illustration of main character Hannah opening a door which leads to a barbed wire fence

The Devil's Arithmetic

by Jane Yolen

Start Free Trial

Student Question

What is the relationship between Aunt Rose and Hannah in The Devil's Arithmetic?

Quick answer:

In The Devil's Arithmetic, Aunt Eva is Hannah's great aunt. She is the sister of Hannah's paternal grandfather.

Expert Answers

An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

In The Devil's Arithmetic by Jane Yolen we meet a character called Rose when she greets Hannah and her family as they arrive at her grandparents' house in the Bronx. Aunt Rose welcomes them at the door and remarks upon Hannah's appearance and in particular how pretty she has become. Aunt Rose then gives Hannah a kiss which leaves a lipstick stain. Hannah goes to the bathroom and tries unsuccessfully to clean the lipstick off. Hannah then feels ashamed of herself because she has mixed feelings about her aunt. She is fond of her but is also beginning to see her more critically. For example, she is suspicious of her Aunt's opinions as she can see for herself in the mirror that she is fairly plain and doesn't like her brown hair and braces. She is also unsure about being named for an Aunt's deceased friend. Hannah reflects that Aunt Rose...

Unlock
This Answer Now

Start your 48-hour free trial and get ahead in class. Boost your grades with access to expert answers and top-tier study guides. Thousands of students are already mastering their assignments—don't miss out. Cancel anytime.

Get 48 Hours Free Access

sometimes exaggerates which shows that she is developing more adult critical thinking skills and is starting to leave childhood behind. As she exits the bathroom to rejoin her family she is nervous about running into other people who she may feel uncomfortable with. She feels that she was right about her worries on her journey from New Rochelle to see her grandparents for Passover Seder in the Bronx. She had said that she didn't want to visit her grandparents, guessing that she and her brother Aaron would be the only children there. She had been worried about being bored as the grown ups joked in Yiddish and told the children how much they'd grown.

Hannah goes back into the sitting room but no one seems to acknowledge her as they are huddled around Grandpa who is watching television. He angrily pushes his fist towards the television because he sees pictures of the Nazis and concentration camp victims. Everyone can see his wartime number tattoo as he has rolled up his sleeve on his left arm. Aunt Eva starts to apologize for him but Hannah is very familiar with his volatile reactions to the war. She even remembers being fascinated by his camp tattoo when she was was a little girl. She had even made a tattoo of her own in blue ballpoint ink on her arm, hoping he would like it. However he had frightened her with his angry response and his shouting had caused her to have bad dreams. Only having a child's understanding of his trauma, Hannah has found herself unable to forgive him for his verbal attack on her. She then finds herself critical of both of her aunts as Eva's apologies seem pointless.

Approved by eNotes Editorial
An illustration of the letter 'A' in a speech bubbles

How is Aunt Eva related to Hannah in The Devil's Arithmetic?

In The Devil's Arithmetic, Eva is Hannah's great aunt. Specifically, she is the sister of her paternal grandfather, Grandpa Will. Aunt Eva is Hannah's favorite relative at the Seder, because she shows more attention to Hannah than she does to Hannah's younger brother Aaron. Furthermore, Eva is particularly close with her nephew, Hannah's father. Since Grandma Belle was away at work so much during Hannah's father's childhood, Aunt Eva helped raise him.

Towards the end of the book, Hannah discovers Aunt Eva's true former identity. Before she left Europe, Eva was known as Rivka. She is the same Rivka that Hannah/Chaya switched places with at the concentration camp to save her life. Eva tells Hannah her story of survival and about Chaya's sacrifice. In fact, Hannah was given the Hebrew name of Chaya in memory of Eva's friend and savior at the camp.

When she came to the United States after the war, she changed her name from Rivka to Eva. Many Holocaust survivors changed their names in order to help them start a new life and move past the trauma of the Holocaust. She wanted to forget her terrible past. Yet, at the end of the book, she admits to Hannah that it is impossible to forget.

Approved by eNotes Editorial