The Stonewall Inn Riots
In the late 1960s, the landscape of American theater began to shift, most notably with the advent of openly gay plays in mainstream venues. Mart Crowley's The Boys in the Band, staged in 1968, marked a groundbreaking moment. Not only did it open New York's stages to gay narratives, but it also coincided with the state's decision to relax its ban on depicting homosexuality. This play's success laid the groundwork for what would become a significant movement in both theater and society at large, ushering in a new era of LGBT representation on stage.
Amidst this evolving cultural backdrop, the Stonewall Inn riots emerged as a pivotal moment in the gay liberation movement. On June 27, 1969, a regular Friday night at the Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village turned extraordinary. The New York City Police Department conducted a raid—a not uncommon occurrence designed to harass the gay community under the guise of law enforcement. These raids typically led to arrests, public embarrassment, and lingering consequences despite often being dismissed in court. The specter of these arrests haunted many, their records a constant threat hanging over their futures.
However, this particular raid was set against a backdrop of profound national unrest. Social upheaval was palpable across the country, fueled by civil disobedience and protest against racial injustice, the Vietnam War, and the systemic inequalities faced by minorities. For the patrons of the Stonewall Inn, the raid occurred in the shadow of grief; the community was mourning the recent death of Judy Garland, an icon whose passing carried emotional weight for many in the LGBT community.
On that fateful night, the usual routine of arrest and dispersal was upended. As police attempted to detain and load patrons into vans, the crowd's mood shifted. Instead of submitting, those present resisted. The collective frustration and anger boiled over, igniting a riot that would become emblematic of the fight for gay rights. This defiance was not just about that evening's raid but a response to the broader context of social injustice and a declaration of a community unwilling to remain silent.
The Stonewall riots represented more than an isolated incident; they were a clarion call that reverberated beyond the confines of Greenwich Village. They galvanized a movement, fueling the fire of activism and paving the way for subsequent generations to push further for equality and representation. In tandem with the trailblazing efforts in theater, such as Crowley's work, the events at Stonewall underscored a transformative period where the voices of the LGBT community demanded to be heard and recognized both onstage and in society at large.
Before Stonewall
During the early 20th century, both sides of the Atlantic underwent significant cultural transformations. This era marked the gradual dismantling of Victorian moral constraints, replaced by a burgeoning spirit of bohemianism. Particularly notable were the artistic enclaves of Greenwich Village in New York and the vibrant cultural awakening of the Harlem Renaissance.
A Shift in Sexual Tolerance
The loosening of rigid Victorian mores brought about a newfound tolerance for sexual freedom. This shift was notably reflected in the circles of the Bloomsbury Group in London, which included prominent homosexuals and lesbians among its ranks. These individuals were some of the era's most creative writers, artists, and intellectuals, contributing to a legacy of groundbreaking work.
Theatrical Subtlety and Censorship
Noël Coward emerged as a central figure in British theater, infusing his work with subtle nods to homosexuality. Plays like The Vortex (1924) and Design for Living (1933) were masterclasses in implication, resonating deeply with those in his audience who identified as homosexual. For a mainstream audience, this was often perceived as "high...
(This entire section contains 327 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
camp," cleverly dodging the scrutiny of British censors. Coward's clever use of song lyrics, such as in "Mad About the Boy" fromWords and Music (1932), further exemplified his ability to veil the taboo in acceptable art.
Oscar Wilde's Coded Narratives
Oscar Wilde, a towering figure from the previous century, skillfully navigated the censorial landscape with works like The Importance of Being Earnest (1895). Wilde's creation of "Bunburying" slipped past the censors, though its double entendre has sparked interpretation in both homosexual and heterosexual contexts. This cleverness in writing allowed for the expression of ideas that might otherwise have been suppressed.
Early Depictions of Homosexuality
Before Stonewall, the portrayal of homosexuality in theater was often fraught with conflict and tragedy. Alfred Jarry’s Haldernablou (1894) and Henry B. Fuller’s At Saint Judas’s (1896) are prime examples. Both plays tackled homosexual themes, resulting in dramatic moral tensions and unhappy endings, as societal norms of the time dictated the narrative outcomes.
Lesbian Plays of the 1920’s and 1930’s
During the early twentieth century, societal attitudes towards lesbianism were notably more permissive compared to male homosexuality. Close relationships between women were regarded with less suspicion and were not deemed unusual. However, the theme of lesbianism in theater remained contentious, as evidenced by the controversy surrounding Lillian Hellman's The Children’s Hour and its exclusion from the 1935 Pulitzer Prize in Drama. Despite being Hellman's most acclaimed play, award recognition eluded her, with the prize going instead to Zoë Atkins for The Old Maid. This decision reflected societal unease with the play's subject matter rather than its artistic merit.
The Complexities of The Children’s Hour
Lillian Hellman’s The Children’s Hour tells the story of Karen and Martha, two teachers who share a deep bond forged during their college years. Teaching together at a school, they become the target of a malicious accusation from Mary, a troubled student, who claims the women are engaged in an "indecent" relationship. Despite Karen's sensitivity to Mary's emotional disturbances, the unfounded rumors irrevocably tarnish the teachers' lives, illustrating the destructive power of suspicion and prejudice. Although the play was bold in addressing such themes, its reception was mixed. It faced censorship in Britain while finding a stage on Broadway, highlighting the era's cultural divide concerning its bold subject matter.
Exploring Love and Expectations in The Lamp and the Bell
Fifteen years before Hellman's work, Edna St. Vincent Millay's The Lamp and the Bell delved into the complexities of love between women. Written for the fiftieth anniversary of Vassar College’s Alumnae Association, this play sees Princess Beatrice and Bianca express a profound affection for one another, though they both discuss the prospect of heterosexual marriage. The dynamics shift with the arrival of King Mario, whose presence confounds Beatrice due to her masculine demeanor. Bianca, after a period of absence, returns, falls for Mario, and marries him. Although Beatrice becomes queen, she kills Mario in a skirmish and reunites with Bianca only when the latter is on her deathbed, sharing a final embrace that underscores their enduring connection.
Lesbian Themes in the Works of Djuna Barnes
Djuna Barnes contributed to the era's lesbian theatrical landscape with The Dove, presenting a narrative centered around three lesbian characters: Vera, Amelia, and the Dove. While the play didn’t reach Broadway, it did find an audience at Smith College's Studio Theatre and New York City's Bayes Theatre. The Dove’s love for Amelia prompts Vera's departure, and similar themes of lesbian relationships are subtly woven into Barnes's other works like Two Ladies Take Tea and To the Dogs. In the latter, a young man's romantic rejection leads him to label a woman as queer, a description she embraces, reflecting Barnes's nuanced exploration of identity.
Thematic Underpinnings and Societal Reactions
The lesbian plays of the 1920s and 1930s often refrained from explicit discussions of sexual relationships, concentrating instead on broader societal and personal themes. While lesbianism was a prevailing motif, plays like The Children’s Hour grappled with issues such as the unjust punishment of innocence, as noted by critic Eric Bentley. He argued that the play's focus on innocence overshadowed its commentary on lesbianism, suggesting that while Karen's love for Martha is apparent, their innocence stands as a central theme against the backdrop of societal misjudgment. These plays, by presenting lesbian relationships within their narratives, challenged audiences to reconsider preconceived notions, even if the era's prevailing attitudes often remained unchanged.
Latent Homosexuality
The exploration of latent homosexuality in theater between the 1920s and the 1960s highlights how playwrights subtly incorporated themes of same-sex attraction and identity into their work. During this era, the depiction of homosexuality was often veiled and indirect, reflecting the broader social taboos surrounding the subject. As societal attitudes evolved, so did the portrayal of homosexuality on stage, culminating in a more open and candid exploration of such themes post-Stonewall.
Veiled Allusions in Early 20th Century Theater
From the 1920s to the 1960s, much of the Western drama subtly alluded to homosexuality through latent themes rather than overt characterizations. In W. Somerset Maugham's The Unknown (1920), the love expressed for a fallen comrade in war is more about veneration than romance. Similarly, J. R. Ackerley's The Prisoners of War (1925) features Conrad, whose complex emotions towards the young Grayle hint at homosexuality, although they are never explicitly realized as a love affair between men.
Eugene O’Neill's work, while largely devoid of openly gay characters, exhibited hints of latent homosexuality. Strange Interlude (1928) features Charles Marsden, a character whose bachelorhood subtly suggests a hidden sexual identity, while Ah, Wilderness! (1933) introduces a sensitive young Richard, whose literary interests in Oscar Wilde and Algernon Charles Swinburne hint at an exposure to homosexual themes.
More Direct, Yet Latent, Representations
Noël Coward's Post Mortem (1931), although never produced, and Keith Winter’s The Rats of Norway (1933) began to present homosexually coded characters more overtly, albeit still without fully centering on them. In Winter’s play, Chetwood is obviously gay, but the narrative focuses more on the new teacher Stevan’s heteronormative romantic endeavors.
Robert Anderson's Tea and Sympathy (1953) epitomizes the era's exploration of latent homosexuality, focusing on Tom, a sensitive youth whose experiences in a boys' boarding school raise questions about his sexual identity. The play navigates the complexities of rumors and societal expectations, portraying homosexuality as something to be understood and treated with compassion rather than condemnation.
Homosexual Playwrights and Latency
Even prominent homosexual playwrights of the era, such as Tennessee Williams, William Inge, and Edward Albee, often depicted homosexuality indirectly. Williams, in works like The Glass Menagerie (1944) and A Streetcar Named Desire (1947), included characters with ambiguous sexualities—Tom and Blanche’s deceased husband, respectively—whose sexual identities were suggested but not overtly addressed.
Inge's early plays of the 1950s lack openly gay characters but reveal his own inclinations through the presence of attractive young male characters. His later works, like Natural Affection (1963), begin to touch on the subject more directly, while his one-act plays such as The Tiny Closet (1959) offer a more explicit portrayal of closeted gay characters.
Edward Albee, although often critiqued for his veiled references to homosexuality, offered a complex portrayal of gender and identity in plays like Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1962). Critics viewed it as a "gay closet play," filled with symbolic gender roles and relationships hinting at the hidden lives of its characters.
Indirect Allusions in Heterosexual Playwrights' Work
Arthur Miller, a heterosexual playwright, incorporated latent homosexuality in his work through characters like Biff in Death of a Salesman (1949), whose lack of romantic relationships and passivity led some critics to suggest a hidden sexuality. In A View from the Bridge (1955), Eddie Carbone’s unexpected kiss with Rodolpho introduced audiences to shocking, though not explicitly gay, interactions.
Transition to Open Depictions
Before the pivotal Stonewall riots, there were a few attempts at open depictions of homosexuality on stage, such as Lanford Wilson’s The Madness of Lady Bright (1964) and Paddy Chayefsky’s The Latent Heterosexual (1968). However, these productions struggled for mainstream acceptance. The landscape shifted significantly with the production of Mart Crowley's The Boys in the Band (1968), hailed for its candid portrayal of a group of gay men.
In The Boys in the Band, Crowley introduced audiences to Michael and his diverse circle of friends, ranging from cultured to athletic, promiscuous to monogamous. While some criticized the play for reinforcing stereotypes of unhappy gay men, its groundbreaking honest portrayal paved the way for future explorations of homosexual identities in theater, marking a significant shift in the narrative of homosexuality on stage.
Post-Stonewall Drama
The pivotal period following the Stonewall riots in 1969 heralded a transformative era for gay and lesbian theater, disassembling entrenched societal norms and redefining narratives around family and identity. Lanford Wilson’s Fifth of July, premiering in 1978, exemplifies this shift by placing homosexuality at the heart of its narrative. The play centers on a homosexual Vietnam veteran who, having lost his legs in the war, returns to small-town Missouri to teach. Here, Wilson presents a family dynamic not grounded in biological procreation but in chosen relationships, challenging the traditional family structure. This portrayal resonates with the subversive undertones found in Edward Albee’s Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, though Albee's work refrains from addressing homosexuality explicitly. Nevertheless, both plays critique and deconstruct conventional family values.
The groundbreaking The Boys in the Band removed the veil from previous representations of homosexuality, setting the stage for subsequent, more candid works. During the 1970s and 1980s, plays such as John Hopkins’s Find Your Way Home (1970), Simon Gray’s Butley (1971), and David Rabe’s Streamers (1976) continued to push boundaries. Similarly, the musical A Chorus Line (1975) by Marvin Hamlisch and Edward Kleban, and Harvey Fierstein’s La Cage aux Folles (1983) and Torch Song Trilogy (1978-1979), further liberated the portrayal of gay lives on stage. The explicit opening scene of Torch Song Trilogy stands as a testament to the evolving openness and authenticity in gay theater following the cultural watershed of Stonewall.
Further expanding the narrative canvas was The Harvey Milk Show, a musical by Dan Pruitt and Patrick Hutchison that premiered in 1991. It dramatizes the life of Harvey Milk, the openly gay San Francisco city supervisor who was assassinated by Dan White, an off-duty policeman. The show serves as an allegorical critique of homophobia, echoing the hostility driven by figures like Anita Bryant and her Save the Children campaign. Within this framework, Milk is portrayed as a Christ-like figure who, despite his martyrdom, leaves an enduring, positive impact on society. This allegorical depiction underscores a broader societal commentary on the transformative and redemptive power of diverse narratives in theater.
The Drama of AIDS
The emergence of the AIDS epidemic in the early 1980s profoundly impacted contemporary gay drama, transforming it into a powerful medium for storytelling and social commentary. The epidemic, claiming countless lives, particularly among gay men, inspired playwrights to craft narratives that both highlighted the devastation of the disease and challenged societal perceptions of homosexuality. One of the most notable contributions came from American playwright Tony Kushner, whose works Angels in America: A Gay Fantasia on National Themes (Part One: Millennium Approaches and Part Two: Perestroika) captivated audiences globally. Premiering in the early 1990s, these plays not only illuminated the complexities of gay life but also educated broader audiences about the human experience beyond stereotypes.
Before Kushner’s plays reached the stage, Ron Cowen's An Early Frost, produced in 1985, had already brought the poignant realities of AIDS into American living rooms via television. This groundbreaking work was one of the first to address the epidemic head-on, reaching a diverse audience and widening the scope of understanding about the disease.
In 1993, Paul Rudnick's play Jeffrey further explored the societal and personal challenges posed by AIDS. The protagonist, a food server in his thirties, grapples with the necessity to abandon the casual sexual encounters that had defined much of his adult life. The play takes a turn when Jeffrey meets Steve, an HIV-positive man, compelling him to confront his deepest fears. Rudnick artfully demonstrates that the greatest hurdle for Jeffrey is not the virus itself, but his own reluctance to adapt to a world transformed by the epidemic.
This body of drama collectively sought to dismantle the misconception of AIDS as a "gay disease" or divine punishment imposed on those deemed different. Instead, these narratives underscored the fear and heartbreak wrought by an illness that stripped individuals of their sexual liberty and, all too often, of their cherished loved ones. Through these stories, the theatrical world emphasized that the true adversary was not homosexuality, but homophobia—a deeply ingrained prejudice that the arts have steadily challenged.
As gay drama progressed in confronting these themes, it delivered a crucial message to society: the issue at hand was not the existence of homosexuality but rather the intolerance and discrimination faced by the LGBTQ+ community. While homophobia has not been eradicated, the visibility and acceptance gained through the efforts of playwrights and their works have fostered greater acceptance in many parts of the Western world, marking a significant cultural shift through the medium of theater.