Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

During the 1930’s, the historical novel became extremely popular. Most of them followed the same pattern: They were long, had many characters, were full of action and realistic detail, and usually ended happily. Drums Along the Mohawk has all of these qualities, and it is one of the best of the genre. In 1936, it was on the best-seller list. In his author’s note, Walter D. Edmonds defends the genre, noting that the life presented is not a bygone picture, for the parallel is too close to the reader’s own. The valley people faced repercussions of poverty and starvation and were plagued by unfulfilled promises and a central government that could not understand local problems. Thus, the valley farmers, in the typically American tradition, learned to fight for themselves and for the land they had worked so hard to wrench from the wilderness.

Contrary to the patriotic myth, the war was not a glorious fight for freedom for all American soldiers. Many fought only because it was necessary to protect their families. They never thought of the American troops in the South and East; that was too remote, while the ever-present threat of immediate disaster was too near. When Captain Demooth says to Gil, “Who gives a damn for the Stamp Tax?” Gil admits that it has not bothered him and asks the key question of most of the farmers: “Why do we have to go and fight the British at all?” The attitude of many of the men conscripted for the militia is “Damn the militia! I need to roof my barn.” Yet, as the attacks upon the small settlements begin, they realize that they must band together and fight.

At times, the western settlers wonder which side is the enemy. Denied food, munitions, and the protection of regular troops by the government at Albany, their seed grain commandeered and their fences burned for firewood, the settlers of German Flats become extremely bitter at the indifferent treatment they receive. When the widowed Mrs. Reall, with her many children, tries to collect her husband’s back pay, she is denied because he is not marked dead on the paymaster’s list. Even though Colonel Bellinger swears that he saw Reall killed and scalped, the money is withheld. The only alternative she is given is to file a claim before the auditor-general, which must then be passed by an act of Congress. In the meantime, the family must either starve or rely on the charity of others who cannot really afford to help. They find that the Continental currency is practically worthless, but the climax of the...

(The entire section is 1032 words.)