Discussion Topic

Portrayal and representation of women in Frankenstein

Summary:

In Frankenstein, women are portrayed and represented as passive, submissive, and secondary to men. Female characters like Elizabeth, Justine, and Safie are often depicted as victims of male actions and societal expectations, highlighting the limited roles and lack of agency afforded to women during the time period in which the novel was written.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How are women represented in Frankenstein?

Despite the fact that Frankenstein was written by a woman (Mary Shelley), women's voices are largely absent in the text. The story is a frame narrative told by Robert Walton, Victor Frankenstein, and Frankenstein's monster. While women are present in the story—such as Elizabeth, Justine, Safie, and the monster's unfinished mate—they are generally relegated to being minor characters, plot devices, or servants to men. Looking at the four aforementioned characters shows how this is the case.

Elizabeth, for instance, is to be Victor's wife. In Shelley's first description of Elizabeth, she is described as "docile and good tempered ... no one could better enjoy liberty, yet no one could submit with more grace." Her submissive qualities are highlighted, and the rest of the paragraph used to describe her continues to talk about her affectionate and subservient nature. Further, she is ultimately murdered at the hands of a man (the monster).

Similarly, Justine plays the role of servant to the Frankenstein family. Justine is described as a provider of happiness to Victor: "if you were in an ill humour, one glance from Justine could dissipate it." She is also killed. In this way, both Justine and Elizabeth are submissive and relatively two-dimensional characters who exist generally to make men happy and serve as plot devices to be murdered at the hands of the monster.

Safie, Felix's betrothed, is a Turkish woman. Her presence exists as a convenient plot device to teach the monster English. However, especially during the early 1800s, when the novel was written, she also represents an exotic, "Oriental" object (see Edward Said's book Orientalism). This exotic element must be removed, and thus she is acculturated by learning English.

Finally, the monster's wife is never given life by Frankenstein. In fact, her body is destroyed at his hands. While the male monster is allowed to receive life by the god-figure of Victor, the female counterpart is not afforded this right, and again, this destruction of the woman figure acts as a plot device to spur the monster into a murderous rage.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How are women portrayed in Frankenstein?

For the most part, it would appear that the female characters in Frankenstein—which include Justine Moritz (young William's governess) and Elizabeth (Victor's love and confidant)—are little more than victims whose untimely deaths provide turning points for the plot; slated for the Monster's murderous "conquests." The protagonist of this story is a man, and to a certain extent the reader could see it as a cautionary tale against masculine hubris. The implication is that men of science, in seeking to reorder Nature's act of creation, cannot help but see their plans go violently awry.

Another female spirit that influences the trajectory of the plot is the Monster's mate, but she's an abandoned abstraction—a further betrayal by Victor toward his wraithlike progeny—and not a character.

However, Mary Shelley's own life must have been informed by the structure and synthesis of contemporary (to the 1800s) affairs. Elizabeth is a credible stand-in for Mary Shelley herself, in that she has a formidable, questing intellect and is a possible foil for Victor's dogged scientific pursuits. While I’m not pointing to a direct equivalence between Shelley and Elizabeth, Elizabeth is a dimensional being in the novel, hardly one of the scream queens that she's reduced to in Frankenstein’s numerous media adaptions.

The novel has been seen as a cornerstone work in Women's Studies. Frankenstein scholar Susan Tyler Hitchcock notes that there were a considerable number of women-of-letters during the developmental era of the novel, but—as they were flying in the face of convention—they tended to publish under pseudonyms.

Barnard College professor Ellen Moers directly links Shelley's life experience (as a pregnant sixteen-year-old) with the creation of Frankenstein and has:

proposed a new feminist definition of the Gothic as literature whose purpose is to "to scare" by reaching "down into the depths of the soul" and getting "to the body itself, . . . quickly arousing and quickly allaying the physiological reactions to fear. (Frankenstein: A Cultural History, Hitchcock.)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial