Student Question
Why are Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson credited with starting our two-party system?
Quick answer:
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson are credited with starting the two-party system in the U.S. due to their opposing political views, which led to the formation of the Federalist and Democratic-Republican parties. Hamilton's Federalists favored a strong federal government and close ties with Britain, while Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans advocated for states' rights and support for France. Their differing visions on issues like the national bank and state debts solidified partisan divisions, shaping early American politics.
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson are credited with beginning our two-party political system because they were the leaders of these parties that had different views on issues. Despite President Washington’s warning in his farewell address to the nation about avoiding political parties, the country was moving in this direction because the needs of the North and the South and of the people were different. As a result, they had differing opinions on various policies.
Alexander Hamilton led the Hamiltonians, which also was called the Federalist Party. This party had the support of business people in the Northeast. They believed in a loose view of the Constitution, having a strong federal government, establishing a national bank, and being friendly with Great Britain. John Adams was also closely tied to this party.
Thomas Jefferson led the Jeffersonians, which also was called the Democratic-Republican Party. This party had support in the South. They...
Unlock
This Answer NowStart your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
believed in a strict interpretation of the Constitution, having a weaker national government that would be small in size, wanted low taxes, and opposed the national bank. They wanted to be friendly with France. James Madison was also closely tied to this party.
Because of these different viewpoints, and because these men were leaders of the people supporting these viewpoints, they are credited with starting our two-party political system.
Why are Jefferson and Hamilton credited with starting the two-party political system?
We credit these two men with beginning the two-party system in the United States because the first two political factions (they weren't really parties as we know them today) formed around them, and their responses to the pressing issues of the early Republic. Jefferson was the Secretary of State under George Washington, and Hamilton the Secretary of the Treasury. Each man had a very different vision of what the United States would look like, and their differences came to the fore on a number of issues, including the assumption of state debts by the federal government, the imposition of an excise tax, and the chartering of a national bank. Jefferson, who favored a strict interpretation of the Constitution and a limited federal government, was suspicious of Hamilton's program for handling the nation's financial crisis. He thought that Hamilton's approach would give too much power to the federal government, and too much influence to bankers and "stock-jobbers," which Jefferson held in contempt. Supporters of these policies rallied around Hamilton, and opponents around Jefferson in the early 1790s. Jefferson was especially adept at using the media (newspapers) to excoriate Hamilton in the public mind, and Jefferson's hacks painted Hamilton as a dangerous Machiavellian bent on recreating the corruption of the British government in the United States. In the process, Jefferson's supporters came to refer to themselves as "Republicans," or "Democratic-Republicans," and Hamilton's preserved the moniker of "Federalists" from the days of the ratification debates. The single event that most shaped the development of the parties, however, was the outbreak of the French Revolution and the wars that followed. Republicans, especially urban workers, were enthusiastic supporters of the Revolution, but Hamilton and the Federalists were wary of its influence, especially when war broke out between the French and Great Britain. By the late 1790s, politics were being contested along explicitly partisan lines, and the divide reached a crisis point in the election of 1800. The parties, then, had their origins in the political positions, the philosophies, and the machinations of Jefferson and Hamilton.
References