Themes: Wealth
Henry foregrounds the drab, worn-down circumstances in which Della and Jim live in order to create a distinction between material wealth and immaterial wealth. Between their second-hand furniture, cheap apartment, and inability to afford new clothes, Jim and Della are undoubtedly impoverished. Jim’s decreased pay and the economic circumstances of early-twentieth-century New York mean that times are tough, and Della has had to bargain for every last penny that she has saved up for Jim’s gift. These depictions of the couple's poverty only serve to emphasize the value of the two possessions that they do take pride in: Della’s hair and Jim’s watch.
The narrator suggests that Della’s hair is beautiful enough to devalue all of the wealth of the Queen of Sheba and that Jim’s watch is fine enough to be envied by King Solomon. For a young couple living in such economically strained circumstances, it is unlikely that their possessions truly rival those of biblical royalty. However, the items are considered valuable for more than just their material worth. Della’s hair represents her beauty and femininity, and for it to have reached such a length, she must have been growing it out for years. Jim’s watch is an heirloom that was passed down from his father. The sentimentality and personal value of these possessions is greater than any monetary value that could be ascribed to them.
It is fitting, then, that both Jim and Della decide to sacrifice their prized belongings not in order to change their material circumstances but rather to buy a sentimentally motivated gift for their partner. Though the combs and the watch chain are given monetary value, it is the sentiment behind each gift that makes them truly meaningful. Della and Jim may remain materially impoverished, but their exchange of functionally useless Christmas gifts only serves to emphasize the wealth of love that exists between them.
Expert Q&A
An analysis of Jim and Della's financial status in "The Gift of the Magi."
Jim and Della in "The Gift of the Magi" are financially impoverished. They struggle to make ends meet, as evidenced by their inability to afford Christmas gifts without sacrificing their most prized possessions. Their love for each other, however, surpasses their monetary constraints, demonstrating that their true wealth lies in their mutual devotion and selflessness.
The paradox of Jim and Della being described as the richest couple on earth in "The Gift of the Magi."
The paradox of Jim and Della being described as the richest couple on earth in "The Gift of the Magi" lies in their material poverty contrasted with their immense love and selflessness. Though they lack money, their willingness to sacrifice their most prized possessions for each other demonstrates a wealth of love and devotion, making them rich in the most meaningful sense.
Jim and Della's Economic Struggles in "The Gift of the Magi"
In "The Gift of the Magi," Jim and Della face financial struggles, both aware of their dire economic situation. They desire to give each other meaningful Christmas gifts despite their limited funds. Della, the story's primary focus, saves money through frugality, while Jim sells his watch to buy combs for Della's hair, which she has sold to buy him a watch fob. Their sacrifices highlight their financial awareness and deep love for each other.
What does the apartment's description in "The Gift of the Magi" reveal about the couple's economic situation?
The apartment description in "The Gift of the Magi" highlights the couple's economic struggles. They live in a shabby, $8-a-week furnished flat with worn-out amenities, symbolizing their poverty. Details like a worn red carpet and a mirror that distorts one's reflection emphasize their financial hardship. This setting contrasts with their treasured possessions—Della's hair and Jim's watch—underscoring the depth of their love and sacrifices in the face of economic adversity.
What is the narrator's comment on the value of money and why does he divert attention from Della and Jim to express it?
The narrator comments on the value of love over money by diverting attention from Della and Jim's embrace to their modest apartment, emphasizing that their love is priceless. By "breaking the fourth wall," the narrator suggests their love transcends monetary worth, echoing the idea that true wisdom lies in valuing love over material possessions. This aligns with the symbolic meaning of the Magi's gifts, highlighting love's immeasurable value.
Indications of the couple's financial struggle in "The Gift of the Magi"
The couple in "The Gift of the Magi" shows signs of financial struggle through their modest living conditions, such as their sparse apartment and Della's concern over saving money for Jim's Christmas gift. Their sacrifices, like Della selling her hair and Jim selling his watch, further highlight their financial difficulties.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
