Themes: Filial Piety and Duty
Amanda, a single mother, is obsessed with the notion of filial piety, and much of her conversation with Tom concerns his duties and responsibilities to his family. She speaks often of her disappointment and rage at being abandoned by her husband, and when she is angry at Tom, she compares his behavior to his father’s. When Mr. Wingfield rejected his family, he abandoned his filial duties, broke his wife’s heart, and damaged his wife’s self-perception. The effects of these consequences play out throughout every scene of the play.
Tom’s natural desire for freedom violates the sense of duty Amanda believes he should prioritize, and this conflict of interests creates tension in the Wingfield household. Amanda believes that Tom’s role as the man of the household is to provide and to ensure that the female members of the family are looked after. Tom is a young man, however, and he is full of curiosity and wanderlust; he resents his mother’s insistence that he take over the duties shirked by his father, especially because Tom works a job he dislikes in order to pay the bills for his mother and sister. Every bit of poorly timed criticism that Amanda sends his way damages their relationship and gives Tom even more motivation to leave.
Amanda’s interpretation of her responsibility to her children is as flawed as her approach to communication. Her desire to take care of Laura is authentic but clumsy, and she refuses to listen to either of her children. Amanda’s inept parenting lets both Laura and Tom down, and while Tom can leave to go to the movies when the pressure builds, Laura cannot. Her disability holds her back in multiple ways, and her fragile nature suggests that she will not be able to endure Amanda’s forcefulness for long.
Expert Q&A
What does Amanda nag Tom to provide in "The Glass Menagerie"?
Amanda constantly nags Tom to provide for the family and find a suitable gentleman caller for his sister, Laura. She pressures Tom to be the family's provider, despite his own dreams and aspirations. Amanda also criticizes Tom's behavior and choices, contributing to his frustration. Her incessant demands and unrealistic expectations ultimately drive Tom to leave the family, feeling guilty about abandoning Laura.
Why does Tom take a long time to decide to leave home in The Glass Menagerie?
Tom takes a long time to decide to leave home because he feels both stifled and responsible for his family, particularly his sister Laura. Despite his unhappiness and desire for freedom, he is conflicted by a sense of obligation and the fear of repeating his father's abandonment. His internal struggle reflects his frustration and guilt, which delay his decision to leave until the end of the play.
In The Glass Menagerie, what does Tom realize about his desires versus his responsibilities?
Based on The Glass Menagerie, which should come first: individual right or responsibility?
Tom's Justification and Decision to Leave Family in The Glass Menagerie
In Tennessee Williams' The Glass Menagerie, Tom Wingfield justifies leaving his family due to his oppressive home life, including a nagging mother, a dead-end job, and the burden of supporting his family. His desire for freedom and travel mirrors his absent father, whom he resembles. While his decision is seen as necessary for his sanity and self-fulfillment, it is also a source of guilt, particularly concerning his sister Laura. Ultimately, opinions vary on whether Tom's departure was justified, reflecting his need to escape an intolerable situation.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.