Themes: Family Relationships
The theme of family relationships in The Diary of a Young Girl is central to Anne Frank's narrative. The diary reveals the complexities and tensions within the Frank family, as well as between the Franks and the Van Daans, with whom they share the Secret Annex. Anne's reflections on her relationships with her parents and sister, Margot, highlight the challenges of growing up in such confined and stressful conditions.
Anne's relationship with her mother, Edith, is often strained. Anne feels misunderstood and criticized by her mother, who she perceives as frequently disparaging. Anne writes, "
At moments like these I can't stand Mother. It's obvious that I'm a stranger to her; she doesn't even know what I think about the most ordinary things.<\/blockquote>" This quote underscores the emotional distance between them, exacerbated by their differing temperaments and the stress of their situation. Edith's attempts to correct Anne often lead to conflict, as Anne feels her mother does not appreciate her maturity.In contrast, Anne feels a strong bond with her father, Otto. He provides her with comfort and understanding, as seen in the birthday poem he writes for her. The poem acknowledges the difficulties of their situation and the challenges of parenting under such conditions. Otto writes, "
Please bear with us, your parents, for we try To judge you fairly and with sympathy.<\/blockquote>" This reflects his awareness of Anne's frustrations and his efforts to maintain a supportive relationship.The close quarters of the Secret Annex amplify family tensions. The Franks and the Van Daans must navigate their differences in a confined space, leading to conflicts. Anne notes the "terrific quarrel" between the Van Daans and observes the selfishness and irritability that arise from their stressful living conditions. These tensions highlight the strain that the circumstances place on family dynamics, as each member struggles to cope with the lack of privacy and the constant fear of discovery.
Anne's relationship with her sister Margot is also affected by their mother's favoritism. Anne feels isolated, as Margot is perceived as the "clever" and compliant daughter. This dynamic prevents Anne from forming a closer bond with Margot, further complicating her family relationships. Despite these challenges, Anne's diary serves as an outlet for her emotions and a means of understanding her place within her family.
Expert Q&A
What challenges does the family face in the Annex in The Diary of a Young Girl?
In The Diary of a Young Girl, Anne Frank describes the problems and challenges faced by those hiding in the annex, which include the need for strict silence in the day and no light at night; strained nerves and conflicts between the residents; extreme fear; and a lack of food and supplies.
Why did Anne Frank feel lonely and neglected?
Anne Frank feels lonely and neglected in the Secret Annex because she receives little emotional support from her family and the others hiding with her. Her mother and sister do not provide the care she needs, and she feels misunderstood and unappreciated. Her father offers some support, but not enough. Anne's isolation leads her to confide in her diary for comfort and understanding.
What caused tension and discord in Anne's relationship with her mother?
The tension between Anne and her mother stemmed from several factors. Anne disliked her mother's "dreadful sermons" and preferred her father's short-lived anger. Frequent criticisms from Edith, who often dismissed Anne's maturity, exacerbated their relationship. Both had combative personalities, leading to frequent quarrels, as seen when Edith insisted on calling maids "domestic help," which upset Anne. Ultimately, the lack of understanding and mutual criticism fueled discord between them.
In Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl, describe the differences between Anne and her mother. Who do you sympathize with more?
Anne and Mrs. Van Daan's Relationship in The Diary of a Young Girl
In The Diary of a Young Girl, Anne Frank's relationship with Mrs. Van Daan is complex and evolves over time. Initially, Anne sees Mrs. Van Daan as a lively and sometimes comforting presence, even confiding in her when she feels distant from her own mother. However, Anne becomes increasingly aware of Mrs. Van Daan's materialism and frequent complaints, which strain their relationship. Conflicts arise, particularly over Anne's friendship with Mrs. Van Daan's son, Peter, contributing to Anne's changing attitude toward her.
Why does Anne believe Margot has become less catty and more sweet?
Anne believes Margot has become less catty and more sweet because Margot now treats Anne as a real friend rather than a little kid. This change may stem from the necessity of getting along in their confined living space, Anne's growing affection for Peter, or Anne's own maturation and increased self-awareness. As Anne matures, her relationships, including the one with Margot, evolve, reflecting her transition from a moody child to a thoughtful young woman.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.