Discussion Topic
Analysis of poetic devices and theme in Emily Dickinson's "There is another sky"
Summary:
In "There is another sky," Emily Dickinson employs poetic devices such as imagery, metaphor, and contrast to convey themes of hope and the enduring power of nature. The poem contrasts bleak, earthly experiences with an idealized, eternal world, evoking a sense of optimism and tranquility through vivid descriptions of an ever-blooming, sunlit garden.
What poetic devices does Emily Dickinson use in "There is another sky"?
Considering that "There is another sky" speaks of a worldly place (Amherst, Dickinson's home) and an otherworldly place, heaven, the main poetic device is metaphor. The speaker describes a worldly place with natural imagery but with otherworldly qualities. "Another sky" directly means a sky that is not the sky of the Earth. This "other" sky would have to be in another place. Presumably, this would be heaven because only a perfect sky could be "Ever serene and fair." The same could be said for "another sunshine." So, the speaker describes this "other" place but uses natural things to do so. In this other place, the leaves are always green, there is no frost, and flowers never fade. This perfect forest (and/or garden) is a metaphor for heaven.
But we can turn this metaphor around. As it becomes clear that Dickinson is describing a heaven-like place, we could also say that she is using hyperbole to describe a worldly place such as Amherst. In other words, in order to convince her brother, Austin, to come to Amherst, she exaggerates (hyperbole) its qualities (to heaven-like levels) in order to evoke some nostalgia and entice him to come to Amherst.
The adjective "whose" can be the possessive form of "who" or "which." That is to say that "whose" can mean a "thing's" or a "person's." So, the little forest "Whose leaf is ever green" can refer to heaven's (God's) place or the forest's place. Thus, the metaphor works both ways: a description of heaven as a metaphor for Amherst, and a description of Amherst as a metaphor for heaven. Therefore, you could say that the imagery used describes either heaven or the natural world. It depends on how you read the poem. Is it a poem describing the landscape of Amherst as a metaphor for heaven? Or, is the poem describing heaven as a metaphor for Amherst?
What is the theme of Emily Dickinson's poem "There is another sky"?
The above answer discusses the contextual factors surrounding this poem, and its likely connection to the physical place that was Amherst at the time of writing. Divorced from this biographical interpretation, however, it seems clear that the poem can be interpreted as a description of heaven, or some other unearthly place in which the "garden" is safe from the natural disturbances that would otherwise plague it, such as "frost" and "darkness." The idea of heaven, or God's kingdom, as "another country" is a relatively common one; Dickinson here uses imagery suggestive of the Garden of Eden as she describes the sky where is it always "fair" and there is always "sunshine," regardless of the darkness that may exist on earth ("there"—where the addressee, Austin, is.) The place described in the poem is one where leaves are always green, and the flowers "unfading." The invitation to "into my garden come," then, may represent an invitation to the recipient to join the speaker in her faith that such a place exists, beyond the boundaries of frosty, faded, earthly reality.
Emily Dickinson wrote "There is another sky" in conjunction with a letter she sent to her brother, Austin. In the poem, she tries to convince Austin to return from Boston to Amherst. In this context, the poem is about place. Although Amherst is a place in the world, and therefore subject to change, Dickinson compares it to a heavenly place, one where things always remain the same. This is the idea that your home, or home town, might change but it will always be "home." Since that designation of "home" never changes, the place, in a sense, never changes. This is why she uses phrases such as "whose leaf is ever green" and "unfading flowers."
There is a bit of ambiguity. Is Dickinson talking about heaven, Amherst, both, or something else. The last line is "Into my garden come!" This could easily be taken as a sexual (and therefore, incestuous) invitation (to her brother, Austin). However, given that the poem has hymn-like qualities, it seems more likely that this poem is about the nostalgic lure of Amherst ("home") and the everlasting promise of heaven.
This conflation of worldly place and heaven has evidence in the poem. The first line is "There is another sky." The fact that "there" is used indicates an otherworldly place: something not "here." Later, in the poem, the speaker claims "Here is a brighter green." The "here" indicates a worldly place. The combination of "here" and "there" could imply a connection between the world and heaven. This theme is about the sense, or perception, of such places.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.