Last Updated on June 2, 2020, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 454
Erasmus begins On the Freedom of the Will with the following quotation:
Among the difficulties, of which not a few pop up in Holy Scripture, there is hardly a more tangled labyrinth than “free choice,” for it is a subject that has long exercised the minds of philosophers.
Free will, or “free choice,” as Erasmus calls it, is the subject of a spirited debate between Erasmus and Martin Luther. Essentially, Erasmus rejected the idea that human beings were predestined by God for salvation or damnation. This idea had recently been defended by Martin Luther and many of his followers, and Erasmus’s essay on free will is a explicit rejoinder to this concept. In this passage, he acknowledges that the debate on free will is one that is fundamental to Western philosophy, not just to Christian theology. For both Erasmus and Luther, it is a central aspect of man’s relationship with God.
Suppose for a moment that it were true that... “God works in us good and evil, and rewards his own good works in us, and punishes his evil works in us”; what a window to impiety would the public avowal of such an opinion open to countless morals!
Here, Erasmus is arguing that if Luther’s argument against free will is followed to its logical conclusion, then there is really nothing keeping people from behaving as they would like. All sorts of evil could be justified by saying, in a sense, “God made me do it.” Without free will, there is no responsibility, and without responsibility, Erasmus argues, God would be arbitrarily punishing people who had no control over their actions. People could not possibly love such a capricious God,...
(The entire section contains 454 words.)
Unlock This Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this On the Freedom of the Will study guide. You'll get access to all of the On the Freedom of the Will content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.