Illustration of Pip visiting a graveyard

Great Expectations

by Charles Dickens

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Great Expectations as a Bildungsroman and Entwicklungsroman

Summary:

Great Expectations by Charles Dickens is a quintessential bildungsroman, or coming-of-age novel, focusing on Pip's journey from a naive orphan to a mature adult. The story chronicles Pip's intellectual, psychological, and moral development as he navigates social class and personal relationships. Throughout the novel, Pip experiences significant growth, learning humility, self-reliance, and authenticity. The novel exemplifies the bildungsroman genre by depicting Pip's transformation, underscoring the challenges and setbacks that shape his character and maturity.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why is Great Expectations a bildungsroman novel?

A bildungsroman is often called a coming-of-age novel because it is usually a story about the mental and moral growth of a young person into adulthood. Great Expectations is definitely a bildungsroman because it is mainly concerned about the experiences that form Pip's character until he is twenty-three. The novel begins when he is ten years old and meets the escaped convict in the churchyard. The climax is in Chapter XXXIX when Pip is twenty-three years old and meets that same convict again. During these thirteen years, Pip has become a London gentleman. There has been some improvement in his character because he has worked assiduously to educate himself. An illiterate working boy in Chapter I, Pip now he has the manners of a gentleman. His early years as the foster son of an honest working man give him a moral foundation unknown to the typical London gentleman. Pip is...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

the narrator of the entire novel, and it is credible he has the ability to write a novel likeGreat Expectations and that his extensive reading gave him taste, values, and understanding. Unfortunately, Pip's acquired understanding and sensitivity make him realize that, like many gentlemen and ladies, he has also become a fop and a parasite. He didn't mind that so much when he thought Miss Havisham was his secret patron and that he would be able to marry Estelle, but his world collapses when he finds out his patron was Abel Magwitch, the escaped convict, who supported Pip and now feels he owns him. Pip has not become a true gentleman, just Magwitch's idea of a gentleman. This discovery is part of the bildungsroman. Pip's decision to stay with Magwitch and help him escape from England is the culmination of his coming of age. In the end, Pip achieves maturity, humility, self-reliance, and an understanding of himself and humanity. One of the important things Pip finally comes to understand is that fine gentlemen and ladies are sustained by the humble working men and women of this world.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Discuss Great Expectations as a classic "bildungsroman".

Much like the monologue of the melancholy Jacques from Shakespeare's As You Like It, known as "The Seven Ages of Man," Great Expectations chronicles in prose, rather than poetry, the three stages of Pip from somewhat lonely and naive orphan who is made aware that he is a "common, a mere labouring-boy," who forms a link to his life on a single, memorable day of "great expectations" to a young gentleman now recklessly foolish, rejecting his old friend--

All other swindlers upon earth are nothing to the self-swindlers, and with such pretenses did I cheat myself.

--to that of a man who has reached a maturity of soul, having weathered failure and loss of friendships, loss of love, and loss of friends in a final stage of rebirth and re-creation.  Pip apologizes to his friends Joe and Biddy, and returns to the warmth of the forge.  Joe marries Biddy, and Pip visits.  Then, he meets with Estella, closing relationship with her. In the final stage, Pip comes full circle and learns that he has left his home in search of illusionary "great expectations" when the best values in life have always been there on the forge.  Pip writes to Biddy,

"My dear Biddy, I have forgotten nothing in my life that ever had a foremost place there and little that ever had any place there.  But that poor dream, a I once used to call it, has all gone by ,Biddy, all gone by!"  

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Consider that basically, a bildungsroman is a coming-of-age novel.  Growth and development of the main character in such a novel is often focused on the major life lessons the character learns, and how he or she changes as a result.  Whether formal or not, this type of novel focuses on the education of the main character.

Great Expectations follows its main character, Pip, from the time he is a poor 7 year old boy in a small English village, until he has grown into a young man with a mysterious benefactor funding his becoming a "gentleman" in the city of London, until finally, through different trials and hardships, he returns once again to his village.

We watch as Pip is educated in the way of social acceptance into a world that has expendable funds.  At the same time, he is conflicted over feelings for a girl from his childhood.  While he never fully loses himself or his roots, when a visit from Joe brings him shame he realizes that the man he is becoming is not the boy he once was.  He is taken on a series of life adventures, some which eventually lead him to his benefactor, others which enable him to becomes a businessman.

By the end of the novel, Pip comes full circle, returning to his village once again equal to those who live there.  Through everything, he learns who loves him most in life, and decides to to be devoted to those relationships which have always been devoted to him.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

You have identified a vital element in this novel. It is clearly a bildungsroman, just like Jane Eyre and other similar novels, in that it traces the development of a main character from their youth and to their maturity. At the end of bildungsromans, the characters have normally gone through some hard times but have found their place in society and end up a maturer, wiser individual because of what they have suffered.

Thus in analysing this novel as a bildungsroman, it is important to note how Pip changes and develops. Key to the early stages of the novel is Pip´s growing sense of class consciousness and his dissatisfaction with his own position in society. We can see that this comes through his first meeting with Miss Havisham and Estella, and how he becomes ashamed of his humble roots. The end of Chapter 9 clearly marks this event as a fundamental point of change in his life.

That was a memorable day to me, for it made great changes in me. But it is the same with any life. Imagine one selected day struck out of it, and think how different its course would hgave been. Pause you who read this, and think for a moment of the long chain of iron or gold, of thorns or flowers, that would never have bound you, but for the formation of the first link on one memorable day.

This passage is key because it introduced the notion of being "bound" - something that is developed in Ch. 13 when Pip is "bound" into his apprenticeship. This indicates how Pip sees his lowly position. It is important to note that this awareness or realisation comes before Pip receives his "Great Exepectations", and so it is likely that if Pip had not received his Great Expectations he would have lived a frustrating and sad life, consciously aware of the limitations of his position in society and unable to do anything about it. With his visit to Estella, gone is the ability to accept his fate.

Moving forward to the rest of the novel, it is key to identify the retrospective omniscient voice that narrates Pip's tale, and how it demonstrates how Pip has matured and become wiser. Certainly the wisdom that the narrator demonstrates has only come through the sufferings and trials that the younger Pip experiences - there is a definite sense that this is a novel of maturing, of change and growth in character. The incident where Pip saves Miss Havisham from being burnt and also burns himself in the process, and his loss of his "expectations" and the fever that cripples him have a sense of purgatorial repayment for the wrongs that Pip has committed - he learns just how much of a snob he has been, and how he has hurt others through his actions, and begins to right his wrongs. Thus we see at the end of the novel a sadder, but much wiser Pip, who has definitely learnt a lot through his experiences, and has found his place in society working with Herbert.

It is surely significant that at the end of the novel, Joe and Biddy call their son Pip after the main character of the novel. After reading a novel which is so much concerned about parental figures and the kind of (bad) influence they can have on their "children" (just think of Miss Havisham and Estella and Magwitch and Pip), we can only think that this naming will have a good impact, as the younger Pip now has an appropriate role model to follow in his life - one that can guide him with sensitivity and wisdom.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What are the examples of Entwicklungsroman in Great Expectations, and how does it compare to Bildungsroman?

There is very little difference between an Entwicklungsroman and a Bildungsroman. Critics are divided on whether the former is a sub-genre of the latter, or whether they are two similar types of novel with a slight difference in focus. It is uncontroversial to say, however, that a Bildungsroman is a "coming of age novel," in which a sensitive protagonist grows and learns throughout the course of the narrative. An Entwicklungsroman has less of a focus on growing up or coming of age. It is a novel of psychological development. In the vast majority of cases, the two terms will both apply to the same book, but a novel about the development of a middle-aged or elderly protagonist might be classified as an Entwicklungsroman without being a Bildungsroman. The section of Proust's novel, In Search of Lost Time, which is often excerpted as Swann in Love, would be an instance of this, with Swann himself, rather than the narrator, as protagonist.

The obvious examples of an Entwicklungsroman (and also Bildungsroman) in the works of Dickens are Great Expectations and David Copperfield. One might call A Christmas Carol an Entwicklungsroman, though Scrooge is such a flat character that it is debatable whether you can call his sudden change a development. There are many twentieth-century examples of the genre, from Rudyard Kipling's Kim in 1901, through J.D. Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye to J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter books almost 100 years later.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is a bildungsroman, and how is Great Expectations an example of one?

A bildungsroman can be defined as a novel that deals with the spiritual, intellectual, and moral growth of a protagonist. In recent decades, it has also been equated with the coming-of-age story, which deals with the often difficult transition from childhood to adulthood.

Great Expectations is a prime example of the bildungsroman genre as it charts the long process of maturation experienced by the book's central character, Pip. When we first meet Pip he's a naive young orphan boy living with his sister and her husband in a blacksmith's cottage on the windswept Romney Marshes. By the end of the book, Pip is a grown man, older, wiser, and considerably more mature than he was at the beginning. It's that bit in the middle, if you like, Pip's transition from boyhood to manhood that forms the basis of the novel and makes it a classic bildungsroman.

It should be pointed out, however, that the development of a character in the bildungsroman is not necessarily smooth; it doesn't always proceed in a rectilinear fashion. Inevitably, in any life journey there are setbacks, times when it appears that, far from making moral or spiritual progress, we're actually backsliding.

This is precisely what happens to Pip after he becomes a young man about town thanks to Magwitch's largesse. Although in one sense Pip has developed, in another sense he's regressed in that he's turned into a crashing snob who's embarrassed to see his good friend Joe Gargery when he comes to see him. Later on, Pip will see the error of his ways, and in that sense, clear moral development will be observed. But for now, Pip has taken a big step back. In feeling embarrassed to be in Joe's presence, he shows that he still has a lot of growing up to do.

Approved by eNotes Editorial