Student Question
Discuss the quote "Bacon is the wisest, brightest and meanest" in relation to Pope's An Essay on Man.
Quick answer:
The quote "Bacon is the wisest, brightest and meanest" in relation to Pope's An Essay on Man highlights Sir Francis Bacon's complex character. Pope acknowledges Bacon's wisdom and brilliance, but also his moral failings. Bacon's contemporaries recognized his intellect and philosophical insights, while also noting his self-serving actions. Some, like Alfred Dodd, suggest "meanest" might mean "humblest," though others, such as Macaulay, saw it as ignoble.
Alexander Pope, in Epistle IV of his Essay on Man, refers to Sir Francis Bacon as "the wisest, brightest, meanest of mankind" (281-282). This character reference of Bacon's is referred to in many other essays.
Sir Walter Raleigh, in "Frances Bacon to King James I," discusses Bacon's notorious life. Bacon confessed to being corrupt and negligent, during his time with the House of Lords, yet he denied that he had ever "perverted justice." Regardless of Bacon's infractions of the law, Raleigh called Bacon prolific, witty, and profoundly philosophical. These statements suggest Bacon's wise and bright nature.
Bacon's peers would not readily disagree with the idea that Bacon was wise. For example, Bacon offered the following advice on revenge: "One who studith revenge keeps his own wounds green, which otherwise would heal and do well." This wisdom illustrated his brightness. For example, "A lie faces God and shrinks from man."
Lastly, Bacon was the meanest. Bacon was a man out for himself. His friendships were made in order to advance his own career, and his marriage was one of convenience. Bacon even wrote a letter which openly flattered the King and Queen.
"The Martyrdom of Frances Bacon," written by Alfred Dodd, also brings up Bacon's intelligence, brightness, and meanness. In this essay, Dodd rebukes some critics' assertions that Bacon is mean. Instead, Dodd offers readers another definition of meanest. According to Dodd, Pope used the term meanest to mean "humblest." One man who did claim Bacon to be mean (ignoble) was Macaulay. Yet given Macaulay's own notorious nature, the University of Oxford deemed all his work "not trustworthy."
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.
References