1. Is Todd Andrews's decision to kill nearly everyone in the town believable, or does it feel forced by the author to make a point? Would readers find a more compassionate choice more aligned with Todd's character?

2. If Todd's father hadn't committed suicide, is it probable that Todd would have developed a more optimistic outlook on life?

3. Do the attitudes towards sex in this novel have any connection to love?

4. How should we interpret Mr. Haecker's suicide attempt at the end of the story? Is it unexpected? What is the dramatic purpose of such an act at the conclusion of a novel where a meticulously planned mass murder has just been prevented?

5. Could one argue that The Floating Opera would be more meaningful or enjoyable if Todd Andrews commented less frequently on how he is telling the story and simply narrated it?