Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

Hartmann von Aue was one of the foremost German poets of the Middle Ages, and he is known to have been admired by his contemporary Gottfried von Strassburg for the clarity and purity of his “crystalline words.” Beyond that encomium, information on Hartmann is limited to brief self-descriptions, as the one that begins Der arme Heinrich, in which he speaks of being a well-educated knight who can read several languages. It is known approximately when his works were written, but his birth and death dates are uncertain, as is the location of the “Aue” where he was born. Several different towns lay claim to him, all with some justification. As with most medieval works, the original manuscript of Der arme Heinrich has been lost, and the work survives in only three complete manuscripts from the fourteenth century. Manuscript A, the best, was destroyed in Strassburg in 1870 in the war between the Germans and the French. Manuscripts Ba and Bb, presumably copies of that source, are preserved in Heidelberg and Genf-Cologny, Hungary. There are also three fragments of the work, manuscripts C, D, and E (manuscript E, which contains verses 29 to 255, was discovered in 1965; its pages had been used to insulate organ pipes).

The reason for Hartmann’s emphasis in the opening lines on his ability to read is that medieval audiences were interested above all in authenticity. Many of the famous German epics, including Erek, Iwein, Parzifal, and Tristan, are reworkings of British Arthurian legends as presented to European audiences by the French poet Chrétien de Troyes, and Hartmann’s Gregorius is based on the Oedipus legend. Audiences first and foremost wanted to know the source of the story. It is all the more unusual, therefore, that no source has been found for the story of Der arme Heinrich. Since the main character, Heinrich, is said to come from the same “Aue” as the author, Hartmann, critics have speculated that Hartmann may have had a personal reason for writing this poem, namely to present in a positive light the marriage of one of his ancestors to a member of a lower class, a marriage that, without mitigating circumstances, would have defied the feudal class system. It is generally agreed that Der arme Heinrich is one of Hartmann’s later works, written when his reputation was sufficiently established to allow his departing from convention.

Heinrich’s sin, symbolically punished by the contraction of leprosy, is presumption, superbia. He believes that he deserves his health, wealth, and the...

(The entire section is 1060 words.)