What does the fish symbolize in Elizabeth Bishop's "The Fish"?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

One interpretation of "The Fish" by Elizabeth Bishop allows that the imagery of a rainbow of colors on the fish symbolizes the victory of the fish, which affects the epiphany of the speaker.

This epiphany begins with the speaker's realization of the great accomplishment of the old fish to have survived so long. Viewing the "medals with their ribbons" that the green and black lines seem to represent as well as the "five big hooks" that have "grown firmly" into his mouth, the poem's speaker begins to feel a sense of awe and respect for the old fish who has defeated several others who have tried to catch him. In addition, the speaker's emotions are aroused from examining the old fish and the light upon him as the speaker examines the "medals" which lead to the epiphany that this fish is a victor who deserves respect:

and victory filled up
the little rented boat

The steady progression of colors that seem to form a rainbow symbolize the victory of the fish over all those who have tried to conquer him. This victorious rainbow of all colors causes the speaker to have an epiphany that this venerable fish should be allowed to live and continue in his victories.

Until everything was rainbow, rainbow, rainbow!
And I let the fish go.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Well, the first option is that the fish doesn't symbolize anything at all. Never leave that option out, even in poetry. Some poems try to capture vivid experiences in vivid verse.  In that reading, the poet caught a fish that looked strange, stared at it, and let it go. Again, don't underestimate that. Confronting other forms of life can be striking and meaningful without metaphor.

But if we assume it is a metaphor, then we find its meaning in those vivid images: the beard, the speckling, the loose skin, the multiple fishhooks, the scarring, etc. In catching a fish, the narrator has accidentally confronted age and mortality. The fish looks old and scarred by life, and if she keeps it, it dies. Releasing it lets life continue (and denies mortality).

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In the poem "The Fish" by Elizabeth Bishop, what does the fish symbolize?  

One of the interesting things about "The Fish" is that the reader discovers the significant aspects of the fish as the speaker of the poem does. The other interesting device of the poem, in terms of style, is that the speaker reveals her understanding and appreciation for the fish through imagery. She, the speaker, withholds her thoughts and emotions until the very end of the poem. 

First, note that the poem is not about the "victory" of catching the fish. The entire poem is of the objective (eventually becoming subjective) perception of the fish. In objectively describing the fish, the speaker and the reader discover things which lead to a more subjective appreciation. 

Although the fish doesn't put up a fight, he continues to fight, to breathe that "terrible oxygen." Upon catching the fish, the speaker describes it as "battered and venerable / and homely." She has respect ("venerable") for this battered fish and feels pity for its plain, unattractive ("homely") look. This is the objective perspective becoming subjective and more personal. 

The speaker describes the fish's skin/scales like armor rusted over time, "shapes like full-blown roses / stained and lost through age." She describes the fish like an old warrior or an old warship adorned with barnacles and sea weed. Following these subtle praises of the evidence of the fish's history of survival, the speaker imagines the fish's colorful insides. She tries to intuit some meaning by looking into the fish's eyes but sees only a semi-transparent surface ("isinglass") which shows how she is struggling to achieve a personal understanding of the fish by making objective observations. 

Acknowledging the five hooks and fishing lines dangling from the fish's mouth, the speaker thinks of them as signs of wisdom and medals of valor: 

Like medals with their ribbons

frayed and wavering,

a five-haired beard of wisdom

trailing from his aching jaw. 

Realizing that this battered, rusted fish has battled to stay alive so many times, the speaker appreciates the fish's perseverance and appreciation for life. Seeing the rainbow dispersed on the surface of the oil, the speaker translates this abundance of color to vitality and symbolic vibrancy with which she thinks the fish must have lived. The fish might look like old brown wallpaper but it has come to symbolize the fullness of life which is comparable to the fullness of colors in a rainbow. It is now with this subjective perception (appreciating life in its full splendor of color and vitality) that she looks upon everything: the rusted engine, oarlocks, gunnels, and of course, the fish. 

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on