Student Question

How would Elizabeth Bishop write a diary entry about stopping at "The Filling Station?"

Quick answer:

Elizabeth Bishop's diary entry about "The Filling Station" might reflect her surprise at finding elements of care and love, like a doily and a plant, in a dirty, utilitarian gas station. She might ponder the family's dynamics, the father's "monkey suit," and the implications of children working. Bishop could also consider her assumptions about cleanliness and class, realizing the station's efficiency and the family's dedication, ultimately questioning her own biases about hard work and domestic life.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

"The Filling Station" describes a small-town family-run gas station, and defines it by the dirtiness of the family and sons who run it contrasted with a doily and plant that seem unnecessary. The narrator, a first-person voice who for the purposes of this question can be deemed Elizabeth Bishop, is amazed at the care that goes into the small piece of decoration in a gas station that is both completely utilitarian and very dirty. The first three stanzas explicitly mention just how dirty everything is:

Oh, but it is dirty!
--this little filling station,
oil-soaked, oil-permeated
to a disturbing, over-all
black translucency.

For a diary entry from the narrator's perspective, you might focus on any number of small details; the Father's "monkey suit" that "cuts him under the arms," for instance. Is this a jumpsuit? Why does it cut him? "Monkey suit" is often used as a pejorative for fancy dress, as a suit-and-tie or tuxedo. Why is it used here? What does the narrator think about the Father using his sons for labor? Their ages are not mentioned; is this significant?
The "dirty dog" which sits on the back porch seems to have no purpose other than to continue the theme of dirtiness; why is it mentioned? Simply because a dog on a porch indicates domesticity?
The narrator, at the end, seems confused that a family gas station might include a mother. She interprets the doily and plant as larger signs of human love and devotion; "Somebody loves us all," she says, equating the unseen hand of the mother with the unseen hand of a deity. However, does she assume that the family lives in a constant, unending state of filth? Is that the life of the lower-classes who serve people such as herself? Or has she simply never considered the need in working people for decoration or escape from their daily lives?
Finally, you might take an entirely different approach than that of the poem. Examine the gas station not as a dirty, lower-class place, but as a necessary and efficient part of daily life. People don't often think about how hard mechanics work to support their families; is the Father being harsh to keep his children in the business, or is he trying to ensure that they have a solid foundation in hard work and skilled labor for their future? Perhaps in her diary, the narrator reexamines her preconceived notions about what hard work truly means, and what her first reaction says about her own prejudices.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial