Student Question

What's April's dilemma between "downright disobedient and deadly dangerous" in The Egypt Game? What would you do?

Quick answer:

April's dilemma involves deciding whether visiting the "Egypt" location on Halloween is too dangerous or disobedient. She believes it's an exciting opportunity for spooky fun, while Melanie worries about potential dangers, like a lurking murderer. April argues they aren't explicitly forbidden from going, and with many people out on Halloween, the risk seems low. While technically breaking rules, the perceived safety makes it tempting. If I were April, I'd likely proceed, considering the circumstances.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

It's chapter 9 of The Egypt Game, and the kids are getting ready to celebrate Halloween. To April, this seems like a great opportunity for the gang to slip away and pay a visit to "Egypt" while everyone else is out trick-or-treating. April thinks it would be good, spooky fun for the gang to shine their flashlights and jack o' lanterns on the storage yard, creating a creepy half-light effect that would conjure up the perfect atmosphere for a night-time ceremony.

At first, Melanie thinks this is a great idea; in fact, it's the most exciting idea she's ever heard. But later on, doubts start to creep in. Although the Professor may not be the neighborhood psycho killer, the real murderer could still be lurking out there on the streets. Going to the Professor's storage yard, even if it's only for a few minutes, might be deadly dangerous as well as downright disobedient.

But, as April has already pointed out, there's no real disobedience involved in going to the storage yard. No one has expressly forbidden the kids from going there. Technically speaking, they'll be breaking the rules by sneaking off from Mr. Barkley's and Mr. Kamata's trick-or-treat group under cover of darkness. But if all goes according to plan, they won't be missed. As for deadly danger, well, there are lots of people out and about on Halloween, so it's unlikely that the local neighborhood psychopath will check in any time soon.

Halloween night presents an opportunity too good to miss for the Egypt gang to perform a creepily unforgettable ceremony. All things considered, it's neither downright disobedient nor deadly dangerous, and so if I were in April's position, I'd probably go right ahead. (Though I wouldn't wear the same costume.)

Get Ahead with eNotes

Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.

Get 48 Hours Free Access
Approved by eNotes Editorial