Discussion Topic
The portrayal and implications of power in Fahrenheit 451
Summary:
In Fahrenheit 451, power is portrayed through the oppressive control of the government, which censors literature and restricts free thought. This power leads to a conformist society devoid of critical thinking and individuality. The implications are the loss of personal freedom, intellectual stagnation, and the dehumanization of individuals, highlighting the dangers of totalitarianism and the importance of intellectual freedom.
How is power portrayed in Fahrenheit 451?
Throughout the novel, the authoritarian regime maintains power over its populace through fear and mass media. Power in the hands of the government enables the regime to enforce strict laws prohibiting literature and intellectual pursuits, which can potentially challenge the ruling party. The government expresses its power through the use of force and punishment, particularly at the hands of the firefighter agency. Citizens who are engaged in intellectual pursuits are arrested and punished throughout the dystopian society. Many individuals, like Faber and the traveling intellectuals, fear the government and go into hiding. The firefighter agency not only destroys homes and property but also harms citizens through their use of the Mechanical Hound, which hunts dissidents. The government also uses its power to influence the media and educational system. Censuring intellectual content while propagating mindless entertainment encourages the population to indulge in sensory stimulating enterprises, like continuously watching the parlour televisions and playing sports. Power is essentially used to dissuade citizens from challenging the authoritarian regime. Through the use of mass media and fear, the government creates a hostile atmosphere, while encouraging citizens to remain passive and ignorant.
Overall, it could be said that power is used in Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451 to make the average person passive and apathetic, and that power is maintained by keeping people this way. In the novel, Guy Montag's society keeps its citizens apathetic by burning books and encouraging the mindless consumption of media. By doing so, society also effectively bans free thought and critical thinking, as reading and books can be seen as vehicles for an active, curious, independent, and potentially disobedient mind. By ensuring that the average person does not think for him or herself and dumbly consumes media, the state also guarantees that no one will question or oppose it. In that case, we can see that, in the novel, power is primarily used to keep people ignorant, as independent thinkers are deemed to be too dangerous for the good of society.
In Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451, the amount of power that a person possesses is based on a combination of two things: individual depth of knowledge about the issues and the person's position of influence. For example, Captain Beatty is knowledgeable because he is a well-read, highly-skilled fireman who has his position as captain to make him powerful. Not only does he have knowledge that other people don't have, but he also has the authority to enforce the government's agenda. When Montag asks what happens to a fireman who happens to take a book from a fire scene, Captain Beatty demonstrates his power by making threats in a polite, professional tone as follows:
We don't get overanxious or mad. We let the fireman keep the book twenty-four hours. If he hasn't burned it by then, we simply come burn it for him (62).
Even though Captain Beatty sounds objective in the above quote, he is threatening Montag. If Montag does not burn the book, Captain Beatty will burn down his house. Needless to say, Beatty can back up any threat he gives because he has the knowledge, authority, and power to do so.
Another way that power is used in the society of Fahrenheit 451 is to control the population's mindset through government-controlled public education. For example, when Montag asks how a girl like Clarisse can escape the clutches of society's system of brainwashing, Captain Beatty responds with the following:
Heredity and environment are funny things. You can't rid yourselves of all the odd ducks in just a few years. The home environment can undo a lot you try to do at school. That's why we've lowered the kindergarten age year after year until now we're almost snatching them from the cradle (60).
By lowering the age that kids start going to school, the government can reach into children's brains earlier to counter anything that they might learn at home.
The Mechanical Hound is another way the government controls people and demonstrates power. A person's chemical makeup can be entered into the Hound's database, which gives it an increased advantage when hunting down criminals. Not only does the Hound's existence represent the power of the government to enforce the law, but it is also used to demonstrate its ability to make examples out of people. For instance, when the Mechanical Hound cannot find Montag during its hunt, the authorities turn it on another man. This keeps people thinking that no one can escape the Hound, and it serves as a way to flex its political and powerful muscles of intimidation. Granger explains the use of the Hound as he and Montag watch the end of the chase as follows:
They're faking. You threw them off at the river. They can't admit it. They know they can hold their audience only so long. The show's got to have a snap ending, quick! . . . So they're sniffing for a scapegoat to end things with a bang. Watch (148).
Granger brings up one more example of power that the government uses to control the populace—the power of mass media, entertainment, and distraction. If no one likes to read, and if reading is illegal, then people turn to television and radio to keep them entertained and happy. If people are happy watching television all day and driving their cars too fast all night, then they won't become upset with political issues. Captain Beatty explains in the following passage:
It didn't come from the Government down. There was no dictum, no declaration, no censorship, to start with, no! Technology, mass exploitation, and minority pressure carried the trick, thank God. Today, thanks to them, you can stay happy all the time. . . People want to be happy, isn't that right? . . . Don't we keep them moving, don't we give them fun? That's all we live for isn't it? For pleasure, for titillation? And you must admit our culture provides plenty of these (58-59).
From what Beatty says, a hedonist culture has taken over the lives and thoughts of everyone in society. As a result, the government only steps in to control the "odd ducks" and largely keeps society moving without much controversy. Still, the government keeps men like Captain Beatty in power to enforce the laws, creates killing machines like the Mechanical Hounds to intimidate and kill criminals, and makes technology and entertainment readily available in order to stay in power and keep control of society.
How does Fahrenheit 451 portray distrust towards power, regardless of who holds it?
In Fahrenheit 451, one of the lessons is that those in power (not power itself) should always be questioned. So, there should be what you might call a "healthy distrust" of authority in order to do two things: to keep the citizens aware of the social conditions of their lives and to keep authority figures/groups from stifling that awareness.
In the novel, those who become aware or question the social conditions in which they live (Clarisse, her family, Montag, and Faber) are claimed as enemies of the state (authorities) and sentenced to death/arrest. The novel illustrates that a society in which authority cannot be questioned or challenged can lead to a passive, thoughtless citizenry. The immense power of the authorities in this novel exists because those authorities have been successful in pacifying the citizens and subsequently because those citizens have not challenged those authorities. So, the novel does propose that a healthy mistrust of authority figures can limit the power of the state to necessary levels and that mistrust also keeps the citizens aware of the pros/cons of their social conditions.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.