Certainty
A central theme in Doubt is the challenge of achieving certainty, even within a faith-based context. The two protagonists, Sister Aloysius and Father Flynn, are steadfast in their worldviews and refuse to consider alternative perspectives. This inflexibility serves as both their strength and their downfall, ultimately leading to a tragic end. Meanwhile, Sister James and Mrs. Muller, the other key characters, are plagued by doubt and able to perceive both sides of their predicament.
Sister Aloysius is convinced that sexual misconduct is occurring at St. Nicholas, even before any solid evidence is presented. Late in the play, she reveals that her certainty stems from a minor incident: a student's reaction to Father Flynn's touch. The evidence she gathers is tenuous and easily dismissed. She interprets trivial matters, such as the length of Father Flynn's fingernails and his talks with the boys about masculinity, as supporting her suspicions. Despite Father Flynn providing plausible explanations for his actions, she remains unyielding. He suspects that her personal dislike for his teaching methods may be bolstering her conviction. She is even prepared to risk causing trouble for the boy, who is presumably the victim. It is only in the play's final line that she admits to having doubts.
Father Flynn, on the other hand, is equally convinced that he is a positive influence, believing his focus on love and empathy is more beneficial for the boys than Sister Aloysius's approach. Ultimately, his departure from St. Nicholas appears to suggest guilt, yet he never explicitly admits any wrongdoing.
Mrs. Muller takes a pragmatic stance, acknowledging that tolerating a bad situation might result in a greater benefit. She suspects a relationship between her son and Father Flynn, but she understands that exposing it could harm her son's future more than the priest's actions. She considers the limited time until graduation, her husband's anger, and the advantages of finishing at a reputable school, concluding that the moral dilemma is complex with no clear answers.
Sister James plays a crucial role in this narrative, as she embodies the conflict over certainty. Initially, she believes that teaching with empathy is best, but Sister Aloysius persuades her that strict discipline trumps compassion. When Father Flynn seeks her support, he argues that Sister Aloysius's harsh methods contradict the Bible's teachings on love. Torn between logic and emotion, reason and compassion, Sister James finds her certainty shaken, embodying the sense of doubt that Doubt aims to instill in its audience.
Gender Roles in the Church and the World
Sister Aloysius often feels exasperated in her efforts to remove Father Flynn due to the Church's hierarchy. She eventually realizes that the Church's structure is designed to keep men in positions of power, making it challenging for her, even as the school's principal, to take the necessary actions to safeguard her students. In Act 4, she shares with Sister James a memory from a previous parish where a sexually predatory priest needed to be removed from interacting with children. She says, "But I had Monsignor Scully then … who I could rely on. Here, there's no man I can go to, and men run everything."
Beyond the Church, society mirrors this division of male and female roles. Mrs. Muller visits the principal alone because her husband is busy working, reinforcing the traditional roles of men as breadwinners and women as caregivers. However, when their son, Donald, faces trouble at school, his father steps in as the disciplinarian, wielding a level of violence so severe that his wife fears it might endanger the boy's life.
Vulnerability
In Doubt , two characters embody vulnerability. The first, and most evident, is Donald Muller, a student suspected of being...
(This entire section contains 220 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
sexually abused. As a recent transfer and the first black student at St. Nicholas, Donald finds himself in a precarious situation. When Sister Aloysius learns that Father Flynn has become Donald's "protector," she quickly assumes his intentions are predatory. She tells Sister James, "He's isolated. The little sheep lagging behind is the one the wolf goes for." While Sister James and Father Flynn view Donald's vulnerability as a call for care and protection, Sister Aloysius is convinced that a malicious predator will exploit any weakness.
Simultaneously, Sister Aloysius is preoccupied with concealing Sister Veronica's frailties from the Church leadership. Sister Veronica's vision is deteriorating with age, and Sister Aloysius worries that if this becomes widely known, the Church might relocate her from the parish. Her protective instincts for Sister Veronica place Sister Aloysius in a peculiar role, as she must shield the aging nun from the institution she serves. However, when advising Sister James to look after Sister Veronica, she admits, "I cannot afford to lose her." Her concern over Sister Veronica's vulnerability is partly driven by her desire to maintain power. In a way, Sister Aloysius exploits Sister Veronica's vulnerability similarly to how she suspects Father Flynn is exploiting Donald's.
Sexual Abuse
Any sexual relationship between an adult and a minor is technically classified as sexual abuse, as a minor is generally considered to lack the life experience and knowledge necessary to give informed consent. It is especially unethical for someone in a position of authority, like a teacher or workplace superior, to engage in such a relationship with someone who might feel intimidated by their influence.
However, like many moral dilemmas, Doubt complicates what might otherwise seem straightforward. It portrays the relationship between Father Flynn and Donald Muller as emotionally complex, regardless of whether it includes a physical aspect. Father Flynn sees himself as a good person, believing that it is he, rather than Sister Aloysius, who truly cares for the boy's well-being. Donald's mother shares this belief; she recognizes the dangers her son faces, both in the hostile school environment and from his abusive father at home, and feels grateful that he has someone looking out for him. She is willing to accept the possibility of a sexual relationship between her son and the priest because she fears the absence of any relationship would be worse. "My son needs some man to care about him and see him through to where he wants to go," she says. "And thank God, this educated man with some kindness in him wants to do just that."
Mrs. Muller also suggests that Donald might have encouraged the relationship because, as she describes, he is "that way." While this may lessen some of the stigma associated with it being a homosexual relationship, it does not make it any less abusive. Even if the boy willingly participates and is not coerced into sexual activity, the adult is still culpable for abusing their power.
