Alienation and Loneliness

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Because of his condition, Merrick is completely isolated from regular society. Initially, he is part of a freak show, and later, he is confined to his quarters at London Hospital. When Treves first meets him, Merrick is treated as a curiosity and is in desperate need of companionship.

Even though Treves means well, Merrick remains alone at the hospital. Treves often sees him more as a subject to study than as a friend. The developing friendship between Kendal and Merrick is destroyed when they become too close. After her expulsion, Merrick feels even more isolated, painfully aware of what he has lost, which breaks his heart.

Beauty

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

In a society that worships beauty, Merrick stands as an outcast. His appearance is so distorted and grotesque that people run away in fear. He starkly contrasts with the lovely Mrs. Kendal, whose compassion exceeds her physical attractiveness. She looks past his deformities and acknowledges the beauty within Merrick's soul.

Creativity and Imagination

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Merrick discovers comfort in his art. In the solitude of his hospital room, he starts sketching St. Phillip’s. He sees a beauty in his artwork that he feels is missing from his own life. Despite his body failing him, Merrick’s mind uncovers hidden talents.

Fear

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Upon Merrick's arrival at Liverpool Station, he faces an assault from crowds of people gripped by fear. They are frightened by what they might turn into and are horrified by a disease they cannot comprehend.

Treves harbors his own anxieties. Reflecting the sentiments of many Victorians, Treves is apprehensive about sexuality and its implications—specifically, the surrender of control and the acceptance of emotions.

Freedom

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Due to Merrick's noticeable differences that provoke fear among the public, his movements are severely limited. The hospital is intended to be a refuge, but Merrick compromises his freedom for security. When Mrs. Kendal is forced to leave, Merrick feels helpless; he lacks the ability to make decisions and depends on Treves to bring her back. Merrick only experiences true freedom through death, as it releases him from his physical limitations.

Human Condition

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Treves views Merrick as a reflection of his own humanity and attempts to project his values and beliefs onto him. In doing so, he fails to recognize that Merrick is an individual with his own needs. Everyone who visits Merrick sees him as a representation of their own values.

Mrs. Kendal describes Merrick as gentle, cheerful, honest, and almost feminine—qualities she identifies with herself. The Bishop sees Merrick as religious and devout, reflecting the bishop’s own characteristics. Gomm perceives Merrick as practical and appreciative of his blessings, just like Gomm. The Duchess views Merrick as discreet, mirroring her own nature. Even Treves falls into this pattern, believing that Merrick is curious, compassionate, and concerned with the world, just like Treves himself.

Proteus Syndrome and Deformity

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Joseph Merrick, often remembered as "The Elephant Man," was born with the rare condition known as Proteus syndrome, a fact that significantly impacted both his life story and Bernard Pomerance’s theatrical portrayal of him. While some have mistakenly attributed Merrick's condition to neurofibromatosis, it was indeed Proteus syndrome that caused his dramatic physical deformities. These deformities not only shaped his identity but also sealed his fate as a spectacle in sideshows, where he was exhibited as an oddity to curious onlookers, thus becoming a symbol of human curiosity and exploitation.

Symbolism of St. Phillip’s Church Model

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

Within the confines of the hospital, Merrick devotes himself to crafting an intricate scale model of St. Phillip’s Church. This model emerges as the central symbol of the narrative, emblematic of Merrick's yearning to reshape his identity into something perceived as beautiful by society. Through his meticulous construction, Merrick...

(This entire section contains 215 words.)

Unlock this Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

imagines a transformation not just of materials, but of self; he sees both himself and those around him as performers, each playing their part in the theater of life. His commitment to this social role echoes in the attention he gives to the model.

Merrick's insight into his creation reveals a deeper understanding of representation and reality. "I did not begin to build at first," he reflects, "Not till I saw what St. Phillip’s really was. It is not stone and steel and glass; it is an imitation of grace flying up and up from the mud. So I make my imitation of an imitation." This statement underscores a dual layer of imitation, capturing Merrick's recognition of both the church as a symbol of ascendant grace and his own model as a reflection of that symbol. Thus, his creation becomes a poignant metaphor for his internal struggle and aspiration to transcend his circumstances, transforming the ordinary into something that aspires towards grace and beauty.

Deviance and Normality

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The theme of the arbitrary distinction between deviance and normality is poignantly explored in scene 12, "Who Does He Remind You Of?" Here, the narrative delves into the perceptions of Merrick by those around him, revealing more about them than Merrick himself. Mrs. Kendal observes him as gentle and cheerful, with an artistic soul that mirrors her own. She identifies qualities of honesty and femininity, suggesting a profound connection between them. Meanwhile, Bishop Walsham How perceives Merrick as a devout and religious figure, aligning these attributes with his own spiritual convictions. Similarly, Gomm views Merrick as a practical man, reflecting his own pragmatic nature.

Dr. Treves offers another layer, seeing Merrick as curious, compassionate, and socially aware, characteristics he finds in himself. The scene artfully captures the myriad ways people project their own identities onto Merrick, illustrating the thin line between deviance and normality. It underscores that what is considered "normal" is often a reflection of personal biases and cultural constructs. The scene reaches a symbolic conclusion as Merrick adds another piece to his model of St. Philip’s, a metaphorical act of building his own edifice of acceptance and belonging in a world eager to label him as deviant. This act stands as a testament to his resilience and the fluid nature of what society deems acceptable or strange.

Inner Nature and Philosophy

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The play delves deeply into the complex and nuanced character of Merrick, whose inner nature starkly contrasts with the superficial judgments of those around him. Despite being surrounded by a world often marked by ignorance and prejudice, Merrick embodies kindness, patience, love, and empathy. These qualities reflect his profound philosophical bent, allowing him to perceive realities that others overlook and articulate thoughts that others shy away from expressing. His ability to question societal norms and challenge accepted beliefs is illustrated when a hospital porter is dismissed for staring at him. Although Merrick views the action as exceedingly severe, Treves defends Gomm’s decision, highlighting Gomm's supposed mercy. Merrick’s poignant inquiry, "If your mercy is so cruel, what do you have for justice?" underscores his ability to scrutinize the moral fabric of his environment and question the true nature of justice and compassion. Through this, Merrick emerges not just as a sympathetic figure but as a thinker who challenges the conventional wisdom of his time.

Vulnerability and Exploitation

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

The narrative intricately explores the entwined themes of vulnerability and exploitation, depicting a world where these elements shape the destinies of its characters. At the heart of the story is Merrick, a figure who suffers victimization yet rises above it through the resilience and beauty of his inner nature. His journey contrasts sharply with that of Ross, who embodies unbridled greed. Ross's actions are governed by a relentless desire for profit, exploiting individuals and circumstances with a blatant disregard for the harm he inflicts on himself and others.

Amidst these polarized characters stands Treves, whose complexity adds depth to the narrative. He straddles the line between exploiter and exploited, caught in the machinations of a society that rewards those who adhere to its rigid norms. Treves's ascent to fame and success comes at a price, as it gradually erodes his integrity and conscience, exposing him to the very exploitation he unknowingly perpetuates. This multifaceted exploration of human nature reveals the intricate balances of power, integrity, and morality, illustrating how individuals navigate a world rife with exploitation, often becoming entangled in its web as both victims and perpetrators.

Social Deformities and Treves' Realization

Download PDF PDF Page Citation Cite Share Link Share

While at first glance, the narrative centers around Merrick, the true lesson of the story unfolds through the character of Treves. As an affluent member of society, Treves grapples with deep disillusionment concerning the moral fabric of his environment, lamenting the pervasive "social deformities" that arise from "unlimited resources and the ruthlessness of privilege." His own achievements, cast in this light, become a source of inner turmoil. Recognizing that his charitable acts are tinged with self-interest and condescension, Treves's distress becomes an invitation for the audience to reflect on their own lives. Are they, too, hiding behind a veneer of civility to cloak their distorted inner selves? This introspective journey of Treves provokes a broader contemplation of societal values and personal integrity.

Previous

Summary

Next

Characters

Loading...