Analysis

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Gore Vidal, a towering figure in American literature, carved a niche as a formidable man of letters with his incisive narratives and complex characters. His works span historical fiction, social critique, and satirical novels, each layered with wit and a penetrating analysis of societal norms. Vidal's literary journey reflects an unyielding commitment to challenge prevailing ideologies, combining historical accuracy with imaginative storytelling to engage readers intellectually and emotionally.

Early Influences and Literary Growth

Vidal's early novels, penned before the age of thirty, grappled with young protagonists facing ethical dilemmas within historical contexts. His narrative voice evolved from the shadow of Ernest Hemingway, gaining a distinct style infused with irony and sharp wit. "The Judgment of Paris" and "Messiah" marked pivotal points in this evolution, drawing on mythological parallels to examine themes of love, power, and knowledge, with "Messiah" satirizing the distortion of religious movements.

Historical Fiction and Political Critique

Vidal's venture into historical fiction began with "Julian," a meticulous exploration of historical records that humanized historical figures. His subsequent novels like "Burr" and "Lincoln" scrutinized American foundational myths, portraying the Founding Fathers as opportunists rather than idealists. These works invite readers to reconsider entrenched narratives surrounding America's past, offering educational yet provocative insights.

Dissecting American Political Evolution

Vidal's "Narratives of Empire" series dives into the intricacies of American political and cultural life. Novels like "Empire" and "Hollywood" explore the expansion of American imperial power and media's role in shaping public perception. Vidal posits that despite its democratic ideals, the United States has pursued imperial ambitions under the guise of freedom and democracy.

Political Dynamics in Mid-20th Century America

In "Washington, D.C." and "The Golden Age," Vidal continues his critique by focusing on the power dynamics and ideological transformations during the mid-20th century. These novels illustrate the United States' emergence as a global superpower, entangled in moral and ethical quandaries, where political figures are often driven by ambition rather than democratic ideals.

Satirical and Campy Exploration of Society

Parallel to his serious historical works, Vidal's campy novels like "Myra Breckinridge" and "Live from Golgotha" employ humor and satire to critique societal norms and media influence. These novels reflect Vidal's belief in the fluidity of identity and the contrived nature of social constructs, challenging readers to question the reality constructed by media and societal expectations.

Reimagining Historical Narratives

"Julian" and "Creation" delve into the ancient world, questioning religious and philosophical foundations of Western civilization. Vidal's portrayal of Julian the Apostate contests conventional Christian narratives, suggesting alternative historical paths. Similarly, "Creation" underscores the interconnectedness of ancient cultures, challenging the notion of Western isolation from its Asian and African influences.

Vidal's Iconoclasm and Wit

Gore Vidal's work extends beyond fiction to critique contemporary society and politics, particularly the "heterosexual dictatorship" and orthodox views on sexuality. "The City and the Pillar," for example, confronted societal norms head-on, establishing Vidal as a provocative voice despite backlash. His sharp wit and intelligence ensured his work remained relevant, challenging societal norms and encouraging discourse on human sexuality.

A Lasting Literary Legacy

Vidal's expansive body of work showcases his mastery in blending historical fidelity with imaginative narratives, providing both entertainment and critical insights into culture, power, and human motivation. His novels encourage readers to reflect on American history's complexities and the tension between individual freedom and societal conformity. Vidal's influence persists, urging readers to embrace the nuanced human experience and question societal assumptions.

The City and the Pillar

Vidal's third novel, "The City and the Pillar," pushed societal boundaries on sexual tolerance, affecting his career significantly. The protagonist, an average American young man grappling with his homosexuality, defied traditional...

(This entire section contains 1337 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

depictions of homosexual characters in literature. This bold narrative choice challenged readers' perceptions and marked Vidal as a liberator in literary circles, even as it subjected him to critical and financial setbacks.

The Judgment of Paris and Messiah

Following "The City and the Pillar," Vidal's "The Judgment of Paris" and "Messiah" found later appreciation for their philosophical depth. Both novels encapsulate Vidal's worldview - the former through a comedic lens, the latter through tragedy. By retelling ancient myths, Vidal explored the human condition's complexities, emphasizing a life of adaptability and openness to change.

Julian: A Historical Examination

In "Julian," Vidal revisits religious movements, scrutinizing Christianity's development. Julian the Apostate's story challenges the prevailing narrative of his time, proposing a more tolerant and diverse religious landscape. Vidal's thoughtful construction of Julian's memoir offers multiple perspectives on historical events, questioning the West's cultural inheritance and its ongoing civilization journey.

Creation: Ancient Interconnections

"Creation" takes readers on a journey through the ancient world's cultural and philosophical evolution. Through Cyrus Spitama's eyes, Vidal explores the emergence of major world religions and their global impact, challenging Eurocentric historical narratives. This novel highlights the global interactions long predating modern globalization, connecting the West to its broader cultural roots.

Burr and American Foundational Hypocrisies

Vidal's "Burr" offers a contrarian view of America's inception, narrated by Charlie Schuyler who uncovers the opportunism behind the Founding Fathers' actions. The novel demystifies revered historical figures, aligning with contemporary historiography's critical perspectives. Vidal's portrayal of these figures reflects their self-interest, urging readers to critically assess foundational American myths.

Lincoln and 1876: Evolution of American Ideals

"Lincoln" presents a nuanced portrayal of the 16th president, revealing the transformation of the United States into a centralized republic. "1876" follows Schuyler's return to post-Civil War America, confronting the era's political corruption and disillusionment. These narratives illustrate the persistent gap between democratic ideals and political realities throughout American history.

Empire and American Expansionism

In "Empire," Vidal captures the turn of the century's cultural and political shifts, depicting figures like Theodore Roosevelt and William Randolph Hearst shaping America's imperial ambitions. The novel critiques the transformation of democracy into militarized imperialism, reflecting on the media's growing influence and its implications for American identity and global power dynamics.

Hollywood and the Media's Role

"Hollywood" explores the burgeoning film industry and its potential to reshape reality, with figures like Hearst recognizing its power. Vidal's narrative highlights the media's role in constructing public perceptions and political power, raising questions about truth and representation in an increasingly mediated world.

Washington, D.C. and Political Ambition

In "Washington, D.C.," Vidal examines the interplay of power and ambition in the nation's capital, where political figures navigate personal and ideological conflicts. Through characters like Senator James Burden Day and Clay Overbury, Vidal critiques the compromises and moral ambiguities inherent in political life, drawing parallels to contemporary power struggles.

The Golden Age: Reflections on American Power

"The Golden Age" revisits Vidal's formative years in Washington, D.C., offering a retrospective on American political and cultural life. Set against the backdrop of World War II and its aftermath, the novel questions America's democratic ideals and imperial ambitions, with characters like Franklin Roosevelt embodying the complexities of leadership in a changing global landscape.

Myra Breckinridge and Gender Fluidity

"Myra Breckinridge" shocked readers with its bold exploration of gender, sexuality, and cultural norms. The novel's protagonist challenges traditional gender roles, reflecting Vidal's commentary on societal constructs and identity fluidity. This campy narrative critiques popular culture while addressing serious themes of power and identity transformation.

Live from Golgotha: Blurring Historical Lines

"Live from Golgotha" continues Vidal's exploration of history's malleability, blending first-century events with futuristic technology. The novel's irreverent take on biblical narratives challenges readers to reconsider foundational beliefs and the nature of historical truth. Vidal's portrayal of anachronisms and fictionalized history underscores the fluidity of narrative and memory.

The Smithsonian Institution and Temporal Manipulation

Vidal's "The Smithsonian Institution" delves into the potential for political and historical change through time travel. The young protagonist's journey highlights the complexities of historical narratives and the ethical implications of altering history. This novel further exemplifies Vidal's fascination with history's plasticity and the enduring quest for truth amidst temporal shifts.

In sum, Gore Vidal's literary canon stands as a testament to his intellectual rigor and fearless examination of societal norms. His works continue to engage, provoke, and inspire, leaving an indelible mark on American literature and cultural critique.

Discussion Topics

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Gore Vidal, a prolific author and keen observer of American society, often critiques the subtle mechanisms of power in the United States. He famously remarked on the "genius of the American ruling class," suggesting that its greatest triumph is how unaware the populace is of its existence. This veiled power structure, according to Vidal, allows the ruling class to operate without significant public scrutiny or resistance.

Vidal contends that the American republic, initially founded on ideals of democracy, was swiftly replaced by an imperial mindset. This transformation began with territorial expansion at home, notably through the displacement of Native Americans and the annexation of Mexican lands. Vidal argues that this internal empire set the stage for an international one, characterized not by the traditional colonial model of ownership but by dominance. The United States, he suggests, exports its concepts of democracy and freedom as a strategic tool to maintain influence over other nations, effectively creating an empire without formal colonies.

A recurring figure in Vidal’s historical narratives is Aaron Burr, often perceived as a contentious figure among the Founding Fathers. Burr’s reputation as a "bad boy" intrigues Vidal, who uses him to explore themes of power, ambition, and the complexities of American identity. Through Burr, Vidal questions the conventional narratives of American history, offering a more nuanced and critical perspective.

Vidal's portrayals of historical figures like George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, and Franklin D. Roosevelt frequently startle readers, challenging the sanitized versions found in mainstream discourse. Despite the shock these portrayals may induce, many historians find Vidal’s interpretations to be not only plausible but also insightful. His proximity to various American elites grants him a unique vantage point, allowing him to craft narratives with an insider’s depth and authenticity.

Intriguingly, Vidal speculated on an alternate historical trajectory had the Roman Emperor Julian succeeded in his ambitions. Vidal theorizes that Julian's success could have led to a more enlightened path in American history, one that potentially avoided the pitfalls of imperialism and embraced a different set of values.

Bibliography

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

  • Library Journal 133, no. 8 (May 1, 2008): 67.
  • The Nation 287, no. 13 (October 27, 2008): 58-62.
  • Publishers Weekly 255, no. 14 (April 7, 2008): 50.
  • Altman, Dennis. Gore Vidal’s America. Malden, Mass.: Polity, 2005. Comprehensive look at every aspect of Vidal’s life that includes a chapter on his career as a writer, including the works written as Edgar Box. Bibliographic references and indexes.
  • Baker, Susan, and Curtis S. Gibson. Gore Vidal: A Critical Companion. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1997. A helpful book of criticism and interpretation of Vidal’s work. Includes bibliographical references and index.
  • Dick, Bernard F. The Apostate Angel: A Critical Study of Gore Vidal. New York: Random House, 1974. An entertaining and perceptive study, based on interviews with Vidal and on use of his papers at the University of Wisconsin at Madison. Dick focuses on Vidal’s work rather than on his biography. The book contains footnotes and a bibliography.
  • Harris, Stephen. The Fiction of Gore Vidal and E. L. Doctorow: Writing the Historical Self. New York: P. Lang, 2002. Discusses Vidal’s strong identification with history as reflected in his writing.
  • Joshi, S. T. Gore Vidal: A Comprehensive Bibliography. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow, 2007. A comprehensive volume containing annotations of nearly every piece of writing by and about Vidal. Includes analysis of his fiction and summaries of the articles and essays he has written.
  • Kaplan, Fred. Gore Vidal: A Biography. New York: Doubleday, 1999. A comprehensive biography of the novelist, playwright, scriptwriter, essayist, and political activist who helped shape American letters during the second half of the twentieth century.
  • Kiernan, Robert F. Gore Vidal. New York: Frederick Ungar, 1982. This study of Vidal’s major writings tries to assess his place in American literature and gives astute descriptions of the Vidalian style and manner. The book, which uses Vidal’s manuscript collection, contains a brief note and bibliography section.
  • Parini, Jay, ed. Gore Vidal: Writer Against the Grain. New York: Columbia University Press, 1992. Vidal’s distaste for much of the academic study of modern fiction has been mirrored in a lack of academic study of his work. Jay Parini sought to redress the balance by compiling this work, which deals with both Vidal’s fiction and nonfiction.
  • Stanton, Robert J., and Gore Vidal, eds. Views from a Window: Conversations with Gore Vidal. Secaucus, N.J.: Lyle Stuart, 1980. A compilation of interviews excerpted and arranged along themes. Vidal comments on his and other authors’ works, on sexuality, and on politics. Vidal edited the manuscript and made corrections, with changes noted in the text.
  • Vidal, Gore. Point to Point Navigation: A Memoir. New York: Doubleday, 2006. Covers the years 1964 to 2006, detailing Vidal’s experiences and his reflections on writing (his own and others’), as well as culture generally.
Previous

Critical Essays

Next

Criticism

Loading...