Historical Context
The Great Depression
Flagg's novel touches on several historical periods, but it mainly focuses on
the time after the café opened in the summer of 1929. On October 15, 1929, Dot
Weems reports, "By the way, is it just my imagination or are times getting
harder these days? Five new hobos showed up at the café last week." These hard
times are a consequence of what John Galbraith describes as a "fundamentally
unsound" economy. Only five percent of the American population receives thirty
percent of all personal income. The thriving economy is driven by an overly
productive industrial sector. Just two weeks after Dot Weems's observation, the
stock market crashes on "Black Tuesday," October 29. Millions lose their jobs,
and meals of dandelions and ketchup become commonplace.
In the 1930s, people flood the highways in search of work, while new airplanes are tested overhead. The railroad industry thrives due to increased travel. The Great Migration is in full swing as African Americans move from the rural South to Northern factories. Many who hit the road remain transient for extended periods. Socialism gains acceptance among those deeply affected by poverty. Franklin Roosevelt is elected on the strength of his innovative social programs. The economy begins to recover, but it is World War II and the prosperous years under Truman and Eisenhower that restore prosperity to America and the world.
Race Relations
In the 1980s, the American Civil Rights era is considered over as a
conservative backlash emerges. Civil rights leaders are caught off-guard. White
middle-class voters, feeling that the changes of the previous decades were too
rapid, elect conservative candidate Ronald Reagan. U.S. Supreme Court Justice
Thurgood Marshall, disagreeing with the view that Reagan saved the nation, said
regarding equal rights for blacks, "Honestly, I think he's down there with
Hoover and that group, when we really didn't have a chance."
A troubling sign of the times is the increase in hate crimes throughout the decade. Neo-Nazi groups and the Ku Klux Klan gain new members after a long decline. There is a race riot in Miami, and Vernon Jordan, head of the National Urban League, is shot and wounded in 1980. Between 1985 and 1987, the year Fried Green Tomatoes is published, the Southern Poverty Law Center reports forty-five cases of arson and cross burnings. From 1986 to 1988, racially motivated incidents on campuses rise to 163 per year. The Reverend Jesse Jackson, regarded by some as a successor to Martin Luther King Jr., runs as a Democratic presidential candidate, while David Duke, a former grand wizard of the Klan, wins a seat as a Republican representative in the Louisiana legislature.
Religion
In the 1980s, the Christian fundamentalist movement began to challenge many of
the social changes from the 1950s and 1960s. Mainline Protestantism was
overshadowed, and in some states, high school science classes were required to
teach the biblical creation story alongside the theory of evolution. However,
the fundamentalist movement encountered significant issues in the mid-1980s.
Televangelist Jim Baker, leader of PTL Ministries, misappropriated church funds
to pay off his mistress, Fawn Hall. He was succeeded by Jimmy Swaggart, who
later admitted to adultery and stepped down. Due to these scandals,
fundamentalist churches lost nearly five billion dollars. With the collapse of
the Iron Curtain at the end of the 1980s, Christian broadcasting significantly
expanded its global influence.
Literary Style
Episodes
An episode typically refers to a short segment of action within a larger narrative that can be distinct from the main work. It's akin to a parenthetical remark. The term originates from the Greek word "epeisodion," which means "following upon the entrance." In Greek drama, an episode takes...
(This entire section contains 728 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
place between choric songs. Initially, the chorus consisted of fifty or more men, but by the time of Christopher Marlowe's "Doctor Faustus" (1604), it had been reduced to a single man delivering a prologue and epilogue.
In Flagg's novel, multiple choruses and numerous episodes are narrated by a third-person omniscient narrator. The most objective chorus is made up of news clippings. Another chorus is the dialogue between Evelyn and Mrs. Threadgoode, who, in true choric fashion, comment on the characters' heroic deeds. Between these choruses, the stories of the residents of Whistle Stop are detailed. Only by considering all three components together can readers grasp the full drama of Whistle Stop.
Comedy
Flagg, a successful comedian, incorporates humor into her writing. In Fried
Green Tomatoes, she uses humor to alleviate the darker, more depressing
moments. Clear examples include Idgie's tales or Sipsey's superstitions.
However, comedy allows Flagg to navigate risky topics and effectively present
both sides of a conflict. A prime example is the confrontation between Grady
and Idgie. When he tells her to stop selling to "niggers," she retorts that she
"ought to" just like Grady should stop cheating on his wife. This revelation of
hypocrisy is made possible because it is delivered with a smile between two
friends.
As Flagg mentioned in an interview: "Oh yes. I suffer from what most humorists do, a deep need to be taken seriously. And I have to grab her by the neck and shake her and say 'Oh, shut up,' just tell the story and stop preaching. But writing humor is very serious and hard. Still, I find a novel without humor is not interesting to me. Life is, after all, very funny. If I did not really believe that I would jump off a building tomorrow."
Characterization
According to E. M. Forster, there are flat and round characters. The
distinction is that flat characters remain simple, while round characters gain
complexity over the course of a novel. Flagg's story is filled with round
characters. She manages to depict the development of a wide array of characters
in a brief period. For instance, it takes only two pages to recount the entire
story of the Adcocks, leaving readers with a complete understanding of their
lives. With a comedian's touch, Flagg describes Mrs. Adcock as the president of
the "I'm Better Than Anyone Else Club." Unfortunately, readers don't need much
more information to fully comprehend this character, as everyone knows someone
like Mrs. Adcock.
Flagg's narration is enriched by the continuous commentary of Mrs. Threadgoode. Mrs. Threadgoode does not serve as an alternate narrator; instead, she exemplifies what Mikhail Bakhtin calls a character zone. Character zones occur when a character's voice overlaps with the author's, allowing them to influence each other's words. While Flagg's narrative revolves around a café, Mrs. Threadgoode, as her husband notes, focuses solely on Idgie.
Trickster
The trickster is a universal archetype that behaves similarly across different
cultures, whether in the Pacific Northwest or Australia. This figure has been
represented as Loki in Norway, a hare in Sudan, a spider, turtle, or human in
Africa, and a coyote or raven in America. Often a supernatural entity capable
of shape-shifting, the trickster is a cyclical hero—alternating between creator
god, duplicitous fool, and destroyer. Trickster tales typically follow the
character on a picaresque adventure, where they encounter situations that
require a witty or foolish response. A clever response leads to victory, while
a foolish one results in violent death. A well-known example in the American
South is Joel Chandler Harris's Brer Rabbit stories, narrated by the fictional
Uncle Remus.
In Flagg's novel, life's journey is the adventure, and Idgie embodies the trickster. She tells stories, plays pranks, and laughs. She puts Smokey Lonesome at ease with a ludicrous tale and teaches Ruth's son through stories and personal example. Idgie takes on the persona of Railroad Bill to redistribute wealth. Through her cunning and high alcohol tolerance, she manages to bring an elephant to Naughty Bird. Additionally, she possesses the remarkable ability to charm bees into giving her honey.
Literary Techniques
Flagg's narrative transitions seamlessly between past and present, presenting her story through brief chapters that offer snapshots of action. These glimpses are either memories recounted by Ninny Threadgoode in the 1980s or conveyed by an omniscient narrator. The book's first half introduces the setting and characters, hinting at the reasons behind a murder, while the second half delves into solving the mystery. Additional context is provided through contemporary newspaper columns from 1929 to 1969, written by Dot Weems, who comments on the people and events in the Whistle Stop community. By the story's end, readers realize that Weems omits critical information to protect her husband Wilbur and his friends from their dubious activities covering up crimes. Separate sections of the Slagtown News Flotsam & Jetsam offer insights into the African-American members of the Whistle Town community, highlighting the era's segregation. Each chapter is labeled with a header indicating the source of the information, the location of the action—such as the Rose Terrace Nursing Home and private residences—or geographical settings crucial to the plot and character development, including Valdosta, Georgia; Chicago, Illinois; and Davenport, Iowa. References to real roads and services, like the Old Montgomery Highway and radio station WAPI, lend authenticity and relatability to the story.
This literary style immerses readers into Flagg's fictional world. By perusing newspaper accounts and listening in on Ninny's storytelling sessions with Evelyn, readers feel as though they are witnessing events in real-time. Flagg's adept use of southern dialect, including idioms and accents true to that region of Alabama, enriches the novel. While some word choices and passages might seem antiquated, Flagg's dialogue convincingly captures the early twentieth-century Deep South, fostering a nostalgic acceptance of her characters' world. The characters appear entirely authentic and realistic. Although they may remind readers of southern figures in popular culture, Flagg's main characters avoid succumbing to stereotypical behaviors and responses to crises, offering a more genuine glimpse into the complexities of individuality and conformity in the modern South. Flagg demonstrates how simple acts, like cooking a meal, have intricate layers that resonate universally, regardless of where readers are from.
Familiar with the Birmingham area, Flagg incorporates elements of the sophisticated urban landscape, such as the massive statue of Vulcan and the steel mills that illuminated the sky, providing a stark contrast to the whimsical rural scenery of Whistle Stop, with its wisteria and sweetheart roses. She skillfully uses the juxtaposition of the Ku Klux Klan disrupting the preparation of nurturing meals at the cafe to illustrate the coexistence of good and evil.
Her vivid imagery and use of figurative language are so powerful that readers feel as if they can taste the buttermilk biscuits and smell the barbecue cooking at Idgie's cafe. They can almost hear the frictional whine of train wheels against the rails as the train slows down to bring Wonderful Counselor's body home. Readers envision themselves sitting next to Ninny, listening to her weave stories, or laughing at Idgie's tall tales in the cafe. They are also eager to piece together the clues about the mysterious secrets concerning the characters' pasts.
Flagg's imaginative writing evokes strong emotional responses from readers, ranging from tears to laughter.
Ideas for Group Discussions
Set in the South, both during and after segregation, Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe delves into friendships that defy age, gender, racial, cultural, and socioeconomic barriers. The story highlights community and humanity in a town where people are valued more than wealth, and kindness shields the vulnerable from hatred.
1. Examine how the fictional newspaper articles separating the chapters enhance the narrative by providing information and clues about the resolution of subplots and the main plot. How do these articles disrupt the storytelling? Are the shifting scene dates across different decades confusing?
2. Is Ninny Threadgoode's narrative credible? Why should Evelyn Couch and the readers trust Mrs. Threadgoode's story? What reasons might Ninny have for altering facts? Evelyn notices clues like Ninny's inside-out dress, purple-dyed hair, and signs of Alzheimer's disease. How does this affect readers' perception of Ninny's reliability?
3. What insights does the book offer about the evolution of racism from the early twentieth century to the 1980s? In what ways have racial relations stagnated according to the text? How do details such as an African-American newspaper and soldiers, Clarissa passing for white and ignoring her Uncle Artis, the whites-only laundry truck, and the use of the freight elevator enhance or distract from Flagg's storytelling? How has the South changed or stayed the same?
4. Discuss how the characterization of women in this book reflects societal attitudes towards women and feminism throughout the twentieth century. How are Eva and Ruth similar and different? What about Idgie and Evelyn? What does this book contribute to the understanding of friendship and love between women?
5. Compare the lifestyles of the twins, Jasper and Artis, and how this contributes to plot development. Does their disparity seem unrealistic and stereotypical? Is Artis more like the abusive Frank Bennett than his own family?
6. Why do characters, including law enforcement officers, often disregard legal procedures? Are various forms of vigilantism acceptable? Is Idgie's Robin Hood-like role as Railroad Bill justifiable because it helped starving people? Should Sipsey be forgiven for her crime because it was committed in self-defense? Why might her contemporaries have treated her with contempt and punishment instead of mercy and understanding?
7. Discuss the role of lies, tall tales, and pranks in this book. Which characters appear to be the most deceptive? Which ones seem the most honest? Why does Reverend Scroggins lie at Idgie's trial?
8. Explain the significance of train imagery in this book. How do trains impact individuals' lives? In what ways is the railroad integrated into the community? How does the railroad foreshadow death and murder, such as the transportation of the executed murderer Seymore Pinto or the murdered body of Wonderful Counselor?
9. How does Ninny Threadgoode serve as the catalyst for Evelyn's epiphany and her spiritual, emotional, and physical transformation? In what ways does Evelyn bring about changes in Ninny?
10. Discuss how Whistle Stop, Alabama, represents the human life cycle. Expand on the portrayal of aging and homelessness in the book, and how these aspects are connected to the decline of small towns in rural America. What are the different characters' perspectives on death, and under what circumstances do they find ending a life acceptable? How do they respond to the downfall of Whistle Stop?
Compare and Contrast
1930s: African Americans are relegated to second-class citizenship. In the South, the doctrine of "separate but equal" enforces this status.
1980s: Civil Rights laws and affirmative action initiatives have created opportunities for African Americans, offering legal remedies for victims of racial discrimination.
Today: Affirmative action has been successfully repealed in some areas of the country. Other civil rights laws are under threat, and Congress has yet to pass a federal hate-crimes statute.
1930s: President Warren Harding maintains a mistress and illicitly transfers naval oil reserves at Teapot Dome, WY, to the Department of the Interior. These reserves are then leased to Harry G. Sinclair of Sinclair Oil. A Senate investigation reveals that Sinclair and Edward L. Doheny had lent substantial sums to Albert B. Fall, the Secretary of the Interior. In 1927, the Supreme Court orders the oil fields to be returned to the U.S. government.
1980s: The Reagan administration illegally sells arms and drugs to Iran, via Israel, to finance the Contras in their efforts to overthrow Nicaragua's leftist government.
Today: President Clinton's extramarital affair with intern Monica Lewinsky nearly leads to his impeachment.
1930s: Iraq, no longer under Ottoman rule, becomes a British mandate.
1980s: Western nations support Iraq in its conflict with Iran.
Today: The West enforces sanctions on Iraq until it dismantles its weapons of mass destruction.
1930s: President Roosevelt establishes the "welfare state" with the Social Security Act of 1935.
1980s: Republicans begin to push for the dismantling of the "welfare state," promoting a narrative of welfare fraud involving "welfare queens" driving luxury cars.
Today: Welfare "as we know it" has been terminated, yet no funds were allocated to monitor the outcomes for former recipients. As a result, the success of welfare reform is uncertain, but there has been an increase in homeless shelter usage.
1930s: Apartheid, a regime of white supremacy, is established in South Africa.
1980s: The African National Congress intensifies its military campaign against the apartheid regime.
Today: Apartheid has been abolished and Nelson Mandela serves as the president.
Literary Precedents
Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe is a prime example of the southern gothic genre. It masterfully blends elements of romance, mystery, humor, and horror to craft a compelling narrative filled with unique and unconventional characters that captivate and intrigue readers. This literary tradition has roots in the oral storytelling of the rural South, where ghost stories and tall tales were shared as a means of communication and bonding among neighbors and travelers in isolated areas. These stories often featured familiar archetypes, such as heroes and villains, allowing listeners to see reflections of their own lives in the tales. This recognition fostered empathy and friendships, essential for building thriving communities like Whistle Stop.
Flagg's characters might have noticed themes in Edgar Allan Poe's thrillers that echoed the eerie events they encountered. Poe himself would likely have been intrigued by the dark undercurrents in Whistle Stop and the gradual decay of its people and structures, both institutional and physical. Flagg employs gothic techniques to surprise her readers with unexpected twists, such as the mystery surrounding Frank Bennett's death, and peculiar situations, like the garden filled with animal heads that remained intact for decades. She skillfully weaves humor with tragedy, kindness with cruelty, and forgiveness with revenge, following the tradition of other notable southern writers. For instance, Truman Capote's The Grass Harp (1951) depicted a sense of extended family and community in rural Alabama. Lesser-known Alabama authors also explored themes of kinship, belonging, and exclusion in stories that predate Flagg's novel. Leila Warren's Foundation Stone (1950) and Whetstone Walls (1952) chronicled the challenges of an Alabama family, while Caroline Ivey's The Family (1952) revealed the betrayals tied to love experienced by Shelby Olmstead Crawford in southeastern Alabama.
Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird (1960) examined the interactions between whites and blacks in Depression-era Alabama, similar to Flagg's novel, with an alleged crime and trial serving as crucial plot points. In many respects, Scout Finch mirrors the tomboyish Idgie Threadgoode. Both female characters defy traditional gender expectations and pursue their interests with little concern for societal opinions. Additionally, Smokey Lonesome and Boo Radley are both reclusive, misunderstood figures. Other significant works that may have influenced Flagg include the southern fiction of William Faulkner, Flannery O'Connor, Carson McCullers, and Eudora Welty, all of whom portrayed southern families as flawed yet largely unified, often incorporating elements of mystery or horror. Alabama writer Shirley Ann Grau penned dark stories about the realities of family life, while Birmingham native Gail Godwin authored several southern gothic sagas that share themes and tones with Flagg's novel. Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind (1936) also explored the role of family and place in sustaining individuals despite uncontrollable challenges and disruptions.
Adaptations
Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe has been produced in two audio cassette editions. In 1992, Fannie Flagg narrated an audio version that included the novel's full text. An abridged audiotape, also read by Flagg, was released in 2000. Flagg received a Grammy Award nomination for Best Spoken Word. She also compiled Fannie Flagg's Original Whistlestop Cafe Cookbook: Featuring: Fried Green Tomatoes, Southern Barbecue, Banana Split Cake, and Many Other Great Recipes (1985). Additionally, Mary Jo Smith McMichael published the Irondale Cafe Original Whistlestop Cookbook in 1995. McMichael's business, the Whistle Stop Cafe (http://www.whistlestopcafe.com), located in Irondale, Alabama, sells book-related merchandise along with foodstuffs and ingredients. Elizabeth Gareis compiled the Fried Green Tomatoes: Teacher's Manual in 1998.
Flagg co-wrote a screenplay with Carol Sobieski for a film adaptation of her novel. Titled Fried Green Tomatoes, the movie was produced by Universal Pictures and released in 1991. The screenplay won the Scripters Award and was nominated for the Writers Guild of America Best Screenplay Award and an Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay. While Flagg's novel garnered critical acclaim in literary circles, the movie gained widespread popularity among mainstream audiences. Due to Flagg's involvement, the film retained much of the novel's characterization and plot. However, significant changes were made for dramatic effect. Newspaper articles were replaced by flashbacks, showing events as they happened instead of reporting them as snippets of human interest.
The movie visually depicted the scenery and settings that Flagg had elaborately described in her novel. Some characters were omitted to allow viewers to focus on the relationships between Idgie and Ruth, and Evelyn and Ninny, and to understand the events surrounding Frank Bennett's disappearance. The intricate details of Flagg's text, including vivid tours of Birmingham, puns, and clever names, could not be fully translated to film.
Director Jon Avnet skillfully expanded Flagg's technique of alternating between present and past by focusing on Ninny's conversations with Evelyn, interspersed with scenes from Evelyn's daily life and vignettes of Idgie's and Ruth's friendship within the Whistle Stop community. Unlike the book, which emphasizes Evelyn's transformation spurred by her awareness of different women's lives through Ninny's perspective, the film centers on Ninny, the storyteller, and her connections to the Threadgoodes.
The movie does not strictly adhere to the book's timeline. For instance, the film places greater emphasis on the trial and depicts Idgie as a young woman shortly after the crime, rather than twenty years later when charges were actually filed. Frank Bennett's truck is discovered early in the film, serving as Ninny's introduction of Evelyn to the citizens of Whistle Stop. Relationships are modified, such as Evelyn visiting her husband's aunt instead of her mother-in-law at the nursing home. These situational changes help streamline the film, offering clearer scenarios and explanations of the book's complex plot.
In the film, Idgie is present in the room when Ruth dies, contrasting with the novel where Idgie's absence allows for Onzell's mercy killing. Additionally, Ninny moves in with the Couches, and both Evelyn and Ninny visit Whistle Stop together, unlike Evelyn's solo trip in the book. The movie diverges from the book in three significant ways: Idgie's and Ruth's lesbian relationship is toned down; Evelyn is portrayed as an unattractive housewife seeking her husband's attention rather than pursuing self-development and acceptance; and Ninny is revealed to be Idgie.
The film's cast—especially the female leads Jessica Tandy, Kathy Bates, Mary Stuart Masterson, and Mary-Louise Parker—effectively bring Flagg's characters to life. Non-verbal actions, such as facial expressions, provide viewers with insights into the characters' motivations and opinions that words, whether in the novel or spoken as dialogue, cannot fully convey. The movie became a box-office success, resonating with audiences' nostalgia and desire for friendship and community. Critics praised the film adaptation, which benefited from Flagg's background as an actress. Tandy earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress for her portrayal of Ninny. The movie Fried Green Tomatoes was later released on videotape and DVD, featuring additional footage on the making of the film, interviews, and recipes.
Media Adaptations
Released by Universal Studios in 1991, Fried Green Tomatoes features Jessica Tandy and Kathy Bates in the leading roles. The screenplay was crafted by Fannie Flagg and director/producer Joe Avnet. The script earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Screenplay Adapted from Material Previously Produced or Published. Filming took place in Juliette, Georgia. The movie garnered widespread acclaim for its performances and its skillful depiction of various historical periods. Fannie Flagg also makes a brief appearance as a teacher.
In 1992, Fannie Flagg narrated the audio edition of the work. Her recording of Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café won her a Grammy Award.
Bibliography and Further Reading
Sources
Carolyn Banks, "Down-Home News & Blues," in The Washington Post,
October 5, 1987, p. B10.
Erica Bauermeister, Jesse Larson, and Holly Smith, in 500 Great Books by Women: A Reader's Guide, Penguin USA, 1995.
Jack Butler, "Love with Reticence and Recipes," in The New York Times, October 18, 1987, p. 14.
Gayle Kidder, "Flagg Writes about Real South," in The San Diego Union-Tribune, November 12, 1987, p. C-1.
Orlando Ramirez, "Flagg Displays Depth, Intellect in Café," in The San Diego Union-Tribune, January 15, 1988, p. C-3.
Carolyn See, "Book Review; Fannie Flagg Offers Tale Full of Nostalgia," in The Los Angeles Times, September 28, 1987, p. 4.
Samuel S. Vaughan, in A Conversation with Fannie Flagg, Ballantine Reader's Circle, 1998, http://www.random-house.com/BB/readerscircle/flagg/excerptguide.html.
For Further Study
Bruce Bibby, in Premiere, February 1992, pp. 33—4.
In this interview, Flagg discusses the female characters in her book.
Rosellen Brown, "Why Audiences Hunger for 'Fried Green Tomatoes,'" New
York Times Current Events Edition, April 19, 1992, p. 2.
This article delves into the theme of friendship in the novel, commending its
portrayal of "real women who band together in an unspoken conspiracy of
affection."
Jack Butler, in The New York Times Book Review, August 20, 1992, p.
14.
Butler lauds Flagg's sensitive depiction of the love affair between Idgie and
Ruth, as well as her accurate portrayal of small-town life during the
Depression.
Fannie Flagg, Fannie Flagg's Original Whistle Stop Café Cookbook,
Fawcett, 1993.
Flagg has published a comprehensive cookbook of southern café recipes.
Renee Hartman, a review of Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop
Café, in Belles Lettres, Vol. 4, No. 1, Fall, 1988, p. 6.
Hartman emphasizes the novel's realism, praising it as a "chronicle of life in
a small town."
R. Kent Rasmussen and Kent Rasmussen, Farewell to Jim Crow: The Rise and
Fall of Segregation in America (Library of African-American History),
Facts on File, Inc., 1997.
This work explores segregation from its origins in colonial Virginia through
the passage of the Civil Rights Act in 1964, highlighting the African-American
struggle for legal equality.
Sybil Steinberg, a review of Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop
Café, in Publishers Weekly, August 28, 1987, pp. 64-5.
Steinberg identifies "the book's best character [to be] the town of Whistle
Stop itself."
Diane Young, a review of Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop
Café, in Southern Living, January, 1995, p. 78.
Young's favorable review describes this "folksy tale" as
written with "heart, humor, and insight."