Return to Nature

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Based on the information provided, it is evident that the speaker resides in a countryside environment: she sleeps on a straw bed and is knowledgeable enough about birds to envision what type of bird her daughter might become. She understands that swallows travel in large flocks and undertake extensive migrations, which means they are away for long durations. Ironically, the idea of the daughter transforming into a swallow in the first stanza is depicted not as a return to nature, but as a distortion of it, forcing a young girl to be separated from her mother. A significant concern for the speaker is the fear that her daughter might lose the ability to play in the meadow if she becomes too entrenched in society, symbolized here by tiny golden slippers. She hopes her daughter will not be spoiled by the excessive sophistication of culture and will instead remain connected to her natural surroundings, specifically the rural area the speaker considers home. The imagery of playing in the meadow serves as an idealized vision of the child staying in harmony with nature, portraying childhood play as an integral part of nature, with little golden slippers representing a departure from it.

Change and Transformation

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

This poem explores a parent's anxiety about the inevitable changes their young daughter will undergo. Change is a natural part of life, and it's understandable for a parent to worry that these changes might create distance between them and their child. This fear underscores the depth of the parent's current bond with their daughter. The poem creatively imagines these changes as transformations, reflecting the parent's emotional perspective rather than reality. While a child cannot literally become a bird, a parent might feel as though their child is like a bird leaving the nest when she grows up and moves on. Similarly, children from modest backgrounds don't suddenly become princesses, but a parent might perceive their daughter as a princess when society starts to admire her, attention that once came solely from her mother. There is also no real threat of the girl turning into a queen, but if she eventually achieves power and influence, her mother might feel as though she has become regal. The poem suggests these transformations are orchestrated by an enigmatic force referred to as "them," who inexplicably want to turn the girl into a sparrow, a princess, or a queen. The most logical interpretation of "them" is the various people the child will encounter throughout her life, with her transformation being a natural outcome of their influence.

Public vs. Private Life

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The poem's speaker, like all parents, shares a unique connection with her daughter—a small, intimate world exclusive to them, experienced when she rocks her child and combs her hair. Outside their personal sphere lies a broader world filled with people who wish to alter the daughter, drawing her away from this cherished bond. Should they succeed in transforming her into a swallow, a princess, or a queen, she would thrive in their realm but no longer belong to her mother's. The poem's title captures a mother's worry about losing her daughter—not through death or conflict, but to the wider social world. This anxiety is most vividly depicted in the third stanza, where the mother envisions her daughter being made a queen, with all the societal influence that entails. Yet, from the throne, the mother would be unable to see her daughter, illustrating how a queen's societal duties would prevent her from associating with a commoner, even if that commoner is her own mother. In such a scenario, social ties take precedence over personal ones.

While readers may empathize with the...

(This entire section contains 309 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

speaker's fear of losing her close relationship with her daughter, they must recognize that this fear stems from a general apprehension of society itself. She dreads that a public life would grant her daughter the freedom of a bird and the accolades of a princess, or worse, the authority of a queen. By imagining that society might confer such honors, the narrator reveals her unfamiliarity with the workings of public life, unsure of its potential impact. As a woman who sleeps on a straw bed, rocks her child to sleep, and combs her child's hair, she comprehends the small, intimate world but not the broader society. Her lack of understanding fuels her fear, leading her to envision the public world taking away what she holds most dear.

Previous

Summary

Next

Critical Essays

Loading...