Ellis Peters

by Edith Mary Pargeter

Start Free Trial

Critical Essays

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Analysis

Ellis Peters, the pen name of Edith Pargeter, revolutionized detective fiction by blurring the lines between "thrillers" and serious novels. Her works are characterized by intricate plots and deeply developed characters, showcasing her belief that detective stories should be as richly layered as any other form of literature. Through her creations, particularly the Felse family and Brother Cadfael series, Peters explored profound human interactions within vividly depicted historical and social settings.

Approach to Detective Fiction

Ellis Peters approached the genre of detective fiction with a unique blend of social narrative and engaging mystery. Unlike traditional thrillers focused solely on the crime and its resolution, Peters infused her stories with richly developed character studies and social commentary. She argued against the conventional distinction between thrillers and other novels, maintaining that "the thriller is a novel." Her dedication to character development is evident in her preference for amateur detectives, whose role in crime-solving arises from circumstance rather than profession. This allows her narratives to delve into themes of love, familial bonds, and personal growth.

The Felse Family and Broader Circles

The Felse family series centers on George Felse, a Central Intelligence Division detective sergeant, his wife Bunty, and their son Dominic. Each family member occasionally takes on the role of detective, allowing the series to explore different facets of human experience, from domestic life to international intrigue. Peters weaves their stories against diverse backdrops, ranging from central England to far-flung locations like India and Czechoslovakia. In contrast, the Brother Cadfael series is rooted in the medieval world of Shrewsbury, England, where the monk Cadfael navigates both monastic life and the political upheavals of the 12th century.

Distinctive Openings and Suspense

Peters masterfully constructs her novels with initial leisurely pacing that gradually builds into gripping suspense. For example, The Grass-Widow’s Tale begins with Bunty Felse reflecting on her life's frustrations, only to spiral into a complex murder and robbery case that rejuvenates her sense of identity and understanding of love. Similarly, A Morbid Taste for Bones introduces the mission of Shrewsbury monks in Wales before unveiling a murder mystery, exemplifying Peters's skill in setting the stage before plunging into the heart of a crime.

Characterization and Creation of Suspense

Peters's detective stories are as much about character exploration as they are about solving crimes. Her characters are well-rounded, vividly realized individuals who engage readers with their personal struggles and triumphs. Peters's talent for character development is matched by her adeptness at crafting suspenseful narratives. Her novels often feature thrilling sequences, such as the dramatic escape in The Grass-Widow’s Tale or the riveting chase in Saint Peter’s Fair.

Brother Cadfael: A Unique Detective

Brother Cadfael stands out as one of Peters's most memorable characters, combining worldly experience with spiritual insight. Before becoming a monk, Cadfael lived a life full of adventure and romance, fighting in the Crusades and traveling widely. His past bestows upon him a deep understanding of human nature, positioning him as a uniquely effective detective within the monastic community of Shrewsbury. Cadfael's garden, where he cultivates herbs for medicine and cooking, symbolizes the nurturing and sometimes dangerous aspects of human life.

The Gardening Metaphor

Brother Cadfael's garden is a living metaphor for both his character and the world he inhabits. As Cadfael nurtures his plants, he also fosters growth within his community, guiding others toward maturity and moral understanding. His detective work often involves "weeding out" malevolent elements, as seen in cases like Monk’s-Hood where murder is symbolically linked to the misuse of his herbal remedies. Through his role as a healer, Cadfael embodies Peters’s thematic focus on morality...

(This entire section contains 886 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

and the triumph of good over evil.

Focusing on Morality and Human Goodness

Peters's novels emphasize the moral dimensions of crime and justice, reflecting her belief that detective fiction should uphold "the side of the angels." Her stories are designed not only to entertain but also to affirm moral values and social order. Villains in her narratives are typically driven by ambition or greed, leading them to acts of treachery against "the innocent and the good." It is the task of characters like Brother Cadfael to restore order and justice, often by proving the innocence of the wrongly accused, such as in A Morbid Taste for Bones or Monk’s-Hood.

The Role of Love and Social Comedy

Love plays a central role in Peters’s stories, driving characters to seek justice and reestablish harmony. In the Brother Cadfael series, innocent young people often face false accusations or entrapments, requiring Cadfael's intervention. Meanwhile, young women collaborate with Cadfael, motivated by justice and love, to solve mysteries. Their efforts highlight Peters's commitment to portraying active, intelligent female characters. The series follows the tradition of social comedy, echoing themes of love's triumph and the restoration of social order.

Legacy and Broader Impact

Although Peters, as Edith Pargeter, wrote other historical novels, the Brother Cadfael series remains her most acclaimed work. The success of these stories led to a resurgence of interest in her earlier novels, including the Felse mysteries and the Heaven Tree trilogy. Adaptations of the Cadfael stories, such as the BBC television series starring Derek Jacobi, expanded her audience and cemented her legacy. Despite her passing, Peters's work continues to captivate readers, affirming her place as a visionary in the realm of detective fiction.

Next

Analysis

Loading...