Discussion Topic

The importance of having someone who can "see beyond" in the community in The Giver


In The Giver, having someone who can "see beyond" is crucial because this person holds memories of the past, which provide wisdom and guidance. This role helps the community make informed decisions and avoid repeating past mistakes. The ability to see beyond also introduces the possibility of change and deeper understanding in an otherwise controlled and uniform society.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why is it important for the Community in The Giver (Chapters 11-15) to have someone who can "see beyond"?

It is important for the Community to have a person who can "see beyond", a Receiver, to hold all the memories of the past, so that they will not have to bear the pain of them.

The creators of the Community have fashioned a society based on "sameness".  Everything is controlled, "predictable...painless"; and the result is a world shrouded in neutral grayness, devoid of color, and of anything that can cause variation.  Even the weather is controlled; there is no sunshine, and everyday is the same.  The landscape also has been leveled, and hills and valleys are beyond the people's experience.  The objective behind the creation of the Community was a world where life is easy.  The people make no choices, because if they did, they might make wrong choices, and have to suffer consequences which might be unpleasant.

It is the Receiver's job to hold the memories of the world as it was before, to "see beyond "sameness".  Sometimes, when the Committee of Elders must make a decision for which the use of memories of the way things used to be might be helpful, the Receiver might be consulted for advice.  This happens rarely however, but the real importance the Receiver has for the Community was made evident ten years previously, when, with the Release of the Receiver-in-Training, the memories returned temporarily to the people.  Chaos ensued, and the people suffered terribly with memories from which they had long been sheltered and could no longer see, memories of hunger and loneliness and violence and pain.  The Receiver's job is "to contain all that pain...and knowledge", and to bear the suffering so that the people will not have to (Chapter 13).

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Why is it important for the community in The Giver to have a person who can “see beyond”?

In The Giver, the Chief Elder tells the crowd that the Receiver has told the committee of Elders that the new receiver must have the capacity to see beyond.  She openly states that she does not know what it is.  Jonas has been seeing slight glimpses of color in this black and white world and he tells the crowd (once he has been selected) that he thinks what he sees is beyond.

As it turns out, he is partially correct.  To put in modern terms, Jonas has the ability to see "outside of the box".  He can see beyond what is his reality and imagine another world- a world that is totally different from his own.  Perhaps more importantly than his vision, seeing beyond refers to his thinking and his ability to grasp concepts beyond that which he has been taught and trained.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on