Richard Wilbur’s “First Snow in Alsace” consists of eight three-line stanzas and a final line that completes the rhyme scheme. The poem describes the first snowfall of winter in Alsace, as the title indicates. Alsace is a region of eastern France frequently the subject of border disputes between France and Germany. Alsace was ceded to Germany as a result of the Franco-Prussian War but restored to France after World War I. The area was occupied by Germany during most of World War II until French and U.S. troops recovered the territory for France in 1945. The references to “shellbursts,” gutted homes, and an ammunition pile make the time as clear as the place: This snowfall occurs in the midst of the hostilities of World War II. Wilbur served in Europe in the war, and he credits his war experiences with stimulating his career as a poet. Wilbur felt that only when one was faced with chaos did one discover the need for the ordering forces of art.
The first four stanzas vividly describe the beauty of the nighttime snowy scene, in which the evidence of war is transfigured by the delicacy of the snowfall. Stanza five places the reader in the poem, opening with “You think,” and speculating that the snow falls on the eyes of recently deceased soldiers still lying in fields. The next two stanzas describe “persons and persons in disguise” encountering the transformed landscape. Then the final stanza identifies a night guard returning from his post who cheerfully brags that “He was the first to see the snow.” His youthful innocence contrasts with the grave images of warfare as it reminds the reader that war is indeed fought by the young.