Essays Cover Image

Essays

by eNotes

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Improving Essays on South Sea Islanders in Australian History

Summary:

To improve essays on South Sea Islanders in Australian history, focus on clarity and consistency. Ensure thesis statements align with essay content, emphasizing both the Islanders' contributions and their mistreatment. Use specific examples to support claims of racial discrimination and the Islanders' resilience. Revise awkward phrasing and ensure consistent capitalization, such as for "South Sea Islanders." Provide proper citations for statistics and historical claims, and avoid introducing evidence in the introduction. Highlight the Islanders' cultural and economic impact while addressing historical injustices.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How can an essay about South Sea Islanders in Australian history be improved?

This is very much better than your first effort from yesterday.  The change in your thesis statement makes the thesis fit much better with the rest of the essay.  I only have a few very minor suggestions to this revised version of your introduction.

First, I would add the words “during their time in Australia” to the end of your paragraph just to be clear about where that daunting experience played out.

Second, you should decide whether “South Sea Islanders” and “Islanders” is going to be capitalized.  In yesterday’s version, you typically capitalized this.  Here, it’s capitalized once but not the second time.

Overall, however, very much better.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

You might want to consider changing the thesis of this paragraph.  In the way that history is taught in the United States, at least, there is a great emphasis on what oppressed people do to resist...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

oppression and to remain resilient in the face of harsh conditions.  You allude to this in your second sentence.  I would simply use the second sentence as my thesis.  I would change a few things to make it grammatical, though.  I would say “Despite the controls over their lives as they worked as indentured labourers (please note that you are no longer calling them slaves here)…”  You also say “lived” when you mean “lives.”

I would then add a second sentence that said something like “they maintained traditional habits, cultural beliefs, foods, and religions.” 

You mention foods that were eaten only on special occasions.  What did they eat on regular occasions? 

Finally, your last sentence does not have a clear purpose here.  I would add to it to make its purpose clearer.  I would say something like “Islanders also kept their spirits up by learning new ways of recreation.  In particular, they have excelled in the sport of rugby league.  In these ways, Islanders coped with the harsh conditions by keeping their old culture and by adopting some aspects of Australian culture.”

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

The first of these paragraphs still shows some of the problems with your essay as originally written.  Its purpose is not as clear as that of the other paragraphs in your revised essay.

This could be helped by removing the second and third sentences.  These sentences are about the difficulties that the Islanders faced when they first arrived.  This would really go quite well in your paragraph about how many of them died of homesickness and such.  It would go well because it explains why their lives were hard and why so many died.

Once this is removed, you need to find a new thesis statement.  This paragraph seems to be about the idea that the Islanders have helped Australia and yet have been treated badly.  I would start the paragraph by saying “During their time in Australia, Islanders have contributed to Australian society.  Even so, Australians have continued to ignore them and treat them badly.  I would then remove the sentence that begins “On the other hand” and would leave the rest as is.

I would then add a little more, if possible, about how their efforts have not been appreciated and why they have still lived in poverty.

Overall, though, you have improved your essay a great deal.  Well done. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It is hard to offer much assistance, as this appears to be an introductory paragraph to a larger work. I will list a few stylistic recommendations, and then a few susbstantive recommendations.

  • Be more specific about which "people" believed that whites couldn't work in the tropics. 
  • I'd change the word "communities" to people in the second sentence.
  • The final sentence should probably read significant role in Australia's development.
  • You need to discuss (in what I assume will be the rest of a longer essay) the reasons why it was believed that whites couldn't work in tropical conditions. This will bring to light a number of racial assumptions that may help to frame your discussion of the nature of labor on cotton and sugar plantations. It might also open the door to the possibility of comparison with other societies like the Caribbean or India. 
  • I would also caution against leaving the category "South Sea Islanders" unexamined. Were there people from specific locations within the South Sea Islands that were particularly desirable to Europeans for racial, economic, or political reasons? Why were these people preferred as laborers to aboriginal Australians, for example?
  • Of course, you'll also want to show exactly what impact these workers had on Australian society, and try to do so in a way that discusses economics, culture, and even politics. 
Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I need suggestions to improve an essay on the influence of South Sea Islanders in Australian history.

South Sea Islanders had a significant influence in the development of sugar and cotton industries. Between the period 1863 and 1904, around 55 000 -762 500 South Sea Islanders, mainly from Solomon and Vanuatu, were shipped to Queensland and New South Wales for cheap labour. Labourers, few women, men and young boys aged between 9 and 30 years old, were known as ‘kanakas’ and their recruitment involved either blackbirding or trickery. They signed a three-year work contract that revealed a system of treatment and labour conditions that discriminates on the basis of race. In 1892, Islanders were excluded from working in sugar industries they built up. When the deportation order was made a total of 6 068 islanders were repatriated back to their islands in the period of 1904 and 1908. However, after a 1904 Royal Commission, certain categories and several other Islanders were allowed to remain in Australia. Approximately 1 500 Islanders were officially allowed to reside and another 1 000 stayed illegally. On the 25th of August 1994, Australian South Sea Islanders gained authorized government recognition as a distinct ethnic group. Australian Government now recognises and regrets that Australian South Sea Islanders faced unfair treatment but they still continue to experience substantial disadvantages.

First, please be certain that you are including appropriate citations.  You have included many statistics here whose source(s) need(s) to be cited. 

Second, you need a better topic sentence.  Your topic sentence says that you are talking about how important the islanders were.  However, the body of the paragraph is mostly about ways in which the islanders have been treated badly.  Therefore, you should have a topic sentence that is about mistreatment, not simply about the idea that these islanders were important to these industries.

Third, the sentence that begins “Labourers, few women…” is rather awkward.  Perhaps you could say “The labourers were mostly young boys and men under the age of 30.  A few women came as well.  They were known…”

Finally, you claim that the whole system was based on racial discrimination.  However, you show no evidence to prove this.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How can this essay on South Sea Islanders' experience in Australian history be improved?

Here, too, the changes I would make are minor and mostly have to do with wording.

“Magnificent afflict” is definitely not the phrase you want to use here.  “One of the most important difficulties” would be better. 

The word “had” in that sentence should be removed.

“Discrimination” and “mistreatment” typically do not get made into plurals.

Do you need to define “blackbirding” or is that a term that has been introduced in your class and/or is in common usage in Australia?  Here in the US, it is not a commonly used term.

In the sentence that begins “They signed…” the word “discriminates” should be in the past tense to agree with the words “signed” and “revealed.”

In the last sentence, you should start with “The Australian Government…”

Finally, please be sure to cite your sources in the finished document.  All of these statistics need to be cited.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Your first sentence might be clearer if broken up.  In addition, I think that you might mean that they had no choice but to endure the harsh conditions.  So, I would say “…Islanders had no choice but to endure the harsh outback environments.  They had no choice because they had signed three-year work contracts even though…”

“Those who had not died of homesickness” doesn’t quite work.  You can change it in one of two ways.  First, you could put a date in; “Those who had not died of homesickness within the first X years…”  Second, you could simply say “Those who did not die of homesickness…”  Also, remove the word “they” from this sentence.

Decide whether you are going to capitalize “kanakas” and be consistent with that throughout the essay.

Finally, I still think that you need to justify your use of the words “enslaved” and “slave labour.”  You have not made it clear that the islanders were actually slaves. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Please provide suggestions to improve this essay about the experience of South Sea Islanders in Australian history.

After being blackbirded, Islanders had no choice but to endure the harsh outback environments. They had no choice because they had signed three-year work contracts even though they were not capable of reading or signing their names. Most Islanders were brought to Central Queensland to work in the most atrocious conditions in the Sugar Plantation. Their job was to clear heavy rainforest and scrub, and to plant, preserve and yield the cane. Agricultural mechanisation and backs declining to load money to Islanders meant that in an industry that had experienced an evolution from plantation to family farms, nothing was possessed by the Islanders whose labour initiated the industry. Furthermore, mechanisation instead of cutting process in 1960s took away most periodic jobs as cane-cutters which ended a century of connexion between South Sea Islanders and the sugar industry. This technology change and discrimination resulted in long-term employment and depressed socioeconomic indicators. After a clash arose between Queensland and Commonwealth Governments over the labour matter, the trade was prohibited in 1903. In 1904, when the trade desisted, most South Sea Islanders were sent back to their home islands. Remaining Islanders looked for further work on the cane field elsewhere.

Once again, you have done well with the changes made so far.  A few more minor things:

“Sugar Plantation” is not a proper noun.  It was in previous drafts when you mentioned one specific plantation, but it is not now.

In US usage, we would not say “yield the cane.”  Do you mean “harvest?”  Again, if this is proper Australian usage, please disregard.

I think you mean “banks” and “loan” in your fifth sentence. 

In the next sentence, perhaps you should say “the mechanization of the cutting process.”  Or you could say “using machines instead of human labor in the cutting process…”

In the next sentence, it would be better to say either “change in technology” or “technological change.”

In the sentence that begins “After a clash arose…” you might want to specify what “trade” you are talking about.

Finally, “desisted” is not used in the best way here.  People “desist” when they stop doing something.  The trade can’t desist because it’s not the actor.  So, maybe just say “when the trade ended…” 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Could you provide suggestions to improve my essay about South Sea Islanders in Australian history?

One of the most important difficulties South Sea Islanders faced was the discrimination and mistreatment they received labouring in sugar and cotton industries. Between the period 1863 and 1904, around 55 000 -762 500 South Sea Islanders, mainly from Solomon and Vanuatu, were shipped to Queensland and New South Wales for cheap labour (Australian Human Rights Commission 2012). South Sea Islanders were mostly visible around Mackay, forming around 25 hundred of the 80 thousand urban populations (Clive Moore 2001). The Islander immigrants were known as ‘Kanakas’ and their recruitment involved either blackbirding (practice of kidnapping labour) or trickery. They signed a three-year work contract that revealed a system of treatment and labour conditions that discriminated on the basis of race. The employment of “coloured” labour, apart from on farm owned by a countryman, was banned by the Queensland’s Arbitration Court between 1919 and 1921 and gave preference in employment to Australian Workers’ Union (the Whites). When the deportation order was made a total of 7 068 Islanders were repatriated back to their islands in the period of 1904 and 1908(Clive Moore 2001). However, after a 1904 Royal Commission, certain categories were allowed to remain in Australia. Approximately 1500 Islanders were officially allowed to reside and another 1000 stayed illegally (Department of Aboriginal 2012).

It is good to see the changes that you have made here.  It is good that you have included citations and defined blackbirding.  A couple things that I guess I missed last time you posted this:

You can’t say “between the period…”  You could say “In the period from 1863 to 1904…”  Or you could say “Between 1863 and 1904…”  But “between the period is not correct.

In the US, at least, we refer to the Solomon Islands and not to “Solomon.”  Unless this is different in Australia, you should change that.

Similarly, we would not say “25 hundred” of “80 thousand.”  We would put it in numerals as you did earlier in the paragraph. 

In that same sentence, perhaps you should say “of the 80,000 people in the urban area.”

Overall, though, this is better than previous drafts.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How can I improve this essay about the role of South Sea Islanders in Australian history?

It was believed that white labour in the 1860s could not labour safely in the tropics and as the Mackay plantation owner commented, “The sugar industry is entirely dependent upon coloured labour”(Australian Human Right Commission 2003).Therefore, in colonial Australia, the development of industries like sugar cane and cotton relied on communities like south sea islanders who were brought to Australia in the 1900s for cheap labour to make Australia’s plantations economically viable and the assiduous effort of the South Sea Islanders remains to be acknowledged by Australians today today. The unique history of this cultural group and their contribution to the development of this nation will be portrayed to prove their great impact on Australia’s history.

This is, presumably, your introduction.  If so, some changes you should make include:

Remove the last sentence.  You have already provided your topic sentence.  You have at least implied that you are going to be proving that these islanders were important to Australia’s history. 

Break up the second sentence.  It is too long and does not make your point clearly.  Break it after “south seas islanders.” 

Then make the rest of that sentence into a strong topic sentence.  Say something like “The assiduous effort of these islanders have had a major part in making Australia what it is today.”  That will tell us that your essay is meant to prove that this group has been important. 

Remove the quote.  This is more optional, but you are not really supposed to start bringing evidence in to your essay in the introduction.  Just start with “In the 1860s, people believed that white labour…” 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I need suggestions to improve an essay about the history and contributions of South Sea Islanders in Australia.

As South Sea Islanders continued to labour and contribute to the Australian society, they remained to be subjected to racial discrimination and harsh treatment. Even so, their history shares interesting information, events, causes and legacies left behind today. The first arrival of South Sea Islanders had to learn English and struggled to adapt to Queensland’s climate. The death rate for Queensland colony for Islander mortality rate was 62.89 per 1000 while it was 13.03 per 1000 for non-Pacific Islanders (Centenary of Federation). The main reason of the death was exposure to bacillary dysentery, pneumonia and tuberculosis against which they had little resistance to. On the other hand, South Sea Islanders have excelled in several areas and made contribution to the nation. They had an impact on the development of grazing and farming, maritime industry, mining, pearling, domestic services, childcare and railways. They served the nation as members of the defence force in times of war and peace. Furthermore, they excelled in education, health, politics, government, religions, business, art and sport.

Even though South Sea Islanders continued to experience ongoing discrimination and atrocious treatment, they showed commitment to their work as labourers and endured harsh times. Their unique history and the legacies they left behind will always be shared. Those characteristics of the South Sea Islanders and their determination will remain to be acknowledged by Australians today.

In the first sentence, “remained to be” should be replaced with “continued to be.”

In the third sentence, the use of “arrival” as a noun would not be proper here in the US.  We would say something like “The first groups of South Sea Islanders to arrive in Australia…”

In the fifth sentence, “against which they had little resistance to” is not grammatically correct.  You could just say “against which they had little resistance.”

As for the last sentence of the entire essay, I think it would be clearer if you said “Australians today do not acknowledge the characteristics, determination, and contributions of the South Sea Islanders as much as they should.”

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I need suggestions to improve an essay about South Sea Islanders' influence on Australian history and culture.

Australian South Sea Islanders have not only played a role in the growth of sugar industries but brought their traditional habits, cultural beliefs and religions. Despite the controls over their lives and working as indentured labourers, South Sea Islanders maintained their cultural connections. Most of the south sea islanders that were brought to Australia were not Christians, but they practised their own religions, believing in the power of spirits, ancestors and one or more gods. However, in 1904, when recruitment ended, the majority of Islanders have converted to Christianity. Their particular food preference also remained – sweet potato, fish and root crops such as taro were limited to special occasion and meat and root vegetables were cooked in underground stone ovens at large Islander party. Also, a sport that they have excelled in is the game rugby league.

If this essay is really about how important these islanders have been to the development of Australia, this paragraph does not fit in.  It says very little about the impact that the islanders have had on the country.  A similar comment could be made about your previous paragraph as well.  This essay is appearing to be much more about how the islanders were treated and how they lived than it is about their contributions to Australia.

Therefore, you have three options.  First, you can change the thesis of your whole essay.  Instead of saying that you are showing how they were important, you can change it and say that your essay is about how they were mistreated and about how they dealt with this mistreatment.  Second, you can keep the overall thesis but explain in this paragraph how any of their practices affected Australia.  Have any of their cultural habits and such had an impact on Australian culture in general?  Third, you can delete this paragraph if islander cultures have had no impact on Australian culture and you are trying to show how the islanders have mattered to Australia.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

I need suggestions to improve my essay about South Sea Islanders in Australian history.

As South Sea Islanders continued to be subjected with racial discrimination and harsh treatment, they excelled in several areas and made contribution to the nation. Majority of the Islanders weren’t capable of speaking or writing in English and so they signed a three-year work contracts thinking that they were only going for three months and were shocked when they realised that they would be gone for 36 months instead. With every new moon, several Islanders marked a tree to know when it was time to go to their homes. The first arrival of South Sea Islanders had to learn English and struggled to adapt to Queensland’s climate. They had little resistance to disease that include: measles, smallpox, tuberculosis, dysentery and pneumonia and many found difficulty in coping with all the different foods. On the other hand, South Sea Islanders had an impact on the development of grazing and farming, maritime industry, mining, pearling, domestic services, childcare and railways. They served the nation as members of the defence force in times of war and peace. Furthermore, they excelled in education, health, politics, government, religions, business, art and sport.

The South Sea Islander’s tremendous effort and their struggles have paid off. They have created a unique history to themselves that will remain to be acknowledged by Australians today. Their work impacted on many areas in Australia, especially in sugar industries.

Now, you are back to saying that this is an essay about how the islanders have impacted Australia.  But you really have said very little in this essay about how this has been true.  This paragraph, too, does little to prove that the islanders have had an impact.  At least half of this paragraph (the first five sentences) shows nothing about how islanders have impacted Australia.  Your final three sentences in the first paragraph of this excerpt claim that islanders have had major impacts, but give no proof.

Overall, then, this essay does not really prove what you have set out to prove.  You say that the essay is about the impact islanders have had on Australia, but your essay is really about what a hard time they had and how badly they were treated.  If you are allowed to do so, you should change the whole topic of the essay.  You should change your introduction and conclusion to say that this is an essay about what a hard time these islanders had.  If you are not going to change your thesis, you need a lot more information about how islanders have had an impact on the country. 

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Please give me suggestions about how to improve this essay about South Sea Islanders in Australian history.After being black birded and enslaved, Islander people had no chance of enduring the harsh outback environments as they signed a three year work contract even though they were not capable of reading or signing their names. Most of the South Sea Islanders were brought to Central Queensland to work in the most atrocious conditions imaginable in the Yeppoon Sugar Plantation. Their job was to clear heavy rainforest and scrub, and to plant, preserve and yield the cane. Those who had not died of broken hearts and homesickness were either worked to death or they eventually died of pneumonia. This is proven as the death rate for Queensland colony for Islander mortality rate was 62.89 per 1000 while it was 13.03 per 1000 for non-Pacific Islanders. Nevertheless, White Citizens believed that Kanakas were a hazard to their own employment and pay conditions, so they abused and viciously attacked these slaves. In spite of this, the majority of white people were against the illicit trade and there were many humanitarian groups who aimed and attempted to change the government thinking which caused a clash between Queensland and Commonwealth governments over the Slave Labour matter. This resulted in the trade being abandoned in 1903 and when the trade desisted in 1904, most South Sea Islanders were sent back to their home islands. Remaining Islanders looked for further work on the cane field elsewhere.

First, this paragraph really should be your third paragraph.  It would fit much better as the third paragraph.  In that case, your essay would in essence be saying (one sentence per paragraph) “The islanders who were so important to Australia’s development had a very tough experience.  They were brought in large numbers to work in sugar cane and cotton.  They worked in very harsh conditions.  They maintained their own cultural practices in an attempt to make their lives better.”

Second, is it valid to call these people slaves?  If so, you need to justify it better.  You have them signing contracts, which implies they were paid.  Are they really slaves or are they exploited and abused workers?

A few minor things.  “White Citizens” is not a proper noun and should not be capitalized unless this is the accepted practice in Australia.  “Slave Labour” should not be capitalized.

Approved by eNotes Editorial