Analysis

Download PDF Print Page Citation Share Link

Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 1132

It is significant that Dispatches should end with a reference to writing, for it is as a writer that Herr defines himself and, ultimately, how he makes sense of his experiences in the war. Although his final words in the narrative are “Vietnam Vietnam Vietnam, we’ve all been there,” he knows that this is not literally true, and his book becomes an avenue for his readers into the complexities of those experiences. Rather than preaching a series of moralistic lessons, however, Herr simply serves as a storyteller, allowing the reader to make his own discoveries. Herr is, in this manner, fulfilling his obligations as a writer.

Illustration of PDF document

Download Dispatches Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Herr’s foremost commitment is to the soldiers, to those whom he observes, about whom he hears, and with whom he interacts. At one extreme are those with whom he has little rapport. The reactions of these soldiers range from simple indifference to contempt, dogmatic disdain (a predictable reaction from those public affairs officers assigned to work with the press corps), and pure hatred (Krynski, a hardened marine, reacts this way when he realizes that Herr, a writer, has volunteered to risk his life for a story). Yet even when Herr’s initial response is to reciprocate these feelings, he comes to realize that his duty as a writer is to tell these soldiers’ stories. Whether overtly articulated as a demand or a passionate plea (“You tell it man. If you don’t tell it . . .”), Herr knows his obligations:And always, they would ask you with an emotion whose intensity would shock you to please tell it, because they really did have the feeling that it wasn’t being told for them, that they were going through all of this and that somehow no one back in the World knew about it.

Out of his compassion grows what one critic calls Herr’s “moral imperative”: a commitment to communicate an “extreme experience in a way that is both accurate and meaningful.”

At the other extreme are those soldiers who realize that he, as a writer, has a special importance. These troops willingly give him stories—about themselves, about their buddies, about people of whom they have merely heard. They allow him access to people and places and operations (at one point he is permitted to ride a special gunship during a night attack) normally closed to outsiders or to those who are uninitiated. This allows him glimpses of emotions and thoughts that no one else is privileged to see. They make room for him in troop carriers and on helicopters, both envying and respecting his need to move quickly to another location. In sum, these soldiers accord him special privileges out of respect for his work as a writer, and Herr reciprocates, quietly telling the stories of those he observes.

In the eyes of some soldiers, Herr becomes almost a godlike figure. This occurs when, early in his tour, soldiers offer him a flak jacket or helmet because he has left his own behind. Initially he believes that this is simply to protect the naive newcomer to the war. Retrospectively, he recognizes this as one of a series of gifts offered in obeisance to him. This is particularly apparent in his interaction with Day Tripper and Mayhew, the soldiers most fully developed as individual characters. Mayhew, specifically, exposes himself to personal danger several times to assure Herr’s comfort in the harshest of conditions at Khe Sanh. In telling these stories, Herr’s humility in being so honored surfaces; in relating how he learns of Mayhew’s death he cannot hide in his typically understated tones his sense of loss and frustration. Herr is, in a sense, telling his own story within the stories of the soldiers.

Yet his vatic impulse does not end simply with a depiction of the way it was for the soldiers. To be sure, he conveys the smells and sounds, the hardships of the cold and the heat, the...

(The entire section contains 1132 words.)

Unlock This Study Guide Now

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this Dispatches study guide. You'll get access to all of the Dispatches content, as well as access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts.

  • Summary
  • Critical Essays
  • Themes
  • Characters
  • Analysis
  • Quotes
Start your 48-Hour Free Trial
Next

Critical Context