The Four Winds Themes
The main themes in The Four Winds are prejudice, love and family, and the American dream.
- Prejudice: In California, the Martinellis face the dehumanizing prejudice directed against “Okies,” which allows wealthy farm owners to exploit their workers.
- Love and family: While Elsa is emotionally wounded by her birth family, she is strengthened by her loving relationships with Rose and Tony, Loreda and Ant, and Jack Valen.
- The American dream: The characters’ faith in the American dream is first threatened by the Dust Bowl and then by the conditions in California, where opportunities are denied to migrants.
Prejudice
Jack states that whenever people are afraid for their own circumstances, those in power shift the blame to the easiest target: outsiders. During the Great Depression, Californians worried about losing their jobs and homes, so the wealthy elite began to blame undocumented Mexican immigrants for allegedly draining state resources. Although this wasn’t true, people believed the propaganda, and the Mexican immigrants upon whom the agricultural industry had long relied were deported. The same sort of prejudice is leveled at the Great Plains migrants who arrive in California looking to escape the ravages of the Dust Bowl. Rather than being viewed as fellow American citizens, the so-called Okies are looked down upon as invaders. This is demoralizing and disheartening for the migrants, who view themselves as proud Americans, ready and willing to work. Furthermore, the negative stereotypes about “Okies” bar them from pursuing opportunities for employment and housing, trapping them in the cycle of seasonal agricultural labor and serving the interests of the wealthy crop growers.
Prejudice is dehumanizing, as it denies the common humanity of those toward whom it is directed. It is this dehumanization that paves the way for labor exploitation, violence, and other injustices. Even children have been taught to look down on the migrants, as evidenced by Loreda and Ant’s experiences at school. This ensures that no one will come to the defence of the workers, even as it is revealed that they are being underpaid or abused. Indeed, despite Jack’s best efforts, the attendees at the Welty town hall meeting throw him out, content to blame the migrant workers for all of the socioeconomic ills facing California.
Love and Family
Family is depicted as a source of both hurt and comfort, capable of building a person up or tearing them down. Elsa’s birth family keeps her isolated and repressed, convinced that she is too ugly to marry and too sickly to venture out on her own. In this environment, Elsa is meek and submissive, rarely speaking up for herself. On the rare occasion that she does so, she is met with anger, spite, and scorn, discouraging further attempts at independence.
When Elsa moves in with the Martinellis, she discovers what a family’s love can truly be like: Tony and Rose come to view Elsa as their own daughter, and they teach her to be strong, capable, and independent. Rose becomes Elsa’s constant companion, and Elsa turns to the older woman for help and advice. Nurtured by a caring family, Elsa grows as a person, finding within herself a “nearly limitless capacity for love.” However, the insecurities instilled in her by her birth family never truly leave her, indicating how a lack of love can do lasting damage. Many of these insecurities are reawakened and exacerbated by Loreda, who Elsa worries has found her “deficient” in the same way that her birth family did.
Elsa discovers the true importance of love in the days prior to her death, writing in her journal that “love is what remains when everything else is gone.” Having reconciled with Loreda and fallen in love with Jack, Elsa realizes that she is surrounded by love, both familial and romantic. For the first time in her life, she realizes that the love she has for others is fully reciprocated, and this gives her the courage to take over the microphone and inspire the strikers. Even though this moment of courage costs Elsa her life, she dies surrounded by her loved ones, happy and proud of the futures they have ahead of them. Years later, as Loreda leaves for college, she promises to...
(This entire section contains 343 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
carry her mother’s love and their shared dreams along with her.
The American Dream
Rose and Tony represent the early-twentieth-century ideal of the American dream. They arrived as immigrants with very little money, but with hard work and dedication, they became successful farmers. Elsa remarks that Rose and Tony, as well as Elsa herself, are the type of people who view hardship as a natural part of life. This enables them to survive even the most difficult of circumstances, as they retain the faith that no hardship can go on forever. The American penny that Tony found on the streets of Italy prior to his departure becomes a venerated family artifact through which dreams of prosperity are conveyed to the next generation. However, whereas Tony and Rose continue to have faith in their land and the dream that the United States represented to so many immigrants, Elsa, Rafe, and Loreda all begin to lose that faith as the drought and dust storms rage on.
The American dream takes on a new shape for Elsa and her children as they journey to California. Whereas Rose and Tony were able to make their dream a reality with “hard work and a fair chance,” Elsa discovers that poverty, prejudice, and capitalist greed have made it nearly impossible for Dust Bowl refugees to find success. Rather than being given the freedom to thrive, they are caught in vicious cycles of debt and poverty, forced to compromise their principles in order to survive. This is why Jack describes communism as “the new American way,” as it enables everyone, rich or poor, to have a fair chance at finding the sort of prosperity that the American dream has always offered to those willing to work for it.
Strength and Resilience
The Four Winds is suffused with hardships of all kinds, ranging from the emotional to the physical. Poverty, hunger, fear, grief, and loss follow the Martinellis throughout their journey, highlighting the myriad struggles faced by the real-life Great Plains migrants of the Dust Bowl era. However, for as much as struggle defines their journey, so, too, does resilience. When confronted by prejudice from the other mothers at the PTA meetings, Elsa finds within herself a spiteful sort of strength, and she takes the snack trays in order to feed both her own family and the Deweys. The meek, nonconfrontational Elsa of the past would not have attended the meeting at all, but her fierce love for her family and her own sense of pride helps her overcome her fears.
A major source of resilience comes from the community that the Martinellis find in California. For every moment of prejudice, there is also a moment of kindness and connection, such as when Betty Anne the hairdresser gives Elsa and her family a box of old clothes and agrees to cut Elsa and Loreda’s hair. Jean, too, becomes a source of strength for Elsa, and the quiet moments of camaraderie that they share enable her to continue working gruelingly long days in order to keep her children fed. Human connection and compassion help make life more bearable, and even the worst hardships seem more manageable when they are not faced alone.