Critical Overview
Dessa Rose (1986) was Williams's first novel after she had become accomplished as a poet. African American literature had been picking up speed since the strong work of the 1960s from writers such as Ishmail Reed (Amiri Baraka), Nikki Giovanni, and Audre Lorde. In the 1970s, Maya Angelou, Toni Morrison, and Alice Walker introduced their voices. The 1980s welcomed Rita Dove, Gloria Naylor and multiple titles from Morrison. In the 1980s, African American women wrote in a distinctly feminist perspective; the story lines focused on the bonds and communities of women who face adversity. Gloria Naylor’s Women of Brewster Place (1982) and the community of women in Morrison’s Beloved (1973) display these voices and characteristics of African American writers as does Dessa Rose.
Dessa Rose has received favorable criticism for its focus on the
role of both black and white women in the South. The discussions and friendship
between Dessa and Rufel is realistic and refreshing in its honesty and
tensions. Alice Walker praised the title as a rich and compelling work.
Williams reconstructs the past of women’s friendships across racial
lines.
Critics praised Williams’s work as a powerful story that is an authentic and
innovative portrayal of the American South before the Civil War. Particularly
strong, many note, is her depiction of antebellum society, especially
in regard to her portrayal of female slaves. Williams also effectively
develops a unique rhythm and sound in the dialect that she portrays among the
slave characters in particular.
Williams has been criticized for occasionally under-dramatizing key events and
for problems with pacing. The travels with the fugitive slaves and Rufel
take up a disproportionate part of the novel for the comparatively weak
emotional effect that it offers. It takes several scenes before the reader
experiences any tension for Dessa in her public life as a fugitive slave.
Additionally, some complain that plot elements that initially have an exciting
start end up languishing. At the end of Dessa Rose, there are repeated
references to the two women, Dessa and Rufel, and their joking about their
handling of Mr. Oscar.
Critics have also cited her Prologue as problematic. Williams answers William
Styron’s Confessions of Nat Turner by opening the novel with the
details of Dessa’s revolt through the character of Nehemiah. Wiliams puts
Dessa’s confession to more effective use than Styron had done with Nat Turner.
Williams’s development of Nehemiah’s character is skilled in that he falls in
love with Dessa over their interviewing. His character is complex and nuanced.
Nehemiah could never admit that this was happening. His behavior becomes a
bizarre obsession as he tracks her down at the end of the novel. The final
confrontation at the end is deeply disturbing. He loses control, which is a
strong theme in the novel. Critics have noted that his reappearance seems
contrived; however, his radical change in character is fitting with his long
absence in the novel.
Williams began writing Dessa Rose in 1982 and approached it by exploring the various relationships among women and men. The relationship between Nehemiah and Dessa is an unusual focus for a novel about slavery in the South. Williams stated that she struggled with the initial problem of how to tell this woman’s story. She needed to learn more information about the circumstances of a slave life in order to tell about it in first-person. Williams confesses that she had no trouble understanding the “uppity” Nehemiah. Williams attempts to be true to that tension between Nehemiah and Williams, and to the odd and unusual pairings in the novel as a whole.
Get Ahead with eNotes
Start your 48-hour free trial to access everything you need to rise to the top of the class. Enjoy expert answers and study guides ad-free and take your learning to the next level.
Already a member? Log in here.