects, and decides that:
He had done what he was compelled to do; he had shown himself to be what he ought to be. People would talk of it, would approve of him, congratulate him.
The key words and phrases in this quotation are "compelled," "what he ought to be" and "People . . . would approve." The Viscount's decision to act chivalrously and challenge the other man to a duel, is clearly not borne out of anything other than the pressure to live up to social standards of masculinity.
After this moment it becomes clear that the Viscount is nervous, and increasingly afraid of the duel ahead. He drinks "three glasses of water one after the other," and hopes that his adversary will "retire and apologize." He then starts to imagine what might happen at the duel, if his fear continues to escalate, and his first thoughts are not for his own self-preservation, but for the social embarrassment that he will inevitably suffer if he faints. He thinks of:
the disgrace, of the whispers at the club, of the laughter in drawing-rooms, of the contempt of women, of the allusions in the papers, of the insults which cowards would fling at him.
The Viscount's decision to challenge Lamil to a duel, his fear of possible social embarrassment, and also his decision at the end of the story to commit suicide rather than risk social embarrassment, all point to the fact that the expectations he was expected to live up to, as a man, were both irrational and debilitating. Those expectations started a domino effect, beginning with a woman who took offense at the way a man was looking at her, and ending with another man thrusting the barrel of his pistol into his mouth, and pulling the trigger.
Guy de Maupassant's short story "A Coward" deals first and foremost with the theme of egocentricity vs reality.
The main character, Vicomte Gontran-Joseph de Signoles, is a foundling who came upon great fortune once he is adopted by a powerful family. As an adult, the young Vicomte becomes the epitome of the French dandy: Good looking, well-spoken, charming, seemingly virile, and quite admired. He is so admired that his nickname is "Handsome Signole" among his cronies.
As it is to be expected, all this validation of his beauty and charms has gone straight to the Vicomte's head. Now, with the support of so many admirers, the Vicomte has come up with his own version of himself: In his world, he is the best guy on earth; a version of a musketeer. He has been put on a mission, he believes, to become the ultimate charmer.
However, Handsome Signole's ego becomes so big that he begins to believe in every attribute everyone has ever given him. He is sure that he could take anyone in a duel and win. In fact, he was hoping for the opportunity.
One night, his opportunity materialized: Signole scolded a man who was staring and one of Signole's female friends during a night soiree. The man warns Signole to leave him alone. Signole refuses, and slaps the man in the face. As a result, Signole demands that a duel should occur to satisfy the honor of the lady and his own dignity as a man who has been insulted.
Yet, reality sinks in. It is not the same thing to plan something as it is to do something. When Signole, for the first time, had to retrieve strength from the REAL man he is, he realizes that there is no strength to be found. He is scared. He is a coward. He has lived too long under a fantasy that he is this or that...but he is far from it.
In the end, he shoots himself in a panic, not knowing what would come out of the duel. If he loses, his ego would have been hurt forever (not to mention that he will likely be dead). And the chances for winning? Not very many, from what he can confess to himself.
Therefore. There is the coward: The man whose self-love and egotism blinded him to the fact that he has weaknesses too, that he is a regular man, and that he also can die, be scared, and back out of things. Egocentricity vs. Reality: That is the central theme of the story.
What is the point of view in "A Coward" by Guy de Maupassant?
The point of view in Maupassant's story "The Coward" is that of Viscount Gontran-Joseph de Signoles. In fact this man is by himself throughout most of the story after he challenges a total stranger whose name is Georges Lamil to a duel. Maupassant describes in detail what is going on in Signoles' mind while he is alone. This is presented not as stream of consciousness but as interior monologue. For example, Signoles examines the card he received in exchange for his at the restaurant where the incident began.
He examined the grouped letters; they seemed to him mysterious, full of confused meaning. Georges Lamil? Who was this man? What did he do? Why had he looked at the woman in that way? Was it not revolting that a stranger, an unknown man, could thus disturb a man's life, without warning, just because he chose to fix his insolent eyes upon a woman?
Signoles gradually loses his nerve as he thinks about the various aspects of the upcoming duel. Maupassant describes not only the viewpoint character's thoughts but also his physical sensations. After Signoles has a meeting with his seconds and has formalized the arrangements for the duel, his condition becomes worse.
His agitation, momentarily quietened, was now growing minute by minute. He felt a strange shivering, a ceaseless vibration, down his arms, down his legs, in his chest; he could not keep still in one place, neither seated nor standing. There was not the least moistening of saliva in his mouth, and at every instant he made a violent movement of his tongue, as though to prevent it sticking to his palate.
The protagonist is in an impossible situation. He feels incapable of going through with the duel to which he has committed himself, while at the same time he cannot think of a way out of it, and he dreads the disgrace that will ensue if he fails to appear. As an experiment he takes one of his own dueling pistols out of its case and practices raising it and taking aim at an imaginary opponent. He finds that he cannot even hold the pistol steady while he is alone and not facing danger. It is obvious that he will be a wretched spectacle when he is facing a real rather than an imaginary adversary. Finally, he can tolerate the pain of his own cowardice no longer. Having discovered that the dueling pistol had been left loaded, he opened his mouth wide and
...thrust in the barrel of his pistol with savage gesture until it reached his throat, and pressed on the trigger.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.