A Death in the Family Critical Evaluation
by James Agee

Start Your Free Trial

Download A Death in the Family Study Guide

Subscribe Now

Critical Evaluation

(Critical Survey of Literature for Students)

The novel’s nostalgic evocation of an earlier, quiet time is set by “Knoxville: Summer 1915,” a poetic reminiscence James Agee wrote in 1936. It was selected by an editor to be a preface to the novel, which was not quite complete when Agee died. The preface re-creates childhood memories of the peaceful summer evenings of Agee’s middle-class Knoxville home as the women finish their kitchen work and the men, collars open and in shirtsleeves, watched by their children and older relatives, turned out to water their lawns. Such evenings are filled with shapes formed by spraying hoses, the sounds of nozzles being adjusted, and the recollections of the family, its work set aside momentarily, sitting outside on a quilt making small talk, watching the sky, waiting for the night to come. The preface closes with a life-affirming benediction: “May God bless my people, my uncle, my aunt, my mother, my good father, oh, remember them kindly in their time of trouble; and in the hour of their taking away.”

Cast as a novel, A Death in the Family is Agee’s long-planned autobiographical memorial to his father. The event that inspired the memorial was a simple one, though its consequences were not. Hugh James (Jay) Agee died in an automobile accident outside Knoxville, Tennessee, on May 18, 1916. Jay had been responding to an emergency call from a brother that their father was dying. The brother had been drinking and, ironically, there was no emergency, a situation made more poignant by the reader’s foreknowledge of what is to happen. Six-year-old Rufus, Jay’s son, whose childhood memories, dreams, and reconstructions inform the story, idolizes his father (rather than his mother, Mary) as the nurturing parent, the model around whom he senses his place in the world and the beginning of his own identity. His father’s death shatters the delicate balance and tranquillity of Rufus’s childhood, and, in fact, marked Agee for the remainder of his own rather brief life.

A 1958 Pulitzer Prize winner, Agee’s A Death in the Family is a touching and lyrical novel of domestic love. Combining strains that are romantic and modernist, it works at different levels around a number of important themes. Agee’s—Rufus’s—childhood love of his father, delicate and balanced but prone to damage by a wrong word or look on the part of those who compose Rufus’s world, provides the novel’s main theme. Agee’s story, however, goes beyond this theme.

Agee was a southern writer who could be associated with a particular southern locale and era. Within that framework he was also in many ways a southern traditionalist, although the novel’s abundant detail includes the depiction of sentiments and situations that are universal. Agee carefully documents the erosion of rural values among people like his father by Knoxville’s growing industrialization during the years of his childhood. The harsh noises of passing streetcars that make his little sister Catherine cry and the grinding, whirring metallic sounds of Jay cranking his Ford, a disturbance to family and neighborhood alike, are only two of many examples of this erosion that Agee sought to evoke.

The clash of rural and urban values is likewise played out within his parents’ mutual love. Jay remains countrified at heart while Mary, quite consciously, is an urban Catholic. Socially, Mary and her relatives look down on Jay. To be sure, Jay dominates his household, but he is oblivious to the price Mary pays in chagrin at his ways. Gentle enough, patient in his way, generous, hardworking, practical,...

(The entire section is 902 words.)