Ethics

by Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Start Free Trial

Religious Themes

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a notable theologian, emphasizes a profound perspective on Christian ethics, urging believers to embrace their liberty to live responsibly under the divine reality manifested in Jesus Christ. Bonhoeffer presents a series of ethical principles, each reflecting the intricate balance between moral obligations and human compassion. He argues that arbitrary killing is indefensible, maintaining that life can only be taken under specific circumstances, such as in warfare when defending against chaos. He further asserts that euthanasia is allowable solely with the explicit consent of the individual involved, highlighting the sanctity of personal autonomy.

When discussing complex ethical dilemmas, Bonhoeffer illustrates the nuanced nature of moral decisions. For instance, he contends that if a ship is threatened by an infectious outbreak, the sacrifice of the sick to save the healthy may be justified. In matters of abortion, he categorizes it as murder, yet shifts the accountability to the community when the act is driven by desperation and isolation of the mother. This perspective underscores a collective responsibility, rather than individual condemnation.

Bonhoeffer critiques Catholic doctrines on birth control by opposing their strict stance, suggesting it fosters joyless unions, which contradict the essence of marriage. He argues for voluntary sterilization, opposing any form of coercion. Moreover, Bonhoeffer vehemently rejects slavery and torture, including state-enforced sterilization, as they violate personal dignity and privacy. This strong advocacy for human rights reflects his broader ethical framework that cherishes individual freedom and integrity.

In exploring cultural sensitivity, Bonhoeffer condemns derision or devaluation of diverse cultural expressions, advocating for respect and understanding. He believes that mockery of different customs, or displaying one’s education boastfully, is indicative of a lack of Bildung, or cultural and moral education. His teachings extend to the personal realm, where he advises that prayer remain private, akin to deep emotions such as joy and sorrow, which are not meant for public spectacle.

Bonhoeffer also addresses the complexity of truth, recognizing that context can dictate the moral weight of words. He provides the example of a child faced with a teacher’s probing about a parent's alcoholism, asserting that a lie in this scenario may be justified, given the inappropriate context of the inquiry. This perspective invites a deeper reflection on the nature of truth, suggesting that ethical integrity often requires a delicate evaluation of circumstances.

Overall, Bonhoeffer’s ethical musings challenge believers to engage with their faith dynamically, considering the context and complexity of human interactions while striving to embody the divine empathy exemplified in the life of Jesus Christ.

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Previous

Summary

Next

Critical Essays

Loading...