Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

It is now a commonplace to state that Camilo José Cela, who won the 1989 Nobel Prize in Literature, is one of the foremost writers in the Spanish language. In 1942, the publication by a then-unknown writer of the violent The Family of Pascual Duarte caused a sensation. Its appearance marked the start of the contemporary Spanish novel, and critics and public were shocked by its theme and by the apparent lack of censorship in a Spain where many writers and intellectuals were dead, exiled, or still incarcerated in Franco’s prisons.

Narrated in first person, the novel purports to be the life history of an Extremaduran peasant, awaiting execution, who is mired in a black destiny of heredity and environment. The core of the novel is the question of responsibility. How much influence did Pascual Duarte have on the course of his own life? The bleak answer seems to be: none. Although Duarte states that he is recounting his life so that others may flee from his example and choose other paths, it is evident that Duarte himself believes that his life is predestined, a fate that he was born into. There are ambiguities and ironies in the text, however, that allow for many interpretations, moral and otherwise.

Duarte’s history, after all, is the truth according to Duarte. All the characters are seen through the filter of Duarte’s vision of the world. For instance, it becomes clear that Duarte is in some way responsible for the premeditated assassination of Don Jesús, the rich man of the village, but Duarte only hints at this. He wants to be viewed as only the victim of his circumstances and his actions to be viewed as the product of spontaneous and understandable rage. In addition, parts of the story are told in unchronological flashbacks so that the motivations that trigger Duarte’s responses are often vague and imprecise.

Duarte’s defense in a hostile environment is to strike out with violence. It is a measure of the brutishness of the human characters that his attacks on his nonhuman victims—his dog, for example—are more appalling than his actions against his fellow...

(The entire section is 863 words.)