Student Question
Can Gandhi's life be considered a success in terms of the Platonic notion in the Gorgias?
Quick answer:
Gandhi's life can be seen as a success in terms of the Platonic notion of justice from the "Gorgias" because he acted justly through his philosophy and practice of non-violence, aligning with Plato's idea of not committing injustice. Despite mixed outcomes—successfully ending British rule but facing sectarian violence in India—his influence in ending apartheid in South Africa and his ethical stance demonstrate alignment with Platonic ideals of justice.
Mahatma Gandhi's life can be considered a success in many ways. The most
obvious is that the two major goals for which he struggled were both achieved.
The first major political goal for which he fought was for equal treatment for
"coloureds" (Indians and people of mixed race) in South Africa. South African
apartheid, after a prolonged struggle, has ended, and Gandhi very much
influenced people like Archbishop Tutu and Nelson Mandela who were architects
of its demise.
In India, Gandhi's main objectives were end of British colonial rule and end of
sectarian violence. Although Gandhi could be considered successful in ending
British rule, partition and ongoing sectarian violence would both be considered
failures or disappointments.
From a Platonic point of view, his own philosophy and practice of non-violence
would have been successes in acting justly, whatever the outcomes of his
actions, because success under the Platonic definition of acting justly is
concerned with not committing injustice.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.