(Edward) Rod(man) Serling Criticism
Rod Serling (1924–1975) was a distinguished American scriptwriter and producer, celebrated for infusing television with the depth and quality of stage drama. Renowned during television's early years, Serling addressed complex social issues, such as prejudice and political corruption, setting him apart as a leading writer of his time. His bold approach to social themes, often avoided by his peers, established him as a pivotal figure in TV's Golden Age.
Serling's rise began in radio during college, leading to a prolific phase in television in the 1950s. His teleplay Patterns, aired on "Kraft Television Theater," scrutinized corporate ruthlessness and won an Emmy, marking the first instance of a network re-airing a drama due to audience demand. Another acclaimed work, Requiem for a Heavyweight, broadcast on "Playhouse 90," portrayed the tragic downfall of a boxer, earning Serling both an Emmy and a Peabody Award—the first for a television writer.
Throughout the mid-20th century, Serling was revered for his high-quality writing and critiqued network censorship, advocating for artistic freedom in television. This earned him the moniker "television's angry young man," admired by contemporaries for his dedication to free expression.
Adapting to shifts in television, Serling created The Twilight Zone (1959-1964), blending science fiction, fantasy, and horror into a series format that prioritized storytelling. Despite the mixed reception of subsequent projects like "Rod Serling's Night Gallery," The Twilight Zone remains a classic, renowned for its innovation and moral depth, as praised by 'Twilight Zone' Is Hottest CBS Series and Where Is Everybody?. His screenplay contributions, including Seven Days in May, acclaimed by What Five-Sided Building?, and Planet of the Apes, showcased his adeptness in film.
While some criticized his work as didactic, Serling's strong moral vision and craftsmanship significantly shaped television's formative years, influencing future storytelling, as noted by Rod Serling, Television Censorship, 'The Twilight Zone'. His legacy endures through reruns and adaptations, appealing to generations of viewers.
Contents
-
The Efficient Murderer
(summary)
In the following essay, Robert Lewis Shayon critiques Rod Serling's television drama "Patterns," arguing that while it powerfully exposes the ruthless dynamics of corporate culture, it inadvertently condones moral compromise and murder as acceptable byproducts of capitalist success.
-
Trial for Treason
(summary)
In the following essay, J. P. Shanley evaluates Rod Serling's television drama "The Rack," noting its departure from Serling's previous work, "Patterns," by tackling the complex and controversial theme of moral conduct under duress, despite certain narrative shortcomings.
-
TV: 'Strength of Steel'
(summary)
In the following essay, J. P. Shanley critiques Rod Serling's television play "Strength of Steel" as a lackluster effort, suggesting its reliance on clichéd narrative devices is a far cry from the writer's more acclaimed works like "Patterns" and "The Rack."
-
'Twilight Zone' Is Hottest CBS Series
(summary)
In the following essay, Tod Raper praises "The Twilight Zone" for its innovative storytelling that blends fantasy with reality, creating a visceral and engaging viewing experience that challenges traditional television norms.
-
Where Is Everybody?
(summary)
In the following essay, Helm praises Rod Serling's Where Is Everybody? as an imaginative and compelling drama that elevates The Twilight Zone, offering a new dimension to television far removed from typical genres, and highlighting Serling's qualitative writing and innovation.
-
Ways and Means
(summary)
In the following essay, Brendan Gill critiques "Requiem for a Heavyweight," emphasizing Rod Serling's script as a sentimental yet refined pastiche that elevates the prizefighters-and-gangsters melodrama to a near-perfect cinematic experience through its exceptional humanity and finesse.
-
The Rise of Jane Fonda
(summary)
In the following essay, Stanley Kauffmann critiques Rod Serling's Requiem for a Heavyweight for its unrealistic plot and clichéd dialogue, suggesting that the work unsuccessfully combines sentimentality with grandiose themes.
-
What Five-Sided Building?
(summary)
In the following essay, Philip T. Hartung argues that Rod Serling's script for "Seven Days in May" captivates audiences with its thrilling depiction of a Pentagon coup against a U.S. President, effectively portraying the potential for such an event in a post-cold war context.
-
A+
(summary)
In the following essay, Brendan Gill commends "Seven Days in May" as a "perfect" thriller, highlighting its gripping plot, convincing portrayal of a right-wing conspiracy in Washington, and its ability to make implausible scenarios appear remarkably plausible through effective storytelling and direction.
-
On Rod Serling, James Agee, and Popular Culture
(summary)
In the following essay, Jack Behar critiques Rod Serling's transition from television to film, arguing that the televised version of Requiem for a Heavyweight captures the raw intensity and mythic presence of its characters better than the film adaptation, which dilutes the original's impact with contrived elements and unnecessary sensationalism.
-
The Naked Human
(summary)
In the following essay, Philip T. Hartung highlights the intense debates between apes and humans in "Planet of the Apes," emphasizing the film's captivating screenplay, infusion of humor, and a chilling conclusion that serves as a stark warning to humanity.
-
An Uglier Violence
(summary)
In the following essay, Robert Lewis Shayon critiques Rod Serling's teleplay Certain Honorable Men for its selective portrayal of Congressional ethics, arguing it focuses on simplistic ethical violations rather than the deeper systemic issues that were central to the real-life case of Senator Thomas J. Dodd.
-
Rod Serling's 'Night Gallery'
(summary)
In the following essay, Cleveland Amory critiques "Rod Serling's Night Gallery" for failing to match the quality of Alfred Hitchcock's works, arguing that despite featuring stories with potential and notable stars, the series lacks compelling endings and coherence, ultimately leading to a sense of dissatisfaction among viewers.
-
Requiem for a Heavyweight: Final Tribute
(summary)
In the following essay, Mark Olshaker examines Rod Serling's enduring influence on television, highlighting his unique ability to integrate moral themes and social commentary within popular science fiction, notably in The Twilight Zone, while also portraying his struggle with the dichotomy of being a serious artist and a media personality.
-
Rod Serling, Television Censorship, 'The Twilight Zone'
(summary)
In the following essay, Lawrence Venuti argues that Rod Serling, initially a realist playwright committed to social commentary, ingeniously navigated television censorship by shifting to fantasy in "The Twilight Zone," using it as a vehicle for indirect yet profound critiques of American society, thereby preserving his integrity as a socially conscious writer.