Analysis
George Moore, a luminary in the realm of literature, brought a distinctive vision to both his novels and short stories. Infusing his narratives with an "oral" style, Moore sought to portray the lives of ordinary people, particularly in the Irish context, through a lens of realism and subtle artistry. His works, revered for their simplicity and emotional depth, often explored themes of human frailty and cultural heritage, leaving a lasting impact on subsequent writers, including James Joyce.
George Moore's Realistic Approach to Short Fiction
George Moore's approach to short fiction was marked by his commitment to depicting ordinary lives, particularly those of Irish people, with a realistic and unembellished touch. Drawing inspiration from late nineteenth-century French and Russian writers like Zola, Flaubert, and Turgenev, Moore aimed to eschew dramatic flair in favor of an "oral" style that evoked intimacy. He aspired to a narrative simplicity that conveyed mood through landscape rather than explicit characterization or narratorial intrusion, thus adopting a "show, don’t tell" philosophy.
His stories avoided extravagant plots, favoring straightforward narratives devoid of dramatic climaxes or definitive conclusions. This objective storytelling style influenced the Irish literary scene significantly, setting a precedent for writers like James Joyce, whose Dubliners exhibited similar characteristics. Moore's exploration of Irish folklore further demonstrated his dedication to preserving and reshaping Ireland’s cultural heritage through literature.
Notable Short Stories: "Wilfrid Holmes" and "Sarah Gwynn"
Moore's story "Wilfrid Holmes," part of In Single Strictness, exemplifies his interest in the quiet desperation of repressed lives. The protagonist, Wilfrid Holmes, embodies aimlessness, drifting through potential careers before settling on composing operas, yet lacking the discipline to master composition. His life, supported by an aunt’s allowance, becomes a study in lethargy, punctuated only by minor incidents that highlight his incompetence but lead to no substantial change. This narrative style, likened to a "minor key" in music, suggests that style itself conveys meaning.
Similarly, "Sarah Gwynn" from Celibate Lives explores human despair and socio-economic challenges. Sarah, a former lay sister dismissed from a convent, finds work as a housekeeper in Dublin, where her potential marriage is derailed by her quest to find Phyllis, a friend who once saved her from destitution. This quest underscores the quiet sacrifices and loyalties that often go unnoticed, culminating in a poignant, unresolved conclusion impacting Sarah, her employer, and her would-be suitor.
"So on He Fares" and Narrative Simplicity
Moore's "So on He Fares"—which he famously claimed as the best short story ever written—demonstrates his commitment to the quiet, intimate portrayal of ordinary lives. Centering on Ulick Burke, whose childhood devoid of maternal affection leads him to a life of wandering, the story reflects Moore’s interest in how life unfolds in subtle, often unresolved ways. The narrative's rhythmic style, or "melodic line," captures the bittersweet essence of endurance amid life’s hardships, eschewing dramatic resolutions for somber acceptance and resilience.
A Narrative Frame: A Story-Teller’s Holiday
Moore’s A Story-Teller’s Holiday tackles the challenge of cohesion in short story collections by embedding the individual tales within a broader narrative. This collection features a fictionalized Moore traveling from London to Ireland, engaging in conversations that organically give rise to stories. These tales, blending educated English and local dialects, traverse themes from political and social commentaries to rural life narratives, ultimately evoking the storytelling traditions of ancient Ireland.
By 1918, Moore, disillusioned by World War I and political strife, found solace in the timelessness of Irish folklore. This collection marked a return to storytelling grounded in cultural roots, offering both artistic enrichment and a subtle critique of contemporary Ireland.
Moore's Complex Aesthetic Philosophy in Novels
Spanning over fifty years,...
(This entire section contains 1238 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
Moore’s career as a novelist defies simple categorization, straddling Victorian sensibilities and classical inspirations rather than modernist experimentation. His aestheticism, focused on "the story of life in grave simple phrases," sought to evoke deep emotion while allowing style and execution to fade into the background. His works, ranging fromAphrodite in Aulis to A Mummer’s Wife, reveal a diversity influenced by writers like Gustave Flaubert, Ivan Turgenev, and Walter Pater.
Moore's novels explore the tension between artistic ambition and societal constraints, often highlighting the struggles of women seeking independence. This thematic concern is evident in A Modern Lover, where Lewis Seymour's artistic journey mirrors the broader conflict between avant-garde expression and commercial success.
The Duality of Women's Lives: "A Mummer’s Wife" and "A Drama in Muslin"
Moore’s portrayal of women, noted for its depth and psychological insight, is prominently featured in A Mummer’s Wife and A Drama in Muslin. In the former, Kate Ede’s transition from a shopkeeper’s wife to an actor’s partner highlights the precarious nature of liberation, as her initial escape from oppressive domesticity leads to a descent into alcoholism and despair. Her narrative suggests that personal agency alone cannot counter societal and personal pitfalls.
Conversely, A Drama in Muslin presents Alice Barton as a woman who successfully navigates societal expectations. Her intellectual independence and self-reliance enable her to sidestep the traditional "marriage market" and secure a fulfilling life, illustrating a more hopeful vision of female empowerment.
Challenging Realism with "Esther Waters"
Regarded as one of Moore’s greatest novels, Esther Waters challenges the notion of realism through its vivid portrayal of a servant class protagonist. Esther, an unmarried mother, navigates the trials of life with dignity and resilience, offering a narrative that subverts Victorian norms and highlights the humanity of those often marginalized in literature. While the novel is celebrated for its realist depiction, Moore’s true interest lay in the artistic expression of maternal instinct and love—a theme that transforms the ordinary into the extraordinary.
Exploring Women's Liberation: "Evelyn Innes"
Moore’s exploration of women’s liberation continues with Evelyn Innes, a novel that examines the inner conflict of a woman torn between career ambitions and personal morality. Evelyn’s relationships with two men embodying the carnal and the intellectual lead her to a drastic decision: entering a convent to reconcile her desires with her conscience. Moore’s ambiguous stance on religion and feminism is palpable in this narrative, as he grapples with the implications of newfound freedom and its limitations.
Historical Narratives: "The Brook Kerith" and "Héloise and Abélard"
In his later works, Moore turned to historical narratives, finding in ancient and medieval settings a canvas for his aesthetic aspirations. The Brook Kerith reimagines the story of Christ, envisioning a matured figure who challenges traditional dogma. The novel’s speculative retelling of religious history reflects Moore’s fascination with themes of humanism and moral evolution.
Similarly, Héloise and Abélard delves into the conflict between intellectual freedom and religious constraint, casting Héloise as a protagonist who embodies the struggle for independence and love against doctrinal rigidity. This novel further exemplifies Moore’s ability to intertwine landscape, character, and idea into a cohesive artistic vision.
Conclusion of a Literary Journey: "Aphrodite in Aulis"
Moore’s final novel, Aphrodite in Aulis, serves as a testament to his lifelong devotion to art and narrative. Set in ancient Greece, the story unfolds as a meditation on the interplay between art and life, culminating in a harmonious resolution where each enhances the other. Despite the personal challenges Moore faced in his later years, the novel encapsulates the enduring themes of his oeuvre: the pursuit of beauty, the complexity of human experience, and the transformative power of storytelling.
