Dogeaters
Jessica Hagedorn’s novel, "Dogeaters," provides a multifaceted portrayal of Filipino society during the Marcos era. Hagedorn, born in Manila and raised in the United States, brings her unique perspective and experience to bear in this dense and richly textured narrative. Through a diverse cast of characters, she explores themes of power, identity, and resistance against the backdrop of a politically turbulent Philippines.
Background and Themes
"Dogeaters," a term used derogatorily for Filipinos, serves as a provocative title. Like other works in Asian American literature, such as Maxine Hong Kingston’s "China Men" and Frank Chin’s "Aiiieeeee!," the title challenges derogatory stereotypes and confronts the reader with the complexity of cultural identity. Hagedorn’s narrative defies and subverts these stereotypes, encouraging Filipinos to resist being defined by pejorative labels. This theme of resistance is woven throughout the novel as it depicts the societal landscape of the Philippines during the infamous Marcos regime, spanning the 1950s to the 1970s.
Epic Form and Lyric Mode
The novel’s structure resembles that of modern epic novels, using filmic techniques to convey a broad view of society. This approach aligns "Dogeaters" with works like André Malraux’s epics, "La Condition humaine" and "L’Espoir," as it presents a wide array of characters from various societal strata in the Philippines. Through a montage of episodes, Hagedorn crafts a vivid collage of Filipino mores, giving readers a panoramic view of the nation’s complex social dynamics.
The Strata of Society
At the uppermost level of society in "Dogeaters" are the unnamed president and his wife, the "Iron Butterfly," a moniker reminiscent of Imelda Marcos’s "Steel Butterfly." Their portrayal is starkly critical, mirroring the decadence and stagnation of the Marcos leadership. Below them, the Alacran family represents the ruthless elite, with Severo Luis "Chuchi" Alacran at its helm, wielding power through media and entertainment enterprises. The Alacrans’ marriage and their daughter’s life choices further underscore the moral decay and superficiality of the elite class.
Contrasting this is the Avila family, led by Senator Domingo Avila, who symbolizes idealism and resistance. His character echoes that of real-life Senator Benigno "Ninoy" Aquino, and his assassination by government forces parallels historical events. The Avilas stand in opposition to the ruling regime, embodying national identity and the fight for democracy, themes that resonate deeply throughout Hagedorn’s narrative.
The Gonzaga family represents the upper middle class, with Rio Gonzaga as a pivotal character. Rio’s perspective offers insight into this social segment’s complicity and aspirations. Her cousin, Pucha, embodies the shallow values of her class, driven by materialism and racial superiority, while Rio herself symbolizes a more nuanced understanding of identity, challenging these superficial distinctions.
Underdogs and the Demimonde
The working class, or "underdogs," in the novel are represented by characters like Orlando "Romeo" Rosales and Trinidad Gamboa. Their dreams of a better life in Manila are thwarted by societal exploitation. Romeo’s ambition to be a movie star is a commentary on the influence of media and the illusion of upward mobility. His unjust framing for Senator Avila’s murder underscores the systemic oppression faced by the lower classes.
The novel also delves into a vibrant demimonde, populated by artists and performers of various sexual orientations. Joey Sands stands out among these, a biracial character who navigates the complexities of identity and survival in a society that marginalizes him. His journey from a disc jockey to a witness of political assassination provides a personal lens through which the broader societal unrest is viewed.
Narrative Technique and Character Interactions
Hagedorn skillfully employs multiple narrators, primarily first-person, to weave a rich tapestry of voices and perspectives. This approach enhances the novel's lyrical quality...
(This entire section contains 888 words.)
Unlock this Study Guide Now
Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.
Already a member? Log in here.
and allows for an intimate exploration of individual experiences against the backdrop of national turmoil. The assassination of Senator Avila serves as a central event, intertwining the destinies of characters across societal lines and highlighting the pervasive corruption and injustice of the era.
Recurring Imagery and Symbolism
The motif of food is a recurring symbol in "Dogeaters," representing both cultural identity and societal critique. From the indulgent consumption of Western brands by the elite to the humble, labor-intensive preparation of rice by the working class, food imagery underscores themes of class disparity and cultural authenticity. This motif extends into the realm of dreams and aspirations, with characters’ desires for a better life often portrayed through their culinary preferences.
Dreams, both literal and metaphorical, pervade the novel, reflecting the characters' yearnings and disillusionments. From Joey Sands’ fantasies of a new life abroad to Rio’s poignant dreams of her and her brother as moths drawn to the light, these aspirations speak to the broader societal discontent and the struggle for national identity. The first lady’s dreams, laden with symbolism, satirize the excesses of power and privilege, contrasting starkly with the genuine hopes of characters like the Avilas.
A Compelling Epic of Filipino Life
Through her ambitious narrative, Jessica Hagedorn offers a critical yet empathetic view of the Philippines during a tumultuous period. Her novel stands as a significant contribution to Asian American literature, notable for its depth, diversity, and the vivid immediacy of its characters. "Dogeaters" not only captures the complexity of Filipino society but also resonates with universal themes of identity, resistance, and the enduring quest for justice amidst corruption and oppression.
Style and Technique
Dogeaters is a novel that intricately weaves together themes of stagnation, fragmentation, and societal decay. Through its two main sections, "Part One: Coconut Palace" and "Part Two: The Song of the Bullets", the narrative unfolds in an episodic manner, populated by a diverse cast of characters. The novel's structure and technique create a vivid portrayal of a society caught in a cycle of corruption and moral decline.
Part One: Coconut Palace
In the first section, "Part One: Coconut Palace", the story is presented through a series of loosely connected scenes. These episodes, characterized by their episodic nature, feature a wide range of characters, many of whom are static and one-dimensional. This deliberate choice highlights the overall theme of societal inertia. Through foil relationships, the characters reflect the fragmented state of society, contributing to the depiction of degeneration and stagnation. Interspersed throughout these scenes are intercalary chapters that include excerpts from Jean Mallet’s The Philippines (1846) and fictional news stories from the made-up Metro Manila Daily newspaper. Other historical sources, such as William McKinley’s 1898 address, further enrich the narrative texture.
Varying Tones and Themes
The episodes in "Coconut Palace" vary widely in tone. The opening chapter sets a relatively innocent scene with Rio Gonzaga, Pucha Gonzaga, and their chaperone enjoying a movie and later indulging in a merienda at Café España. This contrasts starkly with the more sordid worlds explored in subsequent chapters. For instance, “Mister Heartbreak” delves into the demimonde, introducing characters like Joey, a disc jockey at CocoRico who seeks out other men, and Andres, the establishment's owner known as the Queen of Mabini. These characters inhabit a gritty world where the boundaries of gender and identity are blurred, exemplified by Andres’s intersex lover, Eugenio/Eugenia.
Part Two: The Song of the Bullets
As the novel transitions to "Part Two: The Song of the Bullets", the pace accelerates, and the plot strands multiply. This section follows the ill-fated journey of Romeo (Orlando) Rosales and Joey’s tumultuous affair with a German film director, Rainer, from whom Joey pilfers money and drugs. It also recounts the harrowing experience of Daisy Consuelo Avila, who suffers at the hands of General Ledesma. As the narrative unfolds, Joey’s frantic escape to his Uncle’s shack in Tondo, his betrayal, and subsequent flight with guerrillas add layers of suspense and urgency. Interwoven are surreal elements like the first lady’s peculiar dream and various media snippets, such as letters and news articles.
Language and Atmosphere
The language used in Dogeaters is a distinctive blend of Tagalog and Spanish, which enriches the atmospheric presence of the novel. While this linguistic choice might initially challenge those unfamiliar with these languages, it heightens the sense of fragmentation and alienation that pervades the narrative. This technique aligns with the novel's themes, intensifying the portrayal of societal disarray. The raw, unfiltered dialogue further underscores the pervasive disrespect towards women, a motif reinforced by the use of coarse language, even from female characters.
Overall, Dogeaters employs its unique narrative structure and language as tools to reflect the complex social dynamics of its setting. Through its episodic scenes, diverse characters, and kaleidoscopic storytelling, the novel presents a compelling, albeit unsettling, exploration of societal degeneration and cultural fragmentation.
Themes and Meanings
Dogeaters is a rich tapestry that intricately weaves the chaotic vibrancy of Manila society with its deep-rooted colonial influences. The novel masterfully delves into themes of reality versus fantasy, questioning what truths might emerge if the layers of deception are peeled away. Jessica Hagedorn invites readers to ponder the tumultuous interplay of aspiration and despair in a society where pretense is a way of life.
Exploding Pretense and Corruption
Jessica Hagedorn skillfully unmasks the facade of the ruling class, mercilessly satirizing the opulence and waste of a morally bankrupt regime. She juxtaposes this with the gritty desperation found in Manila's slum towns, such as Tondo, where characters like Joey and Uncle reside. Here, morality is often sacrificed at the altar of survival. In stark contrast, the guerrilla community of Daisy and her cousin Clarita, who provide Joey refuge in the mountains, embodies a rare glimpse of human warmth and solidarity. This community stands removed from the pervasive aggression and deception of city life, offering a glimmer of hope and transformation for characters like Joey and Rio.
Dreams and Fantasies
Central to Hagedorn's narrative are the dreams and fantasies that pervade the lives of her characters. These dreams, alongside radio serials and film plots, become manifestations of the fantastical worlds in which the characters seek solace. Joey's tumultuous dreams as he journeys to the mountains reflect his inner turmoil and fears. The novel's second half opens with a surreal, sacrilegious hallucination by the first lady, featuring Hollywood stars and religious figures, symbolizing the blurred lines between reality and illusion. The narrative concludes with Rio's recurring dream of her and her brother as moths drawn to a light, embodying the enduring allure of unattainable dreams.
The Power of Gossip
Gossip, or tsismis, serves as another binding thread among the characters of Dogeaters. Characters are as consumed by the act of gossiping as they are by their indulgence in food, drugs, and sex. Figures like Cora Camacho and the first lady wield gossip as a manipulative tool, weaving webs of misinformation. Even Rio's account of Pucha's life is cast in doubt by a final letter, hinting at the tenuous line between fact and fiction. The fictitious Metro Manila Daily further underscores the prevalence of gossip, with its intermittent inaccuracies and sensationalized reports.
A Controversial Title
The title Dogeaters itself has sparked controversy among Filipino readers, serving as Hagedorn’s bold statement on the society she depicts. The term, a pejorative label for Filipinos, is recontextualized to expose a cutthroat world marked by canine ferocity. This audacious title sets the tone for the novel, signaling a fearless exploration of societal taboos and forbidden subjects. Hagedorn’s narrative bravely challenges conventions, offering a raw and unflinching portrayal of Manila’s complex social landscape.
Historical Context
The rich tapestry of themes in Dogeaters weaves together gender dynamics, power structures, and societal expectations, revealing the complexities of personal and political relationships. The novel, recognized as a nominee for the National Book Award in 1990, delves into the malleable nature of gender identity and the harsh realities of male dominance. Through its candid narrative, it challenges traditional gender roles and exposes the dark undercurrents of misogyny.
The Fluidity of Gender
One of the novel's most compelling explorations is its depiction of gender as a fluid and dynamic construct. Characters such as Andres and Joey, who are gay, coexist with the intersex Eugenio/Eugenia and the transvestite "Uncle" Perdito, a dressmaker. These portrayals disrupt conventional ideas of male-female roles, highlighting that gender orientation is not fixed but rather a spectrum. This diverse representation invites readers to reconsider their own perceptions of gender and identity.
Challenging Male Dominance
The narrative also lays bare the pervasive male disrespect and dominance over women. From the opening scene, where young Pucha and Rio Gonzaga navigate a patriarchal society under the watchful eye of their chaperone, Lorenza, to Boomboom Alacran's objectifying behavior, the novel paints a vivid picture of the condescension women face. Severo Alacran's boastful flaunting of mistresses and his servants further exemplifies the entrenched misogyny.
Oppression and Resistance
General Nicasio Ledesma's abusive relationship with Lolita Luna exemplifies the brutality women endure. Ledesma not only reminds Lolita of her subordinate status but also physically abuses her. This power dynamic escalates with the rape and torture of Daisy, who, after enduring such trauma, emerges as a revolutionary figure. Her transformation into "Aurora" symbolizes empowerment, as she learns to wield firearms and teaches others, including Joey, to do the same.
Strained Relationships
Even in the absence of overt chauvinism, the relationships between men and women in Dogeaters are fraught with tension. This stands in stark contrast to the idealized notion of "happily ever after" often found in Hollywood narratives. Severo and Isabel Alacran's constant feuding, Daisy's swift marital dissolution with Malcolm, and the tumultuous end of Romeo's romance with Trinidad all serve as reminders that personal fulfillment is not guaranteed by marriage or romantic entanglements. General Ledesma and Lolita's relationship, far from domestic bliss, underscores the theme of discord.
Through its vivid depiction of gender and power, Dogeaters offers an unvarnished look at the societal norms that govern relationships. The novel's exploration of both individual and collective resistance to these norms provides a poignant commentary on the nature of identity and liberation.
Setting
Dogeaters is the chronicle of four Filipino families whose lives intersect as the plot unfolds. Most of the action takes place in the capital city of Manila, Philippines, in the 1950s. As the novel opens, it is many years later, however, and one of the three main narrators, a young girl named Rio Gonzaga, begins the story of her family with a flashback to 1956. A corrupt dictator and his former beauty queen wife (patterned after Ferdinand and Imelda Marcos) are in power. The country is a chaotic mix of corrupt politicians, waste and extravagance, abject poverty, fomenting rebellion, American movies, drugs, sex, beauty pageants, and violence. Against this backdrop, the characters search for identity, both personal and national, amid the turmoil of a country trying to define itself after a century of colonization.
Author Jessica Hagedorn describes the Philippines as a “tropical archipelago of 7,100 known islands.” It is a country “serenaded by mournful gecko lizards, preyed on by vampire bats,” and protected by giants that hide in the acacia trees. It is enchanted by evil spirits that live in caves. Its humid landscape swarms with beetles, flies, and butterflies. At certain times, locusts and cockroaches blacken the sky. Mosquitoes are everywhere, ready to infect children with brain fever. It is also a country awash in lush vegetation and adorned by a myriad of beautiful flowers that scent the air with their perfume. It is a “fragmented nation of loyal believers divided by blood feuds and controlled by the Church.” It is both beautiful and dirty, full of life and full of death. There is a cultural tug-of-war between the leftover influences of two former colonizers, Spain and the United States. It is a country of the very rich and the very poor, a corrupt nation controlled by dictators whose power is being challenged by a growing revolutionary movement. Its people are torn between the past and the present as they try to define their future. It is a country of contrasts.
The Philippines were colonized by Spain in the 1500s. They named the island nation Las Islas Filipinas after their king, Phillip II, and established their language and their religion. In the Treaty of 1898, which ended the Spanish-American War, Spain ceded the Philippines to the United States. During this war, the Philippines declared its independence from Spain. The United States refused to honor this independence, however, so the Philippines then declared war against the US (the Philippine-American War) but were soundly defeated. The US controlled the Philippines, making it a commonwealth in 1935. When World War II broke out, the Japanese invaded the country and established a puppet regime. The Japanese were defeated in 1945, and the United States gave the Philippines its independence in 1946. World War II ravaged the Philippines, however, and in the aftermath of war, the country’s multiple warring factions caused political instability for many years. In 1965, Ferdinand Marcos was elected president. His wife, Imelda (nicknamed “the Steel Butterfly”) was constantly by his side, and together they “ruled” the country with an iron hand. In Dogeaters, the Marcos character is called “The President” and his wife is referred to as “The First Lady” or “Madame.” Philippine law limited the presidency to two terms. When Marcos’s second term was nearing an end, he declared martial law in September 1972. In order to retain power, he established a strong military presence in Manila, represented in the novel by the cruel General Ledesma. Marcos justified martial law by claiming it was necessary to preserve the peace and protect the country from the Islamic insurgency, Cold War tensions, and threats of Communist rebellions. Several of the teenage characters in Dogeaters are arrested from time to time and must be bailed out of jail by their wealthy parents for minor infractions during the period of martial law.
In 1983, Marcos’s chief rival for power, Benigno “Ninoy” Aquino, returned from exile in the United States in an attempt to oust Marcos. Aquino was assassinated as he stepped off the plane at the Manila airport. In Dogeaters, this event is depicted by the death of the popular senator Domingo Avila. Opposition leaders convinced Aquino’s wife, Corazon, to run for president, but in a rigged election, Marcos was declared the winner. Rebellion broke out over the election results, and Ferdinand and Imelda Marcos eventually were forced into exile in Hawaii. Corazon Aquino became the new president of the Philippines in 1986, but the excesses of the Marcos regime had left the country with a staggering national debt. It was later revealed that the Marcoses had embezzled billions of dollars of public funds during their years in power.
By the time the Marcos regime was overthrown by the People’s Revolution (depicted in the novel by the beauty-queen-turned-guerilla Daisy Avila, sex worker Joey Sands, and revolutionary Santos Tirador), Filipinos had suffered twenty years of corrupt government, secret arrests, torture, mysterious disappearances (such as that of Romeo Rosales and Trinidad Gamboa in the novel), and assassinations. The first lady’s vanity and callousness was ridiculed all over the world. Imelda Marcos became a laughingstock when it was discovered, for example, that her closet contained over three thousand pairs of shoes.
The characters in the novel come and go in a mélange of Manila’s neighborhoods, from the ritzy Monte Vista Golf and Country Club where the Gonzagas, Avilas, and Alacrans spend their days drinking cocktails and playing golf, to the Tondo Dump where Joey Sands’s “Uncle” lives in a cardboard shack amid filth and disease. The wealthy characters spend hours each day having facials, manicures, and dress fittings in the most exclusive salons while the low-class, marginalized characters sniff, inject, and snort themselves into oblivion in sex clubs and brothels. The cloud of American colonial influence still lingers in the form of movies, department stores, fashion, food, and drink. The Spanish colonial influence still lingers in the form of the Catholic Church, which condemns all of the most popular American movies that the Filipinos want to watch. The military leaders live in posh subdivisions “patrolled by men in blue uniforms” and maintain secret torture camps where enemies of the state are questioned, tortured, and disappeared.
Jessica Hagedorn explains that in Dogeaters, she has tried to subvert fiction by peppering her novel with factual documents, speeches, and news reports. There are various snippets from Father Jean Mallat’s 1946 History of the Philippines, excerpts from a speech about the Philippines given by US President William McKinley, a poem by José Rizal, and several news articles from the Associated Press. These tricks of setting serve to realistically fictionalize the Marcos-era Manila. The novel’s setting is a postcolonial nation of conflicting social, cultural, political, and economic forces whose passive citizens are waiting to see what will happen in a country of “guns, goons and gold.”