Discussion Topic

An analysis of Doctor Faustus, focusing on its tragic elements and themes of knowledge, Christianity, and power

Summary:

Doctor Faustus is a tragedy that explores themes of knowledge, Christianity, and power. The protagonist's insatiable quest for knowledge leads him to make a pact with the devil, reflecting the conflict between Renaissance humanism and medieval Christianity. Faustus's ultimate damnation underscores the tragic consequences of overreaching ambition and the moral limits imposed by Christian doctrine.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragic hero.

A tragic hero always has far to fall, and Doctor Faustus is no exception. A great scholar and polymath, he has an enviable position in life, one for which many people would give their eye teeth. Yet somehow it's not enough. Faustus wants more out of life than he's currently getting. More than anything else, he wants power, and plenty of it; the kind of power that one can only receive from the supernatural. In practical terms, that means the Devil, as God would never grant power to his own creatures that might make them start acting like himself.

So Faustus summons Mephistopheles, one of the Devil's acolytes, and makes a fateful bargain with him. In return for his mortal soul, he will receive twenty-four years of power. Initially, all goes well. Faustus enjoys his increased powers and the renown it brings him. Faustus becomes something of a celebrity and travels all over the world showing off his remarkable abilities.

Yet after a while, it all starts to get rather boring for Faustus. Over time, he gradually becomes dissatisfied, feeling himself to be nothing more than a magician putting on shows for the delight of the rich and powerful. To make matters worse, Faustus cannot ignore the fact that one day all this will be over and that he'll end up going to hell. Crucially, however, he makes no effort to make things right with God, not even in his last few hours on earth.

Eventually, as expected, Faustus is dragged to hell. As with all tragic heroes, a basically good man has become undone by his own hubris. In wanting more power, Faustus was trying to put himself on the same level as God. Such arrogance could only end one way: in damnation.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus in terms of the tragic flaw theory of character development.

The character of Doctor Faustus certainly coincides well with the tragic flaw theory of character development.   From the opening lines, the reader already gets a sense that Faustus has an insatiable desire to attain knowledge which will confer power on him.  His desire for this knowledge, particularly his view that he is entitled to it, is his tragic flaw.  As his character develops, the reader is meant to understand the corruption that inevitably coincides with the pursuit of such knowledge, as well as the blindness to potential consequences.

The last lines of the play effectively summarize the lesson to be learned - a lesson which springs from the outcome of Faustus's tragic flaw.  He aspires to too much, and in doing so he gets what is rightfully his.  An excess of anything becomes a bad thing.  Faustus's excess pride and intellectual curiosity ultimately consign him to hell.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

Christopher Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus is perhaps one of the best known tragedies. It definitely differs from a traditional Greek tragedy, as Faustus doesn't have a high birth status (like a king, prince etc.). Moreover, as we know, in a Greek tragedy, though the hero suffers, but everything is brought into restoration by the end. As long as the person is alive, there is an option of repentance and forgiveness of his sins by the God. But Doctor Faustus shows some deviations.

Doctor Faustus can be called as an Elizabethan form of tragedy with elements of Christianity and Renaissance. It drew inspiration but was significantly different from the Aristotelian form of tragedy. In fact, the tragedy plays by the famous playwright William Shakespeare are believed to be an advancement of Marlowe’s genius.

Now, though we understand that Faustus doesn't have a high birth status, he still enjoys respect in the society because of his unmatchable education and intelligence. 

Doctor Faustus represents the modern man who is divided between the Christian faith and the Renaissance spirit. Faustus, similar to the heroes of Greek tragedies (Greeks were pioneers of tragedy plays) has one fatal error or tragic flaw (known as Hamartia) that leads to his damnation. It is his hubris or extreme pride (this is considered as the most severe of all seven deadly sins as it gives rise to the other sins). He is guilty of being too proud over his intelligence and achievements. Because of his he commits a series of other mistakes one after the other.

We see that Faustus too finally realizes his mistakes (all tragic heroes meet revelation of their faults) and begs for repentance. But it’s too late by then and he meets damnation. Through his tragic end, he gains the audience’s sympathy and provokes Catharsis. Catharis is atypical of any tragedy. In fact, the most obvious and logical conclusions of the Elizabethan (or, later famously called as the Shakespearean tragedy) is the hero’s death.

Doctor Faustus can be, hence, called as a tragedy play.

Posted on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

Doctor Faustus certainly qualifies as a tragedy (in fact the full name of the play is The Tragical History of Doctor Faustus) as it incorporates many of the characteristics and qualities of such a work. In the main character we see an individual who falls from a relatively position in society to a far lower position of society as the result of his central flaw. In this case, Doctor Faustus's flaw is that of hubris, or his excessive pride. We see Faustus's excessive pride demonstrated most clearly is his own steadfast belief in his soul's damnation.

One specific way in which Doctor Faustus differs from the traditional tragedy mold is in the background of the main character. Taditional tragic figures typically come from the highest of social ranks--often royalty or nobility. Faustus, however, is not. In fact, he comes from very meager beginnings and lower class parents. His rise of the rungs of the social ladder is facilitated by his ability to excel in academia.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

I would say that one reason why Marlowe's work represents tragedy is because it is the story of a protagonist who seeks to appropriate the world in accordance to his own subjectivity.  Within the seeds of his greatness are the very elements of his own destruction.  It is here where a tragic condition lies.  Faustus seeks to gain more knowledge, more understanding, and more control over his own world.  These attributes are brought to a tragic condition when it is seen that Faustus' destruction is not prevented by these qualities, but actually enhanced by them.  It is in this light where tragedy is apparent in the character.  This notion of seeking to make one's place in the world better actually setting the stage for one's own demise is a tragic predicament.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

[Second Post to answer.]

In addition to this, the questions addressed in Marlowe's play are nobel universal questions pertaining to the highest order of considerations: the meaning of life and death, the quest for knowledge, the respective power of of good and evil. In further accord with elizabethan tragedy, the play Dr. Faustus employs comedic relief through the presence of clowns that also acts as a means of giving information about the characters and the action of the play. The clowns in Dr. Faustus are Rafe and Robin. In Elizabethan tragedy, the clowns (rural, country simpletons who misuse language accidentally) and fools (urban dwellers who play with language and "misuse" it intentionally for wit) generally replace the Greek Chorus that carried the task of moving the story along with information not performed on stage, but in Dr. Faustus, Marlowe employs both the Greek-style Chorus and Elizabethan clowns.

Finally, in keeping with Elizabethan tragic form, Faustus gets himself in so deep, his tragic flaw or error in judgement is so aggregious that it leads ultimately and necessarily to his death, thus fulfilling the fate of an Elizabethan tragic hero. Since Faustus has overestimated what he can attain from an arrangement with Lucifer and since he underestimated the power of Lucifer's evil, his ultimate end must be and is death even though he recognizes his mistakes and pleads for pardon.

[For more information on Dr. Faustus, see the blog of Tarun Tapas Mukherjee, Kolkata, West Bengal, India; Sr. Lecturer in English, with a couple of entries on Dr. Faustus.]

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

[Too long for one post. Posted in two parts. (I hope)]

Understanding of Christopher Marlowe's Elizabethan tragedy, Dr. Faustus, can be framed in terms of the Renaissance philosophy and the Elizabethan tragedy, which takes a different turn on some points from the Aristotelian tragedy, for instance such as the Elizabethan tragedy's requisite death of the tragic hero. Dr. Faustus demonstrates the Renaissance philosophy that pits the dichotomy of good, angelic humanity against evil, depraved humanity. Marlowe's play also is a model of the Elizabethan tragedy.

Marlowe constructed the character of Dr. Faustus to represent within himself both characteristics of the Renaissance view of humanity as divinely good and hellishly evil. First, Dr. Faustus is presented as a scholar of all things including divinity, the highest Renaissance scholarly discipline. Then, Faustus is shown as dissatisfied with the limitations of humanity and grasping for unlimited knowledge, which is a Biblical allusion to Adam and Eve who ate of the Tree of Knowledge. Throughout the play, Faustus descends to lower and lower planes of knowledge in his pursuit for the "power" and "omnipotence" that comes from knowledge. At the beginning, Mephistopheles answers all Faustus' questions but draws the line on talk of the universe, which can be seen to stand for astronomical and cosmological studies--the very studies that science is deeply involved in today: CERN; Hubble; SoHo; etc). Faustus must be content with merely mapping the universe instead of understanding it. Marlowe ultimately shows in Dr. Faustus the futility of the quest for ultimate knowledge and the inevitable end result of abandoning moral integrity for omnipotent knowledge.  

Dr. Faustus also represents a Classic Elizabethan tragedy. First, the tragic hero has a flaw or makes an error in judgment that leads to his own doom. It's hard to say whether Faustus had a fatal flaw in his character or whether he was doomed by a faulty understanding that lead to a fatally disastrous error in judgment. All along the way, Faustus has doubts and hesitations which speak for an integrity of his moral character. If he has a fatal flaw, it might be that he did not reckon the power of evil highly enough, that he thought that with omnipotent knowledge, he could free himself from the chains of evil he wrapped so blithely around himself. Adam and Eve also fell to the punishment from the lure of knowledge. Of course, quite often Faustus' fatal flaw is said to be greed and irreverent disregard for goodness. One clue to forming a literary stance on the question lies in examining his hesitations and second thoughts.

[Post 2 below (I hope).]

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

Dr. Faustus is a tragedy because the main character falls as a victim of his own circumstances, and is a victim of himself.

He is a man with all the potential and possibilities to be successful. He is a Renaissance man who is versed in every aspect of science, philosophy, the arts, education, and genius, yet, he utilizes his energy and wit into absolutely nonsense and unnecessary goals, such as his obsession to be a magician, and his ridiculous fixation for power: A power he has no clue what to do with.

To make matters worse, his self absorbence led him to make a pact with the devil to obtain that same power he wanted for no factual reason. He didn't even know why he did it, in all reality. In fact, he did it with no solid basis, and he obviously began to regret it.

All this for nothing: He dies insane and cursed. No triumph, no merits. Just he, victim of himself.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

In his play 'Dr Faustus' Christopher Marlowe presents his main character as a tragic 'hero' right from the start - the full title of the play is 'The Tragicall History of Doctor Faustus. So we have the idea of 'tragedy' and of a history (story) at the beginning - his audiences knew what they were getting - a tragedy or fall from grace or from some lofty status. Marlowe's audiences would have been familiar with this idea of tragedy from the old morality plays that were in performance round that time. Marlowe re-used an old legend called Faust to tell the story of a man,who like all of us at some time in greater or lesser degree, lets himself down. He loses credibilty, reputation, his standing in the eyes of God and Man and risks his immortal soul. It is in identifying with his human frailty and weakness that we see him as a tragic figure. He sells his priceless soul to the devil for the sake of intellectual superiority and finds it a shallow recompense.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

One way that Dr. Faustus can be seen as a tragedy lies in the main character himself.  The fundamental story of a man, Faustus, trying to appropriate the world in accordance to his own subjectivity can lead to the tragic conclusion that each step towards creation is inevitably a step towards destruction.  Faustus is a man of science, of boundless optimism, who genuinely believes that through his pact with the devil, he will be able to externalize his own subjective beliefs.  In this setting, the real world is to mirror the mind.  It is in this condition where the tragic condition of Faustus is present, as he believes that he can overtake and control the world based on what is in his mind, his own subjectivity.  The realization that his desire to do so inevitably leads to his own destruction reflects the tragic condition that immerses human beings.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze Doctor Faustus as a tragedy.

"Dr. Faustus" is a story of a man who sells his soul to the devil in exchange for necromantic powers (magic). The devil makes him a deal and allows Dr. Faustus 24 years of magical power, but at the end of that time, he was to be taken to Hell. "Dr. Faustus" is a tragic story because the protagonist suffers extreme suffering as a result of the choices he makes throughout the course of the play.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Discuss Doctor Faustus as a study of ambition and despair.

Christopher Marlowe's Faustus mirrors itself as a study of ambition and despair. In the beginning of the story, Marlow presents his protagonist in all airs of sad self grandiosity. The story begins with Faustus expressing his huge ambitions, his vision of the present and future, and his plans to attempt a form of complete domination. Sadly, as the beginning Choir predicts, we already know that he is going to set himself for failure, but still the reader marvels at this man's hunger for power.

Meanwhile, as the story develops, we get to know the real Dr. Faustus. A petty and empty, hollow man with a dim wit, who is impulsive, and we could almost classify him as imprudent. Yet, considering the time when the character of Faustus was conceived, Marlow clearly wants to demonstrate the social characteristics of the Renaissance's break with the medieval mentality of a God that controls the fate of man: As a Renaissance man, Faustus demonstrates the feeling of want to control one's own fate.

With the contract that he makes with the Devil, he is basically uncovering his own weaknesses. He denies that hell exists even after he made the pact because we know he is in constant fear. He is tempted to repent, but continues to deny himself to do so. He is a staunch and stubborn character who got too much, and knew not what to do with it.

The only part when Faustus moves the reader to compassion is when, in his final hours, as he is about to be taken to eternal damnation, the best of him comes out, and he can see clearly where he stands. And it is then when his best words are expressed, and his more clear thinking is evident. As his end comes, despair sets in, yet, despair is a silent ghost that involves Faustus's entire existence, and his view of who he is and where he is going.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Discuss Doctor Faustus as a study of ambition and despair.

In many ways, Faustus' overriding sense of ambition leads to his despair.  The idea of appropriating the world in accordance to one's own subjectivity creates an infinitely regressive cycle of subsuming vistas and horizons.  This leads to despair as there is little in way of contentment, or the ability to simply "tarry for a moment."  Faustus' pact with the devil that he would be able to represent the zenith of appropriation or control leads to despair for there is no sense of finality.  Every moment of accomplishment is punctuated with the belief that there is more to appropriate.  There can be little contentment or joy in this setting because of Faustus' own sense of ambition which knows no limits.  In the end, his animating force of desire and ambition leads to despair.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Analyze the themes of knowledge, Christianity, power, and tragedy in Doctor Faustus.

Doctor Faustus (full title: The Tragical History of the Life and Death of Doctor Faustus) is a Renaissance tragedy written by English playwright and poet Christopher Marlowe. It tells the story of one regular man—a scholar by the name of Faustus and, as the full title suggests, his tragic life and death. Marlowe's intention when writing the play was to showcase the readers that all people, regardless of social status, age, gender or any other social category, are just that—people, or human beings that are curious, weak, thirsty for knowledge and power, prone to making mistakes and often tempted to sin.

Thus, knowledge and curiosity, Christianity and the meaning of sin and redemption, as well as ambition and power are some of the main thematic representations of the drama.

Knowledge

Faustus is an ambitious man; he's certainly educated and learned, however, he yearns to know all of the things that schools and books can't teach. He wants to know more so that he can use that knowledge to make himself wealthy and powerful. He turns to dark magic and the Devil's wicked ways in the hopes of becoming the most knowledgeable man; however, he fails to recognize that there are limits to everything. Having the desire to learn and gain knowledge is certainly admirable, but knowing too much is not something one should strive for. Moderation is the key to everything, and (blind) ambition might seem like a good trait to have, however, it often prevents people from seeing and understanding their environment and their reality.

Christianity

One of the main themes in Doctor Faustus is the exploration of the concepts of sin and redemption, as well as salvation and damnation, and the existence of dualism in Christianity—good (God) and evil (Satan) as the two main opposing forces in the universe. Faustus ponders about fate, heaven and hell and the complexity of one's soul, and he is torn. On one hand, he wishes to be a good and graceful man—moral, ethical and compassionate, a man worthy of God's grace. On the other hand, he wishes to possess the infinite power and knowledge that Lucifer promises.

Faustus commits the ultimate sin—he rejects the grace of God and chooses to follow the Devil's path instead. In the end, he's aware of his mistakes and even asks for forgiveness and redemption for all of his sins and wrongdoings; unfortunately, it is too late and his soul is condemned to eternal damnation.

Power

Faustus desires great power; he wishes to be powerful and unstoppable. The Devil grants him his wish and, instead of trying to transform all of his grand plans and ideas into reality and to uncover the greatest secrets of the universe, Faustus is overwhelmed and doesn't know what to do with all the power he now possesses; one could even argue that he's lost and no longer capable of seeing the bigger picture or the reality of the situation. He becomes ignorant and loses his ambition, drive and passionate spirit; he sacrifices his soul and his morality to gain unimaginable power that he most certainly cannot handle.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on