Critical Essays
Analysis
Edward Lear, often hailed as the pioneer of nonsense literature, crafted works that extend beyond mere amusement. His poems endure for their melodic charm and the reflection of his own innocence and exuberance. Lear's creations reveal a whimsical yet profound exploration of themes such as individuality versus societal norms, the pursuit of happiness, and the nuances of human relationships.
The Limerick Form
Lear's delightful "nonsense rhymes" or limericks find their origins in earlier works such as "There was a sick man of Tobago" from Anecdotes and Adventures of Fifteen Gentlemen (circa 1822). Characterized by their signature opening lines featuring an "Old Man [or Old Person, or Young Lady] of [place name]," these verses conclude with a similar refrain, often humorously altered. Accompanied by Lear's charming cartoons, these characters—whether riding geese or perched in trees—enthrall with their eccentricity. Frequently depicting aged but spirited personalities, Lear's limericks captured the imagination of Victorian children, inviting them to laugh at adults behaving absurdly.
Formulas for Humor
Lear excelled in crafting humor through incongruity. Characters might meet absurdly grim ends, such as drowning or being baked into cakes, yet their plights are portrayed with levity. The text often suggests they deserve their fate or remain blissfully unaware of it. This playful approach allows Lear to explore themes of individuality in conflict with societal expectations. His work subtly critiques the arbitrariness of societal judgment, as seen in "a man who danced a quadrille with a Raven" being "smashed" by his countrymen.
Imaginary Settings
In Lear's imagined worlds, animals converse, objects dance, and odd friendships bloom. His settings defy conventional decorum, allowing anything wonderful to happen. Here, owls marry pussycats, and peculiar characters set sail for fantastical lands like "the great Gromboolian Plain." These worlds propose an alternative reality where whimsy reigns supreme, free from societal constraints.
Marriage, Family, and Freudian Interpretations
Lear's ambivalence towards traditional marriage and domestic roles is evident in his whimsical critiques of courtship rituals. His "laughable lyrics" often subvert gender norms, reflecting perhaps his own complexities concerning intimacy. As critics like George Orwell have noted, Lear's work reveals deeper, possibly conflicted emotions surrounding sex and relationships. These are visible in his characters, such as the timid owl of "The Owl and the Pussycat" or the effeminate kangaroo of another tale.
"The Courtship of the Yonghy-Bonghy-Bò"
In "The Courtship of the Yonghy-Bonghy-Bò," Lear crafts a tale of unrequited love with a comical twist. The titular character's proposal to a married woman results in his self-imposed exile to "the sunset isles of Boshen." This piece, enhanced by Lear's own piano accompaniment, is rich with sound play, echoing the lyricism of Romantic poetry while parodying its tropes. Lear's emotional investment in "The Yonghy-Bonghy-Bò," written during personal turmoil, underscores the depth beneath its playful surface.
"The Pelican Chorus"
In "The Pelican Chorus," Lear portrays a contented avian couple who celebrate their daughter's union with the King of the Cranes. The poem balances humor and nostalgia, capturing the pelicans’ joy and their fond memories of their daughter. Lear's skillful blend of melancholy and humor ensures the piece remains engaging rather than overly sentimental. The pelicans’ pride in their distinctive features and their playful visualization of their daughter’s future exemplifies Lear's ability to evoke complex emotions through whimsy.
"Mr. and Mrs. Discobbolos"
"Mr. and Mrs. Discobbolos" narrates the tale of a family living in self-imposed isolation atop a wall to avoid societal interactions. When Mrs. Discobbolos laments their children's lack of social experiences, Mr. Discobbolos’s drastic reaction of dynamiting their home into oblivion is both shocking and humorously absurd. This act reflects Lear’s critique of conventional domesticity, suggesting...
(This entire section contains 833 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
that such isolation might ultimately be preferable to the conformities of societal life.
"Incidents in the Life of My Uncle Arly"
"Incidents in the Life of My Uncle Arly," published posthumously, offers an autobiographical glimpse into Lear's own life. This poignant narrative, inspired by "The Lady of Shalott," recounts the journey and demise of a lonely man. Uncle Arly's burial with a railway ticket and a "pea-green Cricket" symbolizes Lear's lifelong wanderlust and his creative muse. This piece underscores the tension between Lear's solitude and the richness of his experiences, rendering it both sad and reflective.
"Eclogue"
The "Eclogue" features a singing contest between Lear and John Addington Symonds, where they humorously enumerate their miseries. While comically self-pitying, the piece resonates with those familiar with Lear’s correspondence, revealing how his light-hearted satire often mirrored his self-perception. Despite Lear's playful lamentations, his success with A Book of Nonsense underscores his impact and enduring appeal.
"The Quangle Wangle’s Hat"
In "The Quangle Wangle’s Hat," Lear envisions a community of exotic creatures finding sanctuary on the hat of the title character. This gathering, joyful and harmonious, contrasts starkly with real-world societal constraints. The Quangle Wangle, embodying Lear himself, finds happiness through friendship and shared experiences, offering a hopeful vision of contentment. This poem encapsulates Lear's belief in the power of imagination and camaraderie to transcend the boundaries of reality.