Themes: Memory
In The Giver, memory plays a crucial role in shaping the society and its individuals. The novel explores the importance of memory in understanding emotions, making informed decisions, and maintaining cultural identity. The community in the story has sacrificed memories to achieve Sameness, resulting in a loss of individuality and emotional depth. The Receiver of Memory holds the burden of the past, preserving both painful and joyful memories to guide the community's decisions. Through Jonas's journey, the novel illustrates how memories are essential for a fulfilling human experience.
Ten years before Jonas's selection as the Receiver of Memory, the previous Receiver-in-training, Rosemary, requested release, leading to chaos when her memories flooded the community. The Giver, who was Rosemary's father, struggled to transfer painful memories to her, which eventually led to her suicide. This event taught the community the dangers of releasing memories, prompting a change in the Receiver's rules to prevent future releases. This incident highlights the community's dependence on the Receiver to contain memories and maintain order.
The Receiver of Memory's role is vital for the community's stability. By holding memories of life before Sameness, the Receiver advises the Committee of Elders on significant decisions, using wisdom gained from past experiences. The Receiver's isolation underscores the community's ignorance, as citizens are shielded from both the pain and joy of the past. The novel critiques this suppression of memory, suggesting that true understanding and happiness require the ability to compare different experiences.
"Our people made that choice, the choice to go to the Sameness. Before my time, before the previous time, back and back and back. We relinquished color when we relinquished sunshine and did away with differences." He thought for a moment. "We gained control of many things. But we had to let go of others." "We shouldn’t have!" Jonas said fiercely.
As Jonas learns from the Giver, he realizes that the absence of memory limits the community's ability to experience genuine emotions. The novel argues that memories are essential for empathy and emotional growth, as they allow individuals to connect with others and understand their own feelings. Without shared memories, culture and civilization would suffer, losing collective knowledge and traditions. The story emphasizes that memories need to be shared to foster understanding and prevent the repetition of past mistakes.
"Behind him, across the vast distance of space and time, from the place he had left, he thought he heard music too. But perhaps it was only an echo" (183).
The ambiguous ending of The Giver leaves readers to ponder the fate of Jonas and the community. If Jonas succeeds in releasing the memories, the community would face an overwhelming adjustment, but it would also gain the freedom to experience true emotions and make informed choices. The novel ultimately suggests that memory is a fundamental aspect of human life, essential for understanding, growth, and the richness of experience.
Expert Q&A
In The Giver, which war does Jonas experience in a painful memory?
In The Giver, Jonas experiences a memory of the American Civil War in Chapter 15. This is inferred from several historical clues such as the lack of modern medical care, the use of horses, and the presence of coarse cloth uniforms and cannons. Additionally, the gray uniform worn by a dying boy suggests the Confederate army, aligning with common perceptions of the Civil War.
In which chapter of "The Giver" was the memory of love given to Jonas?
The memory of love is given to Jonas in chapter 16 of The Giver. In this memory, Jonas sees a group of people sharing pleasurable activities like giving presents and admiring a decorated tree. He experiences feelings of excitement, family, happiness, and warmth. Jonas struggles to identify a strong feeling he sensed, which The Giver explains is "love."
How would the world be different if people only had one-generation memories?
If people only had memories from one generation, society would likely repeat past mistakes, lacking historical knowledge to guide decisions. Without multi-generational wisdom, achievements and lessons would be forgotten, leading to a cycle of relearning. The absence of historical context would diminish traits like wisdom and integrity, making life less purposeful. As depicted in The Giver, this ignorance could falsely equate the absence of pain with happiness, impacting family pride, education, and scientific progress.
The Significance and Role of Memories in The Giver
In Lois Lowry's The Giver, memories play a crucial role in shaping humanity and society. Memories in Jonas's community are confined to the Receiver of Memory to spare citizens from pain, but this also deprives them of joy and individuality. The Giver reveals that memories are "forever," highlighting their permanence and potential to overwhelm the community if released. The theme emphasizes that memories, both joyful and painful, are essential for a complete human experience, fostering wisdom and emotional depth.
The Giver's Request for Forgiveness After Sharing War Memory with Jonas
In The Giver, the Giver asks Jonas for forgiveness after transmitting a harrowing memory of war. This memory exposes Jonas to intense physical and emotional pain, depicting a battlefield where soldiers die around him. The Giver apologizes because the memory is too traumatic for Jonas, who has grown up in a society devoid of war and suffering due to strict control over emotions and experiences. The Giver feels remorse for burdening Jonas with such pain, highlighting the conflict between the society's imposed peace and the harsh truths of the past.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
