Summary
Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s work Ethics explores the profound connection between the divine and the human experience. It suggests that with the arrival of Jesus Christ, God embraced humanity, thus redefining the cosmic order. This transformation heralds a world beyond the dualities of good and evil, inviting humanity to integrate fully into the divine essence as revealed in Christ.
The Transition to God-Reality
According to Bonhoeffer, humanity stands on the brink of a profound transition towards "God-reality." In their current state, people operate within the realm of nature, but their ultimate potential lies in embodying the divine reality manifested by Jesus. For example, when faced with mortality, a natural reaction might be silence born of helplessness, while a divine reaction embraces solace. Both these stages are essential for understanding the breadth of human experience, which is inherently social.
The Merging of Divine and Human
God’s incarnation in Jesus signifies the ultimate act of love, bridging the gap between the divine and the human. This new relationship ushers in complete freedom within the framework of divine reality. As Bonhoeffer references Martin Luther, adhering to the Ten Commandments showcases obedience, yet true freedom allows Christians to construct their own moral guidelines. To "be good" is to "live," seamlessly transcending the binary of morality. Jesus’s love is unconditional, extending to all people, especially those driven by justice, without idolizing moral exemplars. Each individual must cultivate a personal moral compass aligned with their perception of Jesus Christ. This approach emphasizes a dynamic, evolving orientation rather than a static, rule-bound existence, focusing more on living from the heart of life than from its fringes defined by rules.
Living in God-Reality
Ultimately, those who embody goodness do so without self-awareness of their virtue, needing Jesus’s affirmation only in retrospect. Fragmented individuals are preoccupied with judgment, while those residing in God-reality live authentically, making relatively better choices without absolutism. Recognizing the independence of others is pivotal for Christians. Bonhoeffer emphasizes that forgiveness is a responsibility, favoring forgiving others over oneself. This intertwines with ethical self-determination and freedom. God’s new commandment calls for profound love among individuals, shifting focus from ethical quandaries to liberating permissions over prohibitions.
Divine Mandates: Work, Marriage, Church, and Authority
Bonhoeffer identifies Work, Marriage and Family, Church, and Authority as divine mandates integral to the world. These mandates fulfill divine purposes even if not explicitly Christian. Bonhoeffer provocatively argues that even the devil plays a role in God’s will, serving Christ’s purpose inadvertently. These divine mandates—Work, Marriage, Church, and Authority—must maintain a balance, each distinct yet integral.
Work as Vocation
Work, or Vocation, involves a calling to live responsibly under the guidance of Jesus Christ. Though vocational tasks may be limited, one's responsibilities are broader and more impactful. One might be called to abandon a job if it compromises responsible living. Restricting focus solely to job duties is deemed irresponsible. Jesus is seen in every human "other," regardless of proximity, making distance irrelevant to moral obligations. Historical context may redefine vocational responsibilities, as illustrated by Paul’s acceptance of Roman slavery in his time. The labor mandate operates independently of the other three mandates.
Marriage and Family
Marriage and Family, regarded as a divine spiritual union, endorse the pursuit of physical pleasures as a precursor to eternal joy. Sexuality is valued for pleasure and not solely for procreation. Marriage, a private covenant enacted by partners, receives public acknowledgment through Church and Authority. This mandate stands autonomous from the other mandates.
The Church's Role
The Church represents another divine mandate, with the preacher being a conduit for God and Jesus to the congregation. While the Church is a...
(This entire section contains 888 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
platform for proclamation, it must also offer unwavering critique, not delve into legislation. The Church must not suppress the body, affirming the right to bodily pleasures in this life and beyond. It desires Authority to uphold God’s mandate and order, without aspiring for a specifically Christian Authority. Through its interaction with individuals, the Church is linked to the human elements of the other mandates, yet it should not attempt to dominate them.
The Nature of Authority
Authority derives its legitimacy from the divine mandate rather than public concessions like a "social contract." It embodies the New Testament's divine directive, wielding control through law and enforcement to preserve public order, which supports the flourishing of the other mandates. Authority lacks the right to impose retributive punishment; that remains solely within God’s purview. It must respect individual privacy and can assume various forms—be it violent or lawful, democratic or autocratic, monarchical or imperial—while retaining its divine legitimacy. Even when Authority errs ethically, it sustains its divine mandate, commanding citizen respect and allegiance without necessitating alignment with Christian doctrine.
When to Challenge Authority
There are times when disobedience to Authority is warranted when it conflicts with God-reality. In uncertain situations, however, obedience is required. Any defiance should be specific and situational, avoiding broad opposition to Authority. Even anti-Christian authorities possess a divine mandate, and obligations like taxation persist despite persecution. As Jesus was indifferent to public policy, Christians should similarly eschew worldly concerns in favor of maintaining distinct boundaries between mandates. While individuals may align with Jesus, Authority operates separately. Bonhoeffer notably excludes ethnic groups from any divine mandate, viewing them as historical, not divinely ordained entities.
