illustrated portrait of English poet Emily Dickinson

Emily Dickinson

Start Free Trial

Discussion Topic

Analysis of Tone and Symbolism in Emily Dickinson's "Success is Counted Sweetest"

Summary:

Emily Dickinson's "Success is Counted Sweetest" uses a tone of wistful reflection to explore the paradox that success is most deeply valued by those who have failed. Symbolism is evident in the imagery of a victorious army and a dying soldier, illustrating how true appreciation of success comes from deprivation and longing.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of Emily Dickinson's "Success is Counted Sweetest"?

One way to identify and analyze tone is to look at the writer’s word choice, which we refer to as diction. Emily Dickinson’s poem “Success is Counted Sweetest” is, like most of her poems, very brief--a mere 53 words. Dickinson’s skill as a poet lies in her ability to say a lot in the space of those few words. Let’s look at her diction and see what kind of tone we can identify.

Ne’er (the truncated form of “never”--Dickinson wanted to shave off half a syllable here), sorest need, not one, defeated, dying, forbidden, distant, agonized.

Here are ten words, almost 20 percent of the poem, that communicate the idea of loss and of being denied the joy of victory. When determining a tone it is important to remember that you’re looking for a word that that expresses the artist’s attitude toward his/her work. There is rarely, if ever, just one correct tone to a work, because there is always variation in the readers’ perception of the work.

I would say that the tone of “Success is Counted Sweetest” is mournful. It laments the “agony” (to use one of Dickinson’s own words from the poem) of those who suffer in defeat not just once, but always. But you, and countless other readers, might perceive a different tone, although all would have something to do with how it feels to "ne'er succeed."

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

What is the tone of Emily Dickinson's "Success is Counted Sweetest"?

It is difficult to find an absolutely upbeat poem in Dickinson's work because she focused so many of her poems on death and dying.  For what seems to be truly upbeat, you might take a look at "Wild Nights."

Even though the tone of "Success is counted sweetest" is not particularly grim, the sentiment Dickinson expresses is, and she sets the parameters of this poem in the opening lines when she says "Success is counted sweetest/By those who ne'er succeed."  And her first example is, of course, a hummingbird that truly understands the value of nectar when it is in "sorest need."

The second and third stanzas continue this theme of understanding the value of something, in this case, success, when one is in the depths of defeat.  Dickinson essentially says that victors in a battle really don't understand the value of victory, but the dying and defeated warrior who hears the celebratory trumpets of victory is the only one who truly understands victory--primarily because victory has slipped away.

In typical Dickinson fashion, this poem has a bitter-sweet component to it--true understanding of value comes with suffering. Also true to Dickinson form, the poem's matter-of-fact tone is offset by the grimness of the sentiment.

Last Updated on
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is nectar interpreted in Emily Dickinson's "Success is Counted Sweetest"?

Dickinson is suggesting that the goal is most attractive to those who strive mightily but fail to attain it; "nectar" will most completely understood by those who have "sorest need" of it but are unable to reach the goal.

Her illustration of this idea refers to warriors after a battle. Those who are on the victorious side - "Not one of all the purple host Who took the flag today" - can't truly appreciate the success they have achieved. The one who completely comprehends the price exacted in gaining the winning side of the battle is the one who lies "defeated, dying." This is the warrior who really knows the meaning of the "distant strains of triumph" but will never be able to share in the sweet success of the battle's outcome.

Nectar is not a forbidden fruit; it is an unreachable desire.

See eNotes Ad-Free

Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Posted on