Glenway Wescott Short Fiction Analysis
Glenway Wescott’s short fiction employs many of the same themes and techniques that he used in his first two novels. The two major themes continue to be the self and love. A technical innovation that he first used in The Grandmothers, the participating narrator, also appears in his short fiction. His use of symbols is also similar to what he had done in his first two novels. The bird remained his favorite symbol and was usually placed at the center of the story. Except for The Babe’s Bed, the short stories that appear after Good-bye, Wisconsin are inferior in quality and demonstrate how Wescott lost his enthusiasm for a literary form once he had mastered it. The next short form with which he experimented, the novella, perfected certain techniques of prose fiction that he used with mixed results in his short stories.
Wescott shaped a number of his early experiences into short stories in which he employed impressionistic techniques instead of the mere transcription of events.
Good-bye, Wisconsin
To a certain extent, the ten short stories and title essay in Good-bye, Wisconsin illustrate reasons why Wescott could not stay in Wisconsin. They cannot, however, be dismissed simply as regional stories in that the universal truths of which they speak could be found anywhere.
Several of the stories that deal, in one way or another, with the search for the self illustrate the ways in which rural Wisconsin impedes that search. “The Sailor” goes beyond being a regional story in the way that it also includes the theme of love. Terrie, who is another of Wescott’s expatriates, has joined the navy to escape the depressing surroundings of rural Wisconsin. After spending some time in France, he recounts his adventures there to his brother, Riley. By the time Terrie has finished his narration, he has revealed that he has been severely traumatized by a failed love affair that he had with a French prostitute named Zizi. Riley, however, sees the stories as nothing more than tales of whiskey and women. Sensing Riley’s lack of understanding, Terrie is filled with a thirst that cannot be quenched at home. Emotions such as the ones that Terrie encountered in Europe are foreign to Wisconsin.
Wisconsin serves primarily as the setting for a transition from innocence to experience in “In a Thicket.” Lilly is a fifteen-year-old girl who lives with her senile grandfather in a house surrounded by a thicket. After hearing about a black convict who escaped the night before from a nearby prison, she stays up all night waiting for him to appear. When she finally sees him at the door, she stands transfixed until he walks away. The three-inch gash that she finds in the screen door the next morning symbolizes the figurative loss of her virginity. The sexual side of her nature has been awakened by the intruder, and she emerges from the thicket of her childhood into the world of the senses.
Like “In a Thicket,” “The Whistling Swan” takes place in Wisconsin, but it focuses instead on the theme of love. Like Terrie in “The Sailor,” the protagonist of “The Whistling Swan,” Hubert Redd, is an expatriate. He is, however, closer to Wescott himself in that he is an artist, a composer, and a sophisticate who is aware of both the advantages and drawbacks of living in Europe and the United States. He returns to his hometown in Wisconsin after his wealthy patrons withdraw their support on the grounds that he is immoral and untalented. The love that he feels for his childhood sweetheart complicates his life because...
(This entire section contains 1697 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
it conflicts with his desire to return to Europe and resume his artistic pursuits. Redd’s inner conflict is resolved when he impulsively shoots a swan and simultaneously kills that part of himself that draws him to Paris. The intentional ambiguity of the ending poses the possibility that he is sobbing, not because he has killed the swan, but because he has destroyed the creative impulse that made him unhappy in Wisconsin.
“A Guilty Woman” traces a woman’s progression from a type of love that enslaves to the type that liberates. Evelyn Crowe is a forty-five-year-old ex-convict who served six years in prison for murdering her lover, Bill Fisher. Fisher had been initially attracted to her because he relished the challenge of corrupting and abandoning an “old maid.” Upon her release from prison, she is taken in by her friend Martha Colvin to live on her farm in Wisconsin. While living there, Evelyn is attracted to Martha’s bachelor friend, Dr. John Bolton. She resists the romantic impulse that is building up inside her until she realizes that the passionless life to which she had returned was a form of pride. No longer content to be a self-sufficient spinster, she finally allows herself to fall in love. Wescott finds a kind of courage in Evelyn’s flexibility, which he believed was discouraged by small-town America.
The short story that merited the most critical acclaim was “Like a Lover.” Like Lilly in “In a Thicket,” Alice Murray is an isolated girl who is mesmerized by a man, in this case, an older man named Hurst. Despite her mother’s protests, she marries him. The assortment of whips and clubs that her husband keeps in the house, however, terrifies her and drives her back to her mother’s house. She remains in isolation for seven years until she learns that Hurst is to marry Mrs. Clayburn, a widow. Even though Mrs. Clayburn believes Alice’s words of warning, she admits that she is unable to break the spell that he holds over her. For two months following Mrs. Clayburn’s marriage, Alice is tormented by ominous nightmares that foretell the woman’s murder. The story concludes with the appearance of Alice’s friend, Mary Clifford, riding frantically from the Hurst farm, waving her arms. Shocked by what she knows has happened to the new Mrs. Hurst, Alice faints and falls backward on the porch. Ostensibly, “Like a Lover” exploits the same kind of scandalous material that Wescott used in “A Guilty Woman.” The godlike power that the men in both stories have over women, however, illustrates Wescott’s belief, discussed in depth two years later in A Calendar of Saints for Unbelievers, that the love for God is similar to the love for a man or a woman in that both forms of affection render a person completely helpless.
The Babe’s Bed
The Babe’s Bed, which is a thirty-five-page short story published as a book in Paris, is, in a sense, a postscript to the introductory essay in Good-bye, Wisconsin. Both were written after Wescott returned to Wisconsin for a short visit and concern an expatriated American who compares the Midwest to Europe. In both works, Wisconsin and the United States in general are found to retard the development of the self.
The story is told from the limited point of view of a nameless bachelor who returns home. As in other stories by Wescott, dramatic tension is created through the narrator’s conflicting impulses. The bachelor becomes so lost in fantasies involving his sister’s baby that he becomes detached from reality. He begins by imagining that the baby is his and then convinces himself that his married sister is his mother. The climax occurs at the dinner table when the baby screams at being placed in the harness that serves as its bed. The baby’s bed, which is the story’s central symbol, bears a close resemblance to the mental web that has ensnared the bachelor. Before he attacks everyone at the table, he realizes that he has been living in a fantasy world and directs his anger toward himself before he can do any real harm to his loved ones.
The Pilgrim Hawk
With the publication of The Pilgrim Hawk: A Love Story, Wescott created what many critics have referred to as a genuine short masterpiece. The novella differs from most of Wescott’s previous fiction in that it concerns expatriated Americans living in France instead of rural midwestern Americans. The story is retold in 1940 by the protagonist, Alwyn Tower, who interrupts his first-person narrative to comment on such matters as love, marriage, religion, alcoholism, and individual and artistic freedom. The events that he recalls took place during one day in May of 1928 or 1929 in France at the house of Alexandra Henry, a great friend of Tower. The story focuses on the arrival of Madeleine and Larry Cullen, a rich, handsome couple from Ireland who arrive unexpectedly with their chauffeur, Ricketts, and Madeleine Cullen’s falcon, Lucy. For the most part, the action of the novella takes the form of a conversation among the four main characters.
As the Cullens chat about money and neighbors, it becomes clear that the hawk symbolizes the Cullens’ relationship and the Cullens themselves. Madeleine resembles the feathered predator in the way she uses her charms to capture and hold her prey, Larry, who is too weak to escape the hold that she has on him. Both she and her husband, however, are hawklike in that they are prisoners of their own appetites. Although the hawk is consistent with the bird symbolism in Wescott’s other stories and novels, it differs in the way it revolves, taking on different meanings in different situations.
Tower continues to attach symbolic meanings to the hawk until it comes to stand for himself and Alexandra as well. Eventually, he builds a tower of symbolic meanings that blinds him to the “petty” facts that constitute reality. The process continues until Cullen, in a drunken stupor, attempts to kill someone; Madeleine, who reports the event just before she and her husband leave for Paris, never makes it clear whether Larry tried to kill himself or Ricketts in a fit of jealous rage. This violent turn of events shocks Tower back to reality, enabling him to descend from the symbolic tower that he has constructed. He recognizes that the “whisper of the devil” is the fear that he has attached the wrong meanings to things in order to make life more meaningful.