Analysis
The Gondal Problem
Emily Brontë's poetry presents a captivating interplay between the realm of Gondal, a fantastical world she created, and her lyrical explorations of universal themes. The so-called "Gondal problem" arises from discerning the extent to which this imaginary world influences her poetry. While some readers believe the Gondal world saturates all her writings, others argue that her most profound poems are independent of its dramatic intensity. Brontë's division of her works into "Gondal Poems" and others suggests a separation, but thematic echoes weave through both categories, making it difficult to draw a firm line between them. Although the original Gondal saga is lost, a thematic examination of Brontë’s poetry offers a cohesive understanding of her diverse oeuvre.
Isolation and Longing
Brontë's poetry frequently depicts characters yearning for lost love or freedom, themes prevalent in both her Gondal and non-Gondal works. In poems like “The Philosopher” and “To Imagination,” the speakers express a longing for unity and liberation from worldly constraints. Gondal characters, with their melodramatic flair, serve as avatars for Brontë's personal musings, rather than distinct dramatic monologues like those of Robert Browning. The intense emotional backdrops, whether set in a fantastical Gondal prison or on the moors of Yorkshire, provide a stage for Brontë’s exploration of the soul’s struggle against the "Invisible," the ultimate source of existence.
The Mechanics of Intensity
Brontë is renowned for the intensity of her emotional expression. Her poetry seems to emerge directly from the core of feeling, avoiding the pitfalls of overwrought melodrama through masterful control of poetic form. She uses simple metrical patterns, strong monosyllabic rhymes, parallel phrasing, and strategic repetition to maintain a balanced emotional intensity. These devices create structured movements that underscore the poem's themes, whether mournful or celebratory.
“Rosina Alcona to Julius Brenzaida”
“Rosina Alcona to Julius Brenzaida,” often known as “Remembrance,” showcases Brontë’s skill in controlling emotion through form. The poem, a Gondal narrative, features Rosina mourning her lover Julius, dead for fifteen years. The rhythmic pattern and repetition of words like "cold" convey a sense of restrained yearning. As the poem progresses, "cold" evolves from a literal description of a grave into a metaphor for the speaker's life, symbolizing the barrenness and emotional numbness she endures.
Through antithesis, Brontë contrasts the stillness of death with the wildness of nature, reflecting Rosina’s inner conflict between memory and the need to move forward. Despite her insistence on forgetting, the poem itself stands as a testament to Rosina's enduring love, illustrating the paradox at its heart.
“The Philosopher” and Inner Conflicts
In "The Philosopher," Brontë explores the inner conflicts between imagination and reason. The speaker appeals to a "radiant angel," asking it to validate her faith in imagination over rationality, despite societal failure to achieve conventional success. The poem delves into the dual role of this angelic figure, seen as both a slave and a king, embodying the speaker’s desire for autonomy and unity with a higher power. Such imagery captures the tension within the soul between freedom and belonging, identity and transcendence.
Visions, Nature, and the Divine
Brontë’s belief in an external power, independent of her existence, pervades her work. In "No Coward Soul Is Mine," she affirms her faith in a deity both immanent and eternal, a force that outlasts the physical universe. Nature plays a crucial role in illustrating Brontë's themes, often paralleling the soul's states. In "Aye, There It Is! It Wakes To-night," a storm symbolizes spiritual awakening, suggesting the soul's release from earthly confines, pointing toward life after death.
The imagery of nature, whether depicting a barren winter or a tempest, serves to externalize...
(This entire section contains 1383 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
the inner experiences of her characters. This interplay enhances the emotional resonance of her poetry, as seen in the symbolic transformation of the body into "mould" and the soul into "skies" upon death, reflecting a triumphant liberation.
“Julian M. to A. G. Rochelle”
The Gondal fragment "Julian M. to A. G. Rochelle," published as "The Prisoner," centers on the mystical visions of a prisoner who, despite physical captivity, finds spiritual freedom. The poem captures the ecstatic transcendence of the soul, experiencing harmony beyond earthly suffering. Brontë's selective excerpting of these stanzas indicates her focus on the visionary experience, stripping away the conventional romanticism of the original Gondal setting to reveal the core spiritual conflict.
Romanticism and Transcendence
Brontë's engagement with Romantic ideals is evident in her desire for transcendence, a theme deeply embedded in her work. Her characters strive to move beyond the mortal realm, as seen in the transcendent love of Heathcliff and Catherine in Wuthering Heights, which defies time and space. This blurring of life and death enhances the novel’s gothic allure, as supernatural elements permeate the narrative.
Her poetry reflects a longing to escape mortality, portraying life as a "cold captivity" and death as a release. In “No Coward Soul Is Mine,” Brontë articulates a mystical union with a divine presence, both internal and external, emphasizing imagination over reason—a hallmark of Romantic thought.
The Role of Nature in Romanticism
Nature, a vital element in Romanticism, plays a significant role in Brontë’s work, embodying human emotions and symbolizing inner states. The stormy moors of northern England, integral to her upbringing, inspire her vivid metaphorical landscapes. In Wuthering Heights, nature mirrors the characters' tumultuous emotions, such as Heathcliff's brutal nature intertwined with the moor's wildness.
The dynamic relationship between her characters and the natural world heightens the narrative's energy, reflecting the unpredictability and intensity of human passion. Nature is not merely a backdrop but an active participant in Brontë’s storytelling, enhancing the drama and emotional depth of her work.
Control and Intensity
Despite the emotional fervor in Brontë’s work, her prose and poetry demonstrate remarkable control and precision. Her narrative structure in Wuthering Heights is complex yet lucid, weaving timelines and perspectives with deft clarity. Her characters' dialogue remains direct and unembellished, lending authenticity and immediacy to their interactions.
Brontë's poetic style is characterized by simplicity and austerity, using ordinary language and subtle devices like repetition and alliteration to evoke mood and depth. Her ability to maintain control over intense subjects results in enduring, memorable imagery, such as the poignant simplicity of "Love and Friendship" or the evocative "The Bluebell," which uses a simple flower to convey a profound sense of homesickness.
The Enigma of Brontë’s Work
Brontë’s work is infused with her fierce independence and mystical yearning for transcendence. From the youthful Gondal poems to the rich narrative of Wuthering Heights, her connection to nature is as strong as her desire to transcend it. This tension between individualism and transcendence is central to her literary exploration, haunting her poetry and resonating through the restlessness of her novel.
Her only novel, Wuthering Heights, published in 1847, exemplifies the gothic romance genre, marked by a tempestuous love story set in the wild northern English moors. The novel’s setting and characters reflect the unpredictable and violent elements of human nature, with Heathcliff embodying the destructive potential of unchecked passion.
Heathcliff and Catherine
The novel’s central relationship between Heathcliff and Catherine defies the boundaries of mortality, suggesting a metaphysical dimension to their love. The narrative's conclusion offers a resolution to the destructive passion, emphasizing themes of mercy and forgiveness. Hareton's forgiveness of Heathcliff and Catherine Linton's compassion toward Hareton illustrate Brontë's belief in humanity's capacity for grace and renewal.
The resolution suggests a transition from the stormy passions of winter to the harmony of spring, symbolizing hope and continuation. Brontë’s narrative, through its powerful control and emotional intensity, remains a testament to her unique literary vision.
“Remembrance” Revisited
“Remembrance” stands out in Brontë's poetry as a poignant elegy mourning lost love. The poem's Gondal origins add a layer of emotional depth, as Queen Rosina Alcona yearns for her deceased lover, Julius Brenzaida. Through repetition and assonance, Brontë creates an echoing resonance that enhances the poem’s mournful tone.
The poem’s use of alliteration and extended pauses reinforces the unending passage of time and the enduring nature of love, despite the physical separation. Brontë’s mastery of language and form ensures that her words linger, much like a haunting melody, capturing the essence of longing that permeates her work.
