Elizabeth Swados Essay - Critical Essays

Swados, Elizabeth


Elizabeth Swados 1951–

American playwright, composer, director, and juvenile novelist. The underlying theme behind Swados's theatrical works and music is the potential of the human spirit to overcome the harsh realities of life. Focusing especially on the resiliency of contemporary youth, she has presented their reactions to the world in her musical collection, Nightclub Cantata, and in Runaways, a musical theater piece about young people both literally and figuratively homeless. Swados synthesizes various forms of contemporary sound, combining them with Latin and tribal rhythms to create music that is vibrant, eclectic, and unconventional. She spent a year in Africa as composer and musical director for English director Peter Brook. Swados traveled with Brook's troupe throughout various African villages; the sense of community and the importance of ritual she experienced there has underscored much of her work, notably Runaways. Another important association for Swados was her partnership with director Andrei Serban, with whom she created contemporary stylizations of plays by such authors as Aeschylus and Chekhov. She also served as composer-in-residence with La Mama Experimental Theatre Club in New York City, and has been a faculty member at several universities. Swados has worked with producer Joseph Papp in many of his New York Shakespeare Festival productions, and it was Papp who was responsible for bringing Runaways to Broadway. The play evolved organically from Swados's interviews with students and runaways. Many of these young people later performed in the production, which has generally been praised as an honest and compassionate portrayal of the anger, energy, and courage of youth under pressure. Although Swados's songs are sometimes criticized for being too obvious, sentimental, self-conscious, or hysterical, and for having melodies that are unmemorable, songs like "To the Dead of Family Wars" and "We Are Not Strangers" from Runaways touchingly evoke the pain and pleasure of adolescence. She has been the recipient of two Obie awards: in 1972 for her score for Serban's production of Medea, and in 1977 for her direction of Runaways. In 1976 she wrote and illustrated The Girl with the Incredible Feeling, a fable about the importance of individuality, and recently adapted it for an off-Broadway production. Her musical adaptation of Dispatches, Michael Herr's autobiographical report of the Vietnam experience, was also recently staged off-Broadway. Merging highly charged emotional appeals with innovative dramatic techniques, Swados is credited with expanding the range of musical theatre and strengthening its appeal for a young adult audience.

Clive Barnes

["Nightclub Cantata"] is the most original and perhaps the most pleasurable form of nightclub entertainment I have ever encountered…. It is more in the pattern of the "Jacques Brel" show, but its accent, its manner and its atmosphere is quite different.

Miss Swados comes off as a force of nature….

What is fascinating about this "Nightclub Cantata" is simply its unique mixture of music, drama and pop entertainment. Miss Swados's own staging is a knockout—the actors are trained like human acrobats—and her choice of source material, much of it written by herself, runs from Sylvia Plath and Frank O'Hara to Carson McCullers. But in the event it is the music that does it.

I have always been interested by her music for other people's scenes. It sounded like Mr. [Peter] Brook and Mr. [Andrei] Serban, a little like Muzak for listeners, or background music for the thinking classes. Heard on its own its amazing perceptions become far more apparent.

From Mr. Brook she has learned the humble but radiant virtue of eclecticism. Miss Swados picks around the store-house of contemporary music like a bright-eyed jackdaw. To listen to her music is like hearing a collage of contemporary sounds; she is a sort of Kurt Schwitters of music. Her musical tone is both strange and familiar. Here you can pick up a touch of Kurt Weill, there will be more than a trace of calypso. But all this eclecticism...

(The entire section is 433 words.)

Michael Feingold

Let's go cautiously. Anyone expecting to discover a theatre piece in Elizabeth Swados's Nightclub Cantata had better take a second look at the title. It is not an opera, not one of the Greek plays Miss Swados is famous for setting, not a revue, not a play. It is a cantata, that quirky form halfway between opera and oratorio, a setting of somewhat dramatic texts that is meant to be sung rather than acted. And it is a cantata meant for performance in a nightclub, where the audience can smoke, drink, and at least whisper during the show, can observe coolly rather than being mobilized in a body to participate vicariously….

Not, of course, a cantata in the normal sense of the word, for Swados does not write "normal" music. Her methods are monodic or responsive chant, recitative, patter-singing, the percussive use of unpitched sounds, intoning in unison or parallel thirds, and the repertory of clicks, shrieks, growls, and wails that we associate with birds, animals, and the tribal languages of Africa and Latin America. Swados is, in short, a neo-primitive—though her "primitivism" has more sophistication than a hundred years of hack composing in the traditional Western musical theatre, a fact that is pointed up by her choice of texts. No primitives here: Delmore Schwartz and Pablo Neruda, Muriel Rukeyser and Sylvia Plath, Frank O'Hara and Carson McCullers. If not for the wildly different nature of the music, it might be a Ned Rorem...

(The entire section is 571 words.)

Edith Oliver

Miss Swados' idea [in "Nightclub Cantata"] is to take poems and passages of prose by various hands (including her own), set them to music for various instruments (including her own guitar), and turn them over to the four young men and four young women of the company (including herself) for performance. Several of the numbers are fierce and angry, and they are delivered with passion—Muriel Rukeyser's "Waking This Morning"…, for example …, and Sylvia Plath's "The Applicant."… Something quite different is "Bird Lament," which Miss Swados sings entirely in bird language…. The weakest numbers, to get them over with as quickly as possible, are a passage from "The Ballad of the Sad Café," in which Carson McCullers makes several obvious points on the subject of love with unwarranted emphasis, and "Are You with Me?," a love ballad by Miss Swados that … made me long for Rodgers and Hart or the Gershwins, who handled this sort of thing with more finesse and just as much conviction. Lest I make the show sound too earnest (it is quite earnest), let me say right away that there is some comedy as well—a bit about two ventriloquists' dummies (written by Miss Swados and Judith Fleisher), and another bit, of venerable antecedents, about a troupe of maladroit acrobats. The strengths of "Cantata" far outnumber its weaknesses…. The climax of the evening (for me, at any rate) is Isabella Leitner's "Isabella"—a woman's horrifying, numbing memories of a concentration camp…. It must also be said that there are moments in the show when the delivery and the movements seem too intense for the material—perhaps a matter of over disciplined direction (Miss Swados again)—but the absolute clarity of everything more or less cancels that out…. Miss Swados' music is undeniably dramatic, original, and effective, though it does tend to evaporate rather quickly once it is finished. (pp. 64-5)

Edith Oliver, in The New Yorker (© 1977 by The New Yorker Magazine, Inc.), January 24, 1977.

Harold Clurman

To call a Greenwich Village "barroom" show Nightclub Cantata may sound a bit uppity but as a matter of fact the name conveys the exact nature of its content…. There are numbers like the spoof on an acrobatic stunt act which fits a nightclub performance. For the rest, with a few exceptions, the show has a seriousness which justifies the designation of "cantata." On this occasion, [the Greenwich Village "barroom"] has been turned into an existentialist café.

The show's overall tone, "Conceived, composed and directed" by Elizabeth Swados is gritty, brave, somber and exhilarating withal. It reflects the best part of a youth which has for some time now lived in a discouraging world, a youth of few illusions, a youth emotionally and physically tattered, but yet eager to continue its life without renouncing joy, despite an experience and foreknowledge of anxiety, deception and pain. One has only to scan the list of the writers whose poems or prose Elizabeth Swados has set to her music: there is Nazim Hikmet, a Turkish poet who died in prison; contributions by Pablo Neruda, Sylvia Plath, Frank O'Hara, David Avidan, an Israeli who writes in Hebrew; by Delmore Schwartz, Muriel Rukeyser, Isabella Leitner and Ms. Swados herself.

The collective import of the words spoken or sung, and for the most part, distinctly heard, is that one must endure life and even "dance" in it, though it be heavy and rough as a "fat rock." The...

(The entire section is 464 words.)

Alan Rich

The first time I came across music by Elizabeth Swados was at La Mama a couple of years ago, during one of Andrei Serban's stagings of some Greek play or other. The room, as I remember it, was full of flying bodies: actresses being thrown off balconies, things like that. Although I spent most of the evening cowering in protected areas, I do remember every now and then picking up a snatch of something that sounded like bad Carl Orff (very bad, in other words) to texts that sounded something like gratch, grotch, pook. I left with the firm resolve that the mysteries of Ms. Swados's art—to say nothing of Mr. Serban's—might be safer in other hands in the future.

But now there is Nightclub...

(The entire section is 341 words.)

Irene S. Levin

The relating of a fable is, at best, a difficult task. When it is attempted with a Y.A. audience in mind, it is even more difficult. Elizabeth Swados has accomplished the impossible. She has managed to instill in this fable [The Girl With the Incredible Feeling], the story of a girl who was different and found that when she listened to a drummer other than her own she lost her own individuality and sense of being…. It is meant to be a short read and a long discussion. Excellent for the beginning of a discussion on "being" and "to thine own self be true". Forget about the format of the children's book, which it is, teenagers will hear about this by word of mouth and read it anyway. (p. 32).


(The entire section is 137 words.)

Mel Gussow

["Runaways"] is an inspired musical collage about the hopes, dreams, fears, frustrations, loneliness, humor and perhaps most of all, the anger, of young people who are estranged from their families and searching for themselves. There are moments of joyfulness and youthful exuberance, but basically this is a serious contemplative musical with something important to say about society today….

[In a mosaic of songs, monologues, scenes, poems, and dances, we are given] a complete portrait of urban children on the run. We see what prods youngsters to leave home and what disturbs—and nurtures—them in their escapes. The musical takes a harsh and uncompromising look at the world of runaways, but it is...

(The entire section is 358 words.)

Edith Oliver

There is no story [to "Runaways"]—one number just follows another—but underneath run the themes of abandonment, anger, and bewilderment, and (lest you think all is unrelieved gloom and reproach) of chipper opportunism in any number of situations, and of innocence and humor and bravery and bravado. Rarely have I seen so much energy and spirit on a stage. In a sense, "Runaways" could be considered a confessional musical, like "A Chorus Line," in that the characters talk directly about themselves to the audience and act out their stories…. Although these characters are for the most part victims (and for the most part victims of parents), there is not a moment of sentimentality or commercial wistfulness. It is their...

(The entire section is 273 words.)

Jack Kroll

Multitalented 27-year-old Elizabeth Swados has what D. H. Lawrence called an intelligent heart. It's this quality of highly charged feeling shaped by insight, empathy and compassion that makes her extraordinary urban pop cantata "Runaways" an immensely affecting show. To call it far and away the best musical of the season is to insult it. "Runaways" seizes your heart, plays with your pulse, dances exuberantly across the line that separates entertainment from involvement.

Swados's runaways are the deracinated, disconnected kids of the metropolis who have been cut off from the human continuity that families are supposed to provide. As writer, composer and director, Swados over a ten-month period...

(The entire section is 276 words.)

John Simon

Let's pretend that nobody has overused the word "nice." It is, therefore, still fresh and available to describe a show that is decent, appealing, enjoyable without being extraordinary. Such a nice show is Runaways, by Elizabeth Swados…. [The] most authentic runaway is Liz Swados herself…. The true runaway quality about her is mental; her invention races freely between the near-classical and the quasi-popular styles of composition, much of it in a special, somewhat fey, faraway province of the imagination. Miss Swados … writes tunes and words about a wonderland often as bizarre and menacing as Lewis Carroll's and, unfortunately, real.

Here the subject is, of course, runaway children from...

(The entire section is 408 words.)

Laura Shapiro

"Runaways is about anybody who's in transition, anybody who's separated," said Swados; but the songs and monologues are about one sort of distance more than any other, the distance between ourselves and our families. Parental fights, divorce, child abuse and general neglect are what the kids describe: their fantasies are about belonging. "Let me be young before I get old," is the climactic plea. "Let me be a kid." They sing about life on the street, about heroin and prostitution and violence; they also demonstrate skateboard technique, play basketball and dream….

The music composed for Runaways is as straightforward as the rest of the production, mainly variations on a few...

(The entire section is 295 words.)

Erika Munk

Once upon a time, Elizabeth Swados wrote a children's book called The Girl with the Incredible Feeling. In 1977—when I was still interested in Swados's work, though beginning to be troubled by it—I bought the book for my daughter Maja, then four. The story was about a girl who had a feeling (drawn as a multicolored blob) which made her sing, dance, "laugh at things others fought over," and have visions…. One day a man came out of the shadows and said the world could use this terrific feeling, so it was dressed up, therapized, explicated, plagiarized. The girl became "more popular," but the feeling grew weak and disappeared. After a while the girl felt empty inside and had horrible dreams. Every thing and...

(The entire section is 422 words.)

Stanley Kauffmann

It may sound pat … to praise a small inexpensive show. I risk it happily…. Swados made a musical from her book for children, The Girl with the Incredible Feeling, and called it The Incredible Feeling Show. It's the perfect title…. It's a long while since an hour and a quarter in the theater has passed in such sheer delight.

Swados's songs, a few of them reminiscent of her past works, are ingeniously based on pop forms….

If you're in New York during the run, even without children, take a plunge into a pool of bubbles. (p. 25)

Stanley Kauffmann. "Slay It With Music" (copyright © 1979 by Stanley Kauffmann: reprinted by...

(The entire section is 123 words.)

John Beaufort

[What] went wrong with "Dispatches"?

Certainly, in addition to all her other creative talents, Miss Swados proved (in "Nightclub Cantata" and "Runaways") an abundant aptitude for original musical-theater entertainment. "Dispatches," Michael Herr's hard-hitting, graphically authentic reportage from Vietnam, offered a challenge which unfortunately has not been met….

The magnitude of the subject [of Vietnam] looms over the inadequacy of Miss Swados' noisy gallimaufry.

Using passages from Mr. Herr's book as spoken links and lyric themes, Miss Swados embellishes the text with 21 musical numbers in a score that features rock-and-roll but which also includes blues,...

(The entire section is 188 words.)

Erika Munk

This is not an apocryphal story: A Vietnam combat veteran went to see Elizabeth Swados's Dispatches in preview. After the show he introduced himself, saying that he had been in Vietnam when Michael Herr was there and would like to talk to her whenever she had a moment. "I'm sorry, I can't," said Swados, "I'm too vulnerable."

Swados has always worked with material that cuts to the emotional quick and, based as it is on things that happen to real people, should allow us no recourse. At the same time she apparently needs to make art pretty, to create easy affect through coarse effects. To be moved by one of her pieces is to be pushed around; this was true of the concentration camp and political...

(The entire section is 354 words.)

Michael Feingold

Dispatches doesn't have any dramatic continuity; it is another Swados nightclub cantata, a setting of disconnected passages from Michael Herr's book of war reportage. Herr's main interest is what Vietnam did to one's consciousness, his own as much as the soldiers'. At one point he equates the moral upheavals caused by the war with the social upheavals going on back home, and refers to a "rock-and-roll war." This dubious phrase is the one that has misled Ms. Swados. Her war is staged as a rock concert…. It is not the silliest damn thing I've ever seen in my life (close, though), but it is certainly the most frustrating waste of a major opportunity….

[The net effect of Swados's]...

(The entire section is 513 words.)

Stephen Holden

Though billed as a "rock-war musical," there's hardly a moment of rock in Elizabeth Swados's adaptation of Michael Herr's Dispatches and only a child's storybook sense of war. One of Herr's triumphs was the invention of an electric-mosaic prose style whose intense emotional cross-currents and streetwise rhythms are the literary equivalent of hard-rock music. Dispatches is a sustained riff on the romance of fear, the pornography of war, and the limits of machismo. Like the greatest rock music, especially the voodoo psychedelic funk of Jimi Hendrix, its mixture of pain, humor, and superstition is as close to unbearable as it is compelling. The book takes off on the McLuhanist assumption that the same...

(The entire section is 421 words.)

John Simon

[Dispatches is a] sordid, even sinister, business. I am willing to believe that Herr's book is all they claim for it; all the more reason to bemoan the self-indulgent, sophomoric, and tuneless mess Miss Swados has made of it. Indeed, the entire Vietnam experience is trivialized, vulgarized, and, worst of all, made boring. It is one thing to take runaway children and portray their dropping out through clever verbal-musical vignettes; such kids do develop a gutter cleverness, are drawn to and drugged by rock music, and can be choreographed into dances of protest, wistful self-expression, kinetic energy as a substitute for purposeful activity.

But the Vietnam war, the soldiers, dismemberment and...

(The entire section is 217 words.)