Discussion Topic

Exploring Feminist Themes in Jane Austen's Emma

Summary:

Jane Austen's Emma explores feminist themes through its portrayal of the protagonist's independence, intelligence, and self-assurance. Emma challenges traditional gender roles by managing her own affairs and making decisions without a male guardian. The novel critiques societal expectations of women, emphasizing the importance of personal growth and autonomy. Through Emma's journey, Austen advocates for women's empowerment and self-determination.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Is Emma a feminist novel? If so, how?

On the face of it, there seems to be very little way in which a novel that spends so much of its time poking fun at the central female character because of her belief that she is a matchmaker could be viewed as being feminist in any way. In addition, consider the way in which the ending of the novel features the traditional Austen ending of marriage and happiness, with Emma marrying Mr Knightley and accepting her role as wife. However, reading the text carefully, there are various ways in which Austen comments on the differences between men and women, and how in particular there are curious double standards in her society. Consider the following example:

A young woman, if she fall into bad hands, may be teazed, and kept at a distance from those she wants to be with; but one cannot comprehend a young man's being under such restraint, as not to be able to spend a week with his father, if he likes it.

This quote from Chapter 14 shows Emma reflecting on the position that women fall into when they are dependents on those who give them food and shelter. To be in such a position as a woman is profoundly entrapping and restricting, as such a woman would be all but controlled by those who look after her. However, a man in a similar position would not expect to be treated in such a way, and would still have freedom. To consider a similar view, note how Mrs Elton compares being a slave to being a governess in Chapter 35, highlighting the terrible conditions faced by so many women in that profession. Although the novel therefore may not be considered overtly feminist, there is certainly evidence enough to suggest that Austen uses it as a vehicle to confront her readers with the various inconsistencies between men and women and how women are often treated far more harshly than men are. 

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Could Jane Austen's Emma be considered a feminist novel?

Jane Austen's novel Emma has a central character criticized as sheltered and overly concerned with status, place, and marrying well, all the things well off women were supposed to be and do. In her match making, she pushed her friend to not marry a prosperous farmer because he was not what was considered well born, from a high or elite background. By novel's end she is forced to admit she was wrong, and the marriage takes place.

Austen also makes use of gendered space in the novel. Female characters almost always meet indoors while males meet outdoors, suggesting their relative freedoms. The main character cannot walk alone to the post office without attracting gossip while her father can go alone to London without worrying about the same.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Could Jane Austen's Emma be considered a feminist novel?

Jane Austen’s insightful critique of English rural society has many components that merit its consideration as a feminist novel. Austen places a number of strong female characters in a variety of social situations, each with their own advantages and disadvantages. The character of Emma, a rich, spoiled teenager, is initially shown to have numerous bad habits, which may cause the reader to find her to be a rather disagreeable protagonist. By contextualizing her situation, however, Austen shows how social conditions affect both rich and poor.

Emma’s character evolves in part through dialogue with Mr. Knightley, who will prove her true match—in part because he can be honest in telling her that she has behaved unkindly toward Miss Bates and to Harriet Smith. Even more, Emma must set aside some of her class snobbery and find common ground with the other women rather than look down on them. Emma’s maturity, which will be a basis for a solid marriage, depends in large measure on embracing sisterhood in solidarity by appreciating women as her friends.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

Could Jane Austen's Emma be considered a feminist novel?

Emma could be considered a feminist novel because it highlights the constraints faced by women in the small, fictional village of Highbury in the early 1800s. Emma, the main character, is wealthy, intelligent and attractive, yet because her father is a fussy hypochondriac, she has never once traveled from the aptly-named Highbury. Her claustrophobic existence has given her an inflated view of her own worth. While she claims to her friend Harriet that she is rich enough never to need or want to marry, in the end, she realizes she has almost no other options.

Jane Fairfax, possibly the true heroine of the novel, faces her own set of constraints. Beautiful, elegant and an accomplished pianist, she has been educated to be a lady, but she has no money. Her choices are marriage to a man who will accept her without a dowry or governessing, and while she compares governessing to slavery, she steels herself to it when it appears her engagement to Frank Churchill is in collapse. 

Jane Fairfax's aunt, Miss Bates, is also a lady, but she has "sunk" from her former status as the rector's daughter and lives on an extremely limited income with her aged mother. She depends on the charitable gestures of other members of the gentry to survive, and she is forced tolerate the ridicule that accompanies being a single woman with no money. 

The novel implicitly critiques the lack of meaningful options all these women face, and in doing so, makes a case for allowing women greater opportunity and autonomy.  

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Last Updated on