Student Question

In Ethan Frome, how does Ethan and Mattie's relationship reveal universal truths about love and compassion?

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Ethan and Mattie's love for each other is not selfish or carnal; it represents instead the deep human longing for spiritual connection with another. When Ethan and Mattie first meet, each lives in a state of personal loneliness. Ethan is trapped in a cold, sterile relationship with Zeena, one that has extinguished almost every spark of life within him. He lives in the world isolated from human warmth and communion. Mattie is alone in the world, also--an orphan with no home or close relationships.  Ethan and Mattie fall in love when they become true companions. With each other, they are no longer lonely. Ethan is amazed when Mattie comes into his life. He had not believed there was anyone else in the world who could say what he felt most deeply.

Compassion plays an integral role in their relationship, as well, and it is a kind of love of its own. Ethan strives to ease Mattie's hard labors in the house and to reassure her when she feels afraid. He tries to take the sting out of Zeena's hurtful comments to her. He comforts her when she despairs. Mattie feels Ethan's pain as if it were her own. She weeps for him, as well as for herself. The compassion that is so significant in their relationship is expressed by Mattie shortly before they attempt suicide. Through her tears, she tells Ethan that he was the only one who was ever good to her.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How does the novella Ethan Frome demonstrate the universal truth of compassion?

Wow! This is a great and deep question!

Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton is multidimensional in the way through which it expresses the basics of human and universal compassion.

We first experiece the compassion as readers when we learn about Ethan's current situation: he is poor, unhappily married, dissatisfied with life and with no future hopes. Yet, he yields to the minimalistic aspects of what could be deemed as joy, namely, Mattie.

Second, we get to know the oppression with which he lives under his own roof. His wife, Zeena, is passive-aggressive hypochondriac who manages his every move. However, Zeena, his also compassionate. She took care of Ethan's mother when she was ill. This was ultimately the reason why Ethan married her. Now it is Zeena who thinks she is ill, and crushing the marital budget with unnecessary treatments.

Then, there is Ethan's love interest, Mattie. She, herself, is a subject of compassion. Young, poor, and destitute, Mattie has to live under the Fromes's roof as a maid under the regime of Zeena. To make the story even sadder, both she and Ethan fall in love. That is worthy enough of compassion, if not pity.

Finally, the climax comes when Ethan and Mattie have had enough and refuse to be separated by Zeena. So they quickly make a (very dumb) suicide pact of running towards a tree on a sleigh...and then the worst part happens: They both survive and become crippled. And, who is their caretaker in the end? Zeena.

After all the nightmare is seemingly over, we get to experience from the viewpoint of one narrator who is telling the story from his personal meeting with Ethan Frome. And that's when we realize that the entire town had felt the pain of Ethan and Mattie. We also realize the contempt of the town towards Zeena. Yet, how could we accuse her of anything when she is demonstrating compassion by serving a husband and potential mistress who nearly completed a suicide pact to get rid of HER?

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on